Verified Document

Companies Should Be Required To Provide Accurate CSR Reports Essay

Normativity and Legitimacy of CSR Disclosure: Evidence from France In this article (published in 2015) by Jean-Noel Chauvey and colleagues the theme is about companies in France following (or not following) laws about disclosure of corporate social responsibility. The law requires companies to give information to stakeholders on the environmental and social impacts of their activities. In 2001 France was one of the very few countries that passed a law requiring corporations to report their actions regarding corporate social responsibility (CSR). But by 2003, only 35% of French corporations were following the law completely. The article goes on to review the different levels of cooperation with the law; are corporations being honest and open -- or are they dishonest?

On page 791 the authors explain that "poor compliance" by companies could be explained because the law was too vague and it did not spell out punishment for corporations that didn't follow the law (Chauvey, 791). The authors explain that in trying to determine how good the CSR reporting has been, what is important is not just "how much" and "what" the companies are reporting, but the "quality of the information" is very important (Chauvey, 792). Chauvey and colleagues investigated the compliance of 120 companies in 2004, and of the 117 that did file a report, 26 did not provide any specific information on their CSR activities. So it is clear that not every company is following the law. The authors of this article gave a number grade to the CSR reports based on averaging the quality (or lack of quality) of what was reported. For example, when it comes to being able to verify what was reported, the 2004 reports only got a mean score of 2.21 (out of a possible 5); when it comes to environmental disclosures, the 2004 reports only got 2.42 (out of 5) (Chauvey, 797).

Regarding the CSR reports for the year 2010, they were better than the CSR reports from 2004, and by 2012 the CSR disclosures have become more complete but "quality remains low" (Chauvey, 800).

Effect of Financial Reporting Quality on Sustainability Information Disclosure

This article (Martinez-Ferrero and colleagues), is about companies' CSR reports (on social, environmental, and financial information). Many companies have caused problems for the planet...

There is a need for companies to produce financial reports, but those reports have had a "weakness" because they failed to provide important information about the social and environmental aspects of a company's behavior (Martinez-Ferrero, 2015). So, there needs to be more information than just finances; good CSR reports address a company's relations with suppliers, customers, and the workforce and those good reports should include information about "social contributions, public safety, (and) safety and health in the workplace" (Martinez-Ferrero, 46).
Meanwhile, the authors explain that those companies that provide "high quality financial information" tend to be more ethical (Martinez-Ferrero, 45). The companies with verifiable financial disclosures also seem to be more responsible when it comes to social issues. The article provides information on two theories that help to understand whether a company is providing an honest and complete CSR report. The Stakeholders Theory holds that the way in which a company "generates sustainable wealth is determined by their relations to different relevant groups of stakeholders" -- but not the society that they serve (Martinez-Ferrero, 47).

The Legitimacy Theory on the other hand links the social interests with business interest, which means this theory expects a company to think wider than just financial goals; this theory says that the interests of all, not just stakeholders, should be taken into consideration. In its conclusion, the article states again that companies that provide the highest quality of financial information are " ... less inclined to carry out unethical actions" and less apt to get involved in "EM" (earnings management, which means manipulating financial data through creative accounting procedures).

Effects of quality and corporate social responsibility on loyalty.

This article (by Chomvilailuk and Butcher) makes it clear that when a company (in this case, a bank in Australia) is socially responsible, and customers know it, it has "significant effects on purchase intention and positive word of mouth" (Chomvilailuk, 2014). This paper is in part about customer loyalty when it comes to perceptions of CSR by a bank; the CSR categories relating to…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Chauvey, J.N., Giordano-Spring, S., Cho, C.H., and Patten, D.M. (2015). The Normativity

And Legitimacy of CSR Disclosure: Evidence from France. Journal of Business Ethics,

Volume 130, 789-803.

Chomvilailuk, R., and Butcher, K. (2014). Effects of quality and corporate social responsibility on loyalty. The Service Industries Journal, 34(11), 938-954.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

CSR Corporate Social Responsibility CSR in This
Words: 2206 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

CSR Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) in this article discusses the fact that corporate responsibility is fledgling in protecting employees at Ealing Hospital. The case discusses instances when professionals lost their jobs when stepping forward to report others fur unethical conduct. There is evidence that the hospital has covered up several instances of fraud and attempted to remove those that reported wrongdoing. The Health Secretary, Stephen Dorrell has reported that an investigation

Positive Effects of CSR
Words: 4374 Length: 16 Document Type: Research Paper

Corporate social responsibility and business ethics have become the focus of an increasing amount of attention from the business sector and academicians following the scandal-ridden era of Enron and others during the 1990s. Although the findings from the research to date are mixed, there is a growing body of research in this area that has lent support to the notion that ethical business practices and corporate social responsibility initiatives have

Batesville Casket Company -- Case
Words: 1644 Length: 6 Document Type: Case Study

Fortunately, due to a dramatic reduction in the number of manufacturers since the 1950s, Batesville is well-equipped to remain the market leader. They kept pace with industry trends (e.g. In materials and style), and realized that it was necessary to retain loyalty from the Funeral Director side of the house in order to maintain share. Note below that while overall casket sales seem to be declining from the1 1970s, current

SCM Systems Importance for Competitive Advantage a Case Analysis...
Words: 7026 Length: 18 Document Type: Multiple Chapters

ERP related job? Analysis of responses received for How does your level of job difficulty compare after ERP to before ERP? Analysis of responses received for How many hours of training did you receive on ERP? Analysis of responses received for Which of the following processes does your job include? Analysis of responses received How valuable was your ERP training? Analysis of responses received Were you performing your current job prior to ERP? Analysis of responses received for How long were

Ethics, Corporate Governance and Company Social Responsibility
Words: 2447 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

Ethics, Corporate Governance and Company Social Responsibility Information that is essential to share includes financial performance, business strategy and overall company actions (Pfeffer, 1998). Sharing this information gives the employees the power to evaluate their performance and help them make the right decisions on how they can improve it. This is a simple and very straightforward practice but most companies are still apprehensive about this practice. One cause for this is

Apple Marketing Strategies and CSR
Words: 2587 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Corporate Responsibility and Marketing Strategies The ethical and social responsibilities lie at the forefront of any company's public image. That image is becoming increasingly more important to uphold as external pressures become more powerful. These ethical questions and challenges have to be faced every day. The issue of ethics is wide encompassing including all aspects of business from basic hiring of employees up to advertising claims. Companies rely on honest employees

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now