Verified Document

Colander, David. The Stories We Essay

This holds that as "aggregate expenditures increased, it brought about a supply response from firms who increased output" (Colander 1995, pp. 174-175). Regarding both curves, even on an intuitive level, wages and prices are not perfectly flexible in the real economy, particularly in regards to decreases in price level. Deflation has not happened on a significant level since the 1930s, but both classical and Keynesian economic theories allow for considerably greater potential for prices to fall than seems likely in fact (Colander 1995, pp. 174-177). The problem of how to teach introductory economics, according to Colander, is just as knotty as the problem posed by the as/AD curve itself. One solution, called the "pedagogy is dirty" solution, suggests that teachers simply assume that there is necessary simplification that must take place within the context of an undergraduate economics classroom, given the complexity of the material being taught (Colander 1995, p.179). However, learning an internally inconsistent model is more confusing for some students than learning a more complex model.

Another approach is to teach the models separately and 'banish' both into their respective categories of micro and macroeconomics (Colander 1995, p.180). Classical adherents say that 'macro' issues should not be part of a general principles class. Keynesian adherents advocate a return to stressing the Keynesian model alone. Colander states the Keynesian model over-emphasizes the impact and influence of fiscal policy in a way that is not coherent with today's economic realities (and thus shows his own bias in favor of the classical model).

Colander offers his own model to replace the current classical, Keynesian, or hybrid forms. In his model "the definition of the AD curve would be changed so that the AD curve would no longer be derived from the Keynesian AE/AP model. The shape of the AD curve would reflect only the direct effect of any combination of the Pigou effect, the Keynes effect, the international effect, and the intertemporal price level effect that one believes makes logical sense," without presupposing a multiplier effect (Colander 1995, p.180). "In...

Such discussions would be institutionally specific and open to discussion" (Colander 1995, p.181).
Towards the end of Colander's article, it gradually becomes clear that his intention is not merely to make economics more comprehensible and realistic for new students of the discipline, but to also advocate a particular point-of-view of the classical vs. Keynesian approaches. The intelligent classicist today, he says allows for muted multiplier effects but denies the government's ability to improve the situation with appropriate fiscal policy while the informed neo-Keynesian does believe that fiscal policy can improve the economy in a limited fashion. Of course, the 'good' modern Keynesian is less optimistic about the government's ability to remedy shifts in the business cycle with policy than the original Keynesian theorists. Given the bitterness of the current economic debate in the wake of the economic downturn, this analysis of different economic ideological camps seems no less simplistic or idealistic than the as/AD model Colander is attempting to criticize. Ultimately, Colander advocates teaching his own model as a solution to the problem of two competing approaches to dealing with economic problems. Perhaps the best solution of all is illustrated in Colander's show of bias -- like politics, economics is such a contentious discipline. Professors must accept there is no singular model, only different versions and opinions of how the economic world works. They should teach the most popular models (like the classical and Keynesian models) separately, rather than in conjunction, while still being mindful of highlighting these models' problems and the current debate as to which is superior. Teaching students of economics to deal with ambiguity is part of teaching them to understand the discipline.

Works Cited

Colander, David. The stories we tell: A reconsideration of as/AD analysis.

The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 9.3 (1995, Summer): 169-188.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Colander, David. The stories we tell: A reconsideration of as/AD analysis.

The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 9.3 (1995, Summer): 169-188.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Macroeconomics Government Borrowing Is Too High and
Words: 1262 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Macroeconomics Government borrowing is too high and interest rates are too low in many countries; fiscal stimulus does not work and cheap money leads only to inflation. Explain and discuss the various caveats of this macroeconomic problem and what policy measures will you suggest and Why if you are hired as a Junior Policy Advisor in an Advisory Board of Economists in one such country including Canada? Use economic theory, policy,

Macroeconomics Over the Last Several
Words: 1026 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Paper

This is problematic, because it allows government waste and inefficiency to increase, which this makes it more difficult to: fire or layoff non-essential employees. As a result, there has been a concentrated effort to eliminate this power, in order to improve the state's ability to adapt to shifts in the economy. (Weitzman) However, many of the public employee unions and liberal Democrats have been fighting this law. The reason why,

Macroeconomics the Ad-As Model Explains How Full
Words: 631 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Macroeconomics The AD-AS model explains how full employment can be reached from a situation of deep recession, assuming no fiscal policy stimulus. The underlying assumption of this theory is that when the economy improves, that this will have an impact on employment. The model therefore assumes a pre-globalization world where increases in aggregate supply on the part of companies in the U.S. will actually be made by U.S. workers. The thesis

Macroeconomics Models the Classical Model 1776-1935 the
Words: 3265 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

Macroeconomics Models The Classical Model (1776-1935) The classical model largely follows the conclusions reached in Microeconomics. The fundamental equilibrium is in the supply and demand for labor. The Demand for Labor and Labor Supply, Income Taxes, and Transfer Payments are the major microeconomic references in the Classic Economic Models (Hicks and Keynes, 1937). Keynesian Models (1936-1969) The simple keynesian model, a greatly oversimplified view of the economy, constructs an equilibrium without referring to the

Macroeconomics Why Is Economics Considered As a
Words: 611 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Macroeconomics Why is economics considered as a social science? What role does economics play in your personal and professional lives? Economics is considered as a social science because it deals with human behavior as to how individuals try to satisfy unlimited wants with the limited or scarce resources. (Sowell, 2010) Economics has a very important role in our lives, we may not realize it but any decision we take, anything we do, economics

Macroeconomics in This Case, There Are a
Words: 700 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Macroeconomics In this case, there are a number of monetary policy prescriptions that apply, all of them expansionary. In terms of open market operations, the Fed should buy Treasuries. This will pump money into the banking system, providing greater means for investment. This will provide the groundwork for economic growth, in particular it will signal that the Federal Reserve is committed to restoring economic growth and halting the growth in unemployment.

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now