Verified Document

Cognitions Pertaining To Illness Essay

Related Topics:

Cognitions Pertaining to Illness The role of risk estimates in preventive behaviour

The hypothesis that was formulated by Students X and Y can best be confirmed or refuted, at least generally, by asking the Likert-scaled questions, "How likely do you think it is that you will develop liver disease in future?" At the same time as they ask the question, "How much alcohol do you drink in the average week?" The superiority of this single approach to posing both questions to the respondents relates primarily to the efficiency of the survey administration and the reliability of the results that emerge. A delay of 4 months between posing these survey questions to all of their subjects would introduce a number of significant constraints to this study that could potentially adversely affect the ability of these researchers to accurately evaluate any responses they received.

First and foremost, 4 months is a prohibitively long time and it is reasonable to suggest that many of the same respondents may not be available for the subsequent survey administration, making Student X's recommendation to ask both questions at the same time a legitimate and viable alternative. Second, 4 months is an arbitrary period of time that does not appear to be based on any corresponding supporting rationale, only the fact that it apparently sounded like a reasonable amount of time to allow to elapse to Student Y.

It is important to note, though, that the recommendation by Student Y to ask the two questions 4 months apart, though, may have some merit as well. For instance, by introducing a lengthy delay between asking these questions, respondents may help provide additional insights concerning the relationship between the respondents' beliefs about acquiring a disease and one of the factors that can precipitate it.

A superior solution would be to administer the survey with both questions to one-half of the respondents at the same time and introduce the 4-month delay in asking the second question for the other one-half and compare the results...

Any statistically significant differences in the responses may point to cognitive processes that occurred during the 4-month interval concerning the respondents' perceptions about how much they drank and its potential connection to the disease they had been asked about initially.
Respondents asked the first question only and then provided with a 4-month period in which to think about it might well modify their drinking behaviors, even subconsciously, to the extent that they will be able to truthfully answer that they are drinking less to conform to their original speculation about the likelihood of their developing liver disease. By contrast, the respondents who are compelled to answer both questions at the same time might try to diminish the perceived risk of developing liver, at least from an emotional point-of-view, by falsifying or hedging their answers to indicate they drink less alcohol on a regular basis than they do in reality. Therefore, perhaps the superior alternative to all of the foregoing research approaches would be to ask the respondents both questions at the same time and then survey them again later (this delay could be 4 months or more) with both questions to determine if completing the first survey and learning about the potential for their behaviors to cause liver disease affected their drinking behaviors in substantive ways.

Part B: Variables affecting judgments of disease seriousness

Main strengths of the study

The researchers had a respectable sample size (n=60) of subjects (the researchers eliminated four respondents from the data analysis due to the weaknesses or limitations described below) and they developed an innovative approach to assessing perceived prevalence of a disease by manipulating the respondents' personal relevance.

Weaknesses or limitations of the study

The major weakness of this study was that the researchers were entirely duplicitous from outset in ways that may…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Treatment of Women Diagnosed With
Words: 13264 Length: 48 Document Type: Term Paper

At one point or another in our lives, we are all beginners. We begin college, a first job, a first love affair, and perhaps a first dissertation project. We bring a great deal to these new situations, including our temperament, previous education, and family situations. Yet, as adults, we also learn. In romantic relationships, couples report having to learn how to interact successfully with their partners. College students routinely report

Neurological Disorder Epilepsy Neurological Disorder Epilepsy --
Words: 2610 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Neurological Disorder Epilepsy Neurological Disorder Epilepsy -- a Neurological Disorder Epilepsy is a neurological disorder which causes frequent seizures due to abnormal electricity activity within the brain. Epilepsy is considered a brain disorder disturbing the brain function which ultimately affects behaviour and cognition. This paper highlights some common symptoms of epilepsy. It also explains different treatments deployed for reducing seizure activity in epilepsy. Each treatment portrays a different way of taking control over

Psychology Sensation and Perception Work
Words: 3036 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

These memories have happened in the external world and they are remembered based on what has been experienced before (Explicit Memory Storage, 2004). Semantic memory is memory that is based on a person's knowledge. This knowledge can be factual or theoretical (Semantic v Episodic Memory, 2004). Some examples of semantic memory might be that a person knows what kind of dog they are looking at or they know their friend's

Participant's Experience: A Qualitative Research Reflecting How
Words: 2610 Length: 9 Document Type: Research Paper

Participant's Experience: A Qualitative Research Reflecting How to Prevent Eating Disorders in Order to Support Current Patients This article aims to present a qualitative research of one woman's experience of anorexia, a kind of eating disorder, using interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA). The details of the women's personal experience of anorexia supposed to be unique, but the general outline is as common as on other patients. The delay of correct medical

Performance and Social Responsibility
Words: 2734 Length: 8 Document Type: Capstone Project

nurses play a very important role in the emotional, spiritual, and physical care of the patient with different illness. When it comes to nursing homes, nurses are responsible for the well-being of the individuals there. Even though majority of the persons there are not critically there, they still depend on nurses for their care both medically and emotionally. Sanghine (2013) reported that two nursing home nurses managed to turn off

Munchausen's Syndrome Is There a
Words: 1941 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

1529). Linked to but separate from attachment theory, cognitive theories focus on identifying deficient or distorted cognitive structures and processes that may contribute to a disorder (Mash & Barkley, 2003). Taken together, the foregoing findings suggest that both attachment theory and cognitive theory could be used to help identify internal and external factors that may contribute to the development of Munchausen's syndrome. References Buchanan, G.M. & Seligman, M.E.P. (1995). Explanatory style.

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now