Verified Document

Comparative Textual Analysis Essay

War is always a collective historical event that survives in official government records and propaganda as well as mass media images and academic and popular writing. Of course, not all individual experiences can be captured by the collective memory, national consciousness and official interpretations of events, and in some cases governments and established elites attempt to censor and repress collective memory. With Hiroshima and Nagasaki, collective denial, cover ups and repression of public memories occurred for decades after the war, while many veterans who returned to Japan in 1945 were deeply dissatisfied by the official version of collective memory and sought to alter the national consciousness. In Black Rain, the family patriarch would also like to repress and deny the events of the recent past, but his niece and lover were so obviously victimized and damaged by the war that in the end he is simply unable to do so. During the Cold War, ruling elites in Germany, Japan and the U.S. all attempted to repress and alter the collective memory of the Second World War since they were now in an alliance against the Soviet Union, but this effort was only partially successful because too many personal and individual memories of profoundly damaging and disconcerting events still existed, both among soldiers and civilians. Black Rain (1989) was a nuclear film about a family of survivors of Hiroshima suffering from radiation sickness and all doomed to eventual death. Filmed in a documentary and cinema verite style, it resembled the real documentaries of Hiroshima and Nagasaki that were suppressed for decades after the war by the U.S. And Japanese governments as too graphic and upsetting for general audiences. Indeed, color footage of the aftermath of the bombings and the survivors sat in the faults of the Pentagon, classified top secret, until a...

In Hollywood, the actual bombings were not part of collective historical memory, either, but sublimated into film noir and science fiction, "where disintegration, invasion, violence, and secrecy are frequently associated with nuclear fear" (Cavanaugh 251). Japanese cinema also dealt with the subject obliquely and indirectly, such as films like Godzilla and other creature pictures in the 1950s and 1960s or in the postwar, post-apocalyptic Rashoman in 1951. Yet by the late-1980s, with the relaxation in Cold War tensions and renewed arms control discussions, Black Rain reflected a new confidence and openness about the hidden past in Japan, and became one of "the few films in Japan dealing with nuclear reality" (Cavanaugh 252). This had not been possible in 1966 when Ibuse Maiusi published the original novel by the same name in 1966, when the Cold War was at its height and Japan was firmly in place as a U.S. satellite.
Most of the film is set in 1950, with only brief flashbacks to life in Hiroshima to August 6, 1945, just before the atomic bomb was dropped. Shermayura Shigematsu is attempting to arrange a marriage for his niece Yasuko, whose three previous engagements have failed because she is terminally ill with radiation sickness. He knows this but is in denial about it at the same time, and almost to the end of the film, when she is clearly near death, he still imagines that she will be happily married and live on after him. Unlike the novel, in the movie Yasuko meets Yuichi, a former soldier still suffering from combat psychosis, and using his sculpture and street theater as a form of therapy. In contrast, Yasuko conceals her illness out of shame, even though her hair is falling out and she has to cover her lesions. Symbolically, she is a spiritually pure virgin but her "body is violated by radiation"…

Sources used in this document:
WORKS CITED

Cavanaugh, Carole, "A Working Ideology for Hiroshima: Imanura Shohel's Black Rain" in Dennis Washburn and Carole Cavanaugh (eds). Word and Image in Japanese Cinema. Cambridge University Press, 2001.

Sakai, Naoki. Translation and Subjectivity: On "Japan" and Cultural Nationalism. University of Minnesota Press, 1997.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Evaluating Data Analysis Software
Words: 516 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

Software Qualitative data is characterized by the deep, rich aspects that enable researchers to enter the realm of the participants in a study. Qualitative research projects are characterized by considerable coordination challenges and tight deadlines. Business clients of market research providers and academic research colleagues anticipate that the value qualitative researchers bring to inquiry is the ability to analyze and interpret, providing insights or contributions to themes. But often these

"Beyond: Two Souls" and "The Last of Us" Narrative Comparison
Words: 3495 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

Computer games have lamentably been kept to such niche, and exist under a false essence as being immature and a waste of time. While, beyond any doubt, there are in fact whimsical/childish computer games out there, that doesn't imply that there aren't mature, engaging and worthwhile video games out there; just because there are childish films and TV programs out there it does not detract from the more quality shows.

Quantitative Vs. Qualitative Research a Comparative Analysis
Words: 1649 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Quantitative vs. Qualitative Research A comparative analysis of quantitative and qualitative research designs In the conduct of sociological research, the qualitative and quantitative research designs remain the predominant structures in which scientific studies on social phenomena are discovered, analyzed, and interpreted. However, the emergence of quantitative research design prior to the development of the qualitative design created a dichotomy in the field of social science research, wherein preferences for each research design

Comparison of Poetry
Words: 2363 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

life William Blake's poem the Lamb, defining it as the divinity of creation. Furthermore looking at Wildred Owen's poem In Dulce et Decorum Est, with an argument that its' message is one that contradicts the generally held beliefs that it is noble and heroic to die for one's country. The paper illustrates this further using quotes form the poem. All is fair in love and War: the lamb and the

Tom Shulich "Coltishhum" a Comparative Study on
Words: 9196 Length: 20 Document Type: Chapter

Tom Shulich ("ColtishHum") A comparative study on the theme of fascination with and repulsion from Otherness in Song of Kali by Dan Simmons and in the City of Joy by Dominique Lapierre ABSRACT In this chapter, I examine similarities and differences between The City of Joy by Dominique Lapierre (1985) and Song of Kali by Dan Simmons (1985) with regard to the themes of the Western journalistic observer of the Oriental Other, and

Art Analysis: ART21 After Reviewing the Artists
Words: 968 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Art Analysis: Art21 After reviewing the artists from Art21, the artists chosen are Pierre Huyghe and AI Weiwei as the subjects of this paper. The pieces the paper will be "This is not a time for dreaming" by Huyghe and "Forever" by Weiwei. Both pieces are installation pieces although the artists are not classified under the same grouping on the Art21 website. Weiwei is listed as "Featured in Change" and Huyghe

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now