Verified Document

Code Of Ethics Term Paper

¶ … grey areas associated with medical ethics is that executive personnel in the medical community are not always subject to the same rigorous ethical codes that other workers in the field are. Arthur Lazarus notes, "American Medical Association (AMA) Principles of Medical Ethics provides norms for treating patients, but provides little guidance for physician executives in terms of helping their organizations comply with legal and regulatory requirements, avoiding litigation, improving productivity and quality and building organizational trust and integrity." This is particularly true regarding executive practitioners in nontraditional medical fields and private practice. Fundamentally, the wide variety of organizational settings in modern medicine can generate an atmosphere where the straightforward application of any single code of ethics is simply not possible. Additionally, modern ethical codes need "to reflect the medical technology industry's unique relationships with health care professionals."

So, while the doctrines set forward by the AMA, American Psychiatric Association, American Association of Psychiatric Administrators, American College of Healthcare Executives, and the American Academy of Pharmaceutical Physicians all provide detailed and useful guidelines for ethical conduct in the actual administration of medicine, broader social and moral conflicts can arise in which medical executives are forced to make difficult decisions.

Lazarus, a psychiatrist employed in the pharmaceutical industry, finds that all of these ethical codes could potentially apply to his practice. He writes that "many pharmaceutical physicians adhere to the AAPP code of ethics, which basically guides ethical decision making related to patients (subjects) in clinical trials, but not to patients seen in clinical practice."

However, this code is far from comprehensive with reference for to psychiatrics in managed care positions. Overall, the conflicts that exist between existing codes of ethics when it is unclear as to whether one or another should be applied undermines the validity of all the major ethical standards in medicine.

One problem has arisen...

The problem was that the APA standards were set before the era of managed care; accordingly, the application of the APA code of ethics to these particular psychiatrists was utterly ambiguous. Psychiatrists in managed care essentially need to conduct insurance reviews for their practices to function properly, but from the perspective of the APA this was a grievous breech of medical ethics. Eventually, "The psychiatrists were exonerated, and later an addendum to the APA's code of ethics was incorporated to clarify existing standards for psychiatrists practicing in 'organized settings.'"
The APA's central goal is to set forward a code of ethics that is capable of providing the best possible care for the patient. Consequently, the addendum that addressed this specific issue fell in line with this approach:

A psychiatrist shall not conduct reviews or participate in reviews in a manner likely to demean the dignity of the patient by asking for highly personal material not necessary for the conduct of the review. A reviewing psychiatrist shall strive as hard for a patient he or she reviews as for one he or she treats to prevent the disclosure of sensitive patient material to anyone other than for clear, clinical necessity.

Although this statement is relatively linear in its reasoning, it is also exceedingly vague; it leaves the ethical choices purely in the hands of each individual practitioner's judgment. In other words, it is not altogether obvious just what manner of reviews is likely to demean the dignity of any given patient. Certainly, it must be associated with the intimate nature of the information that is required and balancing this against information which might not be as pertinent. However, exactly where the line is drawn is wholly up to the one conducting the review, and again, rests within the bounds of their own judgment.

So, the intended ethical principle that the American Psychiatric Association adheres to is fairly plain: the best possible care for the…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited:

1. American Psychiatric Association. (2001). "The Principles of Medical Ethics with Annotations Especially Applicable to Psychiatry." American Psychiatric Association: http://www.psych.org/psych_pract/ethics/ppaethics.cfm.

2. Childs, Blair. (2005). "Decoding the Different Ethical Codes and Guidance." Journal of Health Care Compliance. Frederick: Jan/Feb. Vol. 7, Iss. 1.

3. Lazarus, Arthur. (2004). "The Moral Obligations of Physician Executives." Physician Executive, Tampa: Nov/Dec. Vol. 30, Iss. 6.

Lazarus, Arthur. (2004). "The Moral Obligations of Physician Executives." Physician Executive, Tampa: Nov/Dec. Vol. 30, Iss. 6. Page, 40.
American Psychiatric Association. (2001). "The Principles of Medical Ethics with Annotations-Especially Applicable to Psychiatry." American Psychiatric Association: http://www.psych.org/psych_pract/ethics/ppaethics.cfm.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Starbucks Evaluation a Business Code Ethics the
Words: 1662 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

STARBUCKS Evaluation a Business Code Ethics the purpose assignment assist refining problem-solving capabilities organizations possesses business ethics applications. This paper a structured, objective format called a system inquiry. Starbucks code of ethics Starbucks' mission The Starbucks Corporation has its origins in a small chain of coffee stores that was designed to replicate the European coffeehouse experience for American consumers. At the time of its birth in Seattle, most Americans' experience of coffee was confined

Code of Ethics Critically Analyse Australian Association
Words: 664 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Code of Ethics "Critically analyse Australian Association Social Worker's Code Ethics (2010), reference utility guiding promoting high quality ethical practice working Aboriginal Torres Straight Islander people. Critically analyse the Australian Association of Social Worker's Code of Ethics (2010), with particular reference to its utility for guiding and promoting high quality ethical practice when working with Aboriginal and Torres Straight Islander people. The Australian Association of Social Worker's Code of Ethics (2010) is designed

Code of Conduct and Ethics for It Professionals
Words: 2258 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

It Professional Code of Conduct and Ethics The objective of this work in writing is to examine the code of conduct and ethics for Internet Technology (IT) professionals. Towards this end this study will examine the literature in this area of study. Defining the IT Professional There is no one set definition for the IT professional however, an IT professional is a professional that works with information technology including installation, implementation, servicing, training,

Code of Effects in Counseling
Words: 3060 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

Ethics for Counselors: Two Case Vignettes Case 1: What are the issues John is facing? What would an ethical counselor do?  John is facing a serious issue of confidentiality. Nilusha is a minor who has admitted to drug use to John. It is not minor drug use either—but weekly use of cocaine and methamphetamines. This is a serious issue that has to be addressed. When Nilusha’s parents call to ask what is

Code of Ethics Core Values My Core
Words: 1365 Length: 4 Document Type: Case Study

Code of Ethics Core values My core ethical value can best be summed up as follows: 'always put yourself in the other person's shoes.' I consider this to be a modified version of the Golden Rule of 'do unto others as you would have done unto you.' The Golden Rule suggests that you should treat other people as you would like to be treated. In my version, I have modified this dictum

Ethics in a Computerized Society
Words: 2132 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

This may be done without the consent of the owner of the information thus also infringing on their right to privacy. Education has also been revolutionized greatly by technology. As a result of technological advancements it is now possible for teachers and students to communicate over thousands of miles. Instructors are also able to give assignments which students can submit despite the distance. In this way, technology has enabled global

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now