Verified Document

Closing Argument For Murder Trial Of Ned Kelly Essay

Closing Argument A modern-day reenactment: the murder trial of Ned Kelly

This is the story of a courageous hero. A valiant leader and bold luminary, who was not afraid to stand up for justice. It's the story of a man who was not afraid to stand up for his family and his community, and fight to defend against an oppressive government and a corrupt and violent police force.

This brave man is Ned Kelly. And it is precisely because of his strong sense of justice and leadership ability that made him a target of the police and government.

We've seen that the police would resort to uncivilized violence for the sake of maintaining order in a rigged system, that reduced the Irish Catholics of this country to poor, 2nd class citizens. The police were blindly carrying out the British government's system, which relegated the Irish Catholics to permanent inferior status. It was a system that enforced British national superiority.

But Ned was not one to passively accept this kind of inequality. And that's what turned him into an enemy in the eyes of the government.

Ladies and gentlemen, Ned Kelly is innocent. He sits before you here today, not because of any true malice or evil that he actually harbored. He sits before you on trial for simply exercising his right of self-defense against ongoing and repeated violent and aggressive police attacks on him and his family.

The Real Story of this Trial

Let's recap the evidence presented to you in today's trial, starting from the beginning. Ned comes from a proud Irish Catholic family who always resented the culture of control...

Ned and his friends challenged corrupt police, greedy land barons and the wealthy establishment in a quest to reform society for the better.
That's why the constables despised him. So they hunted him down, repeatedly harassed him, and falsely accused him of wrongdoing. They arrested his mother and friends only to intimidate him. They arrested Ned himself based on invented stories of stolen horses or being drunk in public. The police came to his house and instigated deadly shootouts with Ned and his friends. You heard evidence of one constable, Fitzpatrick, really had it out for Ned. He sexually assaulted Ned's sister and then spread a false rumor that Ned had attacked him.

In spite of such mistreatment by the police, the testimony you've heard here has demonstrated that Ned has a solid character. He was extremely loyal to his family, friends, and supporters. He was intelligent and articulate, and attempted to advocate for independence and dignity for his people by writing numerous editorials and letters. Yet the British-controlled newspapers refused to publish Ned's writings. Ned and his crew might have held up two British-run towns and robbed British banks, but they did so without firing a single shot. Moreover, Ned wrote numerous essays owning up to this disobedience -- he never tried to run and hide. In these letters that were ignored by the press, Ned explained that his actions were part of a larger moral movement for independence.

You saw an example of Ned's writings in his Jerilderie letter of February 10, 1879, wherein he demanded equal treatment. You'll have a chance to review that letter again in your deliberations. That letter was just one of countless examples of Ned's intelligent and civilized efforts to voice opposition to the inequalities of the British system. Ned was not alone -- his letters reflected the sentiments of countless followers. Unfortunately, rather than cooperating with Ned and his followers, the police reacted to the Jerilderie letter with even harsher and more vicious militaristic tactics.

These aggressive police approaches are part of the reason Ned became an outlaw. But it's also why he…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Argumentative
Words: 619 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay Titles

Introduction The best argumentative essay titles reveal the nature of the argument and suggest the position that you will be taking as the author of the argument.  Since every argument has at least two sides to it, your essay title should point out these two sides.  Then it should identify the side you think makes the most sense, i.e., the correct position to take.  One of the easiest ways to do

Argument Analysis of the Cohabitation Epidemic
Words: 764 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Cohabitation Epidemic Argument Analysis" "The Cohabitation Epidemic" In "The Cohabitation Epidemic," Neil Clark Warren argues that cohabitation between unmarried couples is an unhealthy situation that is decreasing the livelihood and well being of people in the contemporary context. Warren's argument is based on the idea that [state here the most important premises or assumption of the argument, or the basic strategy of his argument]. More specifically, in a part of his argument

Argument Analysis Applied to Homeland Security
Words: 935 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Privacy, Security, Whistleblowing [Surveillance is a necessary evil to prevent terrorist attacks from happening.]A [For example, the secret "PRISM" effort saved New York City's subways from a 2009 terrorist plot led by a young Afghan-American, Najibullah Zazi.] A = Main Argument Surveillance is a necessary evil to prevent terrorist attacks B = Level The secret PRISM effort saved New York City's subways in 2009 from a terrorist plot. Claim B. is Level 1 and supports Argument

Arguments Between the Obama Administration and Congress on Immigration...
Words: 958 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Immigration between the Obama Administration and Congress: United States immigration policy has been an issue of major political debates and controversies for several decades. The controversy surrounding the nation's immigration policy is partly because policymakers are increasingly considering the need to maintain global competitiveness through attracting top overseas talent against the need to curtail illegal immigration and secure the country's borders (Lee par, 1). In the past few years, the

Arguments For and Against Birth Control
Words: 801 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

This choice gives them the ample time to balance their social life with the economic endeavors hence not remaining economically disadvantaged and dependent on men due to childbearing. The social independence and economic stability will also lead to better health for the mothers and the population at large. Hence, it is significant to note that the birth control aspect is a thing that starts from personal level but affects

Argumentative Response to Homosexuality and Marriage
Words: 1842 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Homosexuality and Marriage Argumentative Response Controversial debates have been on the rise on whether gay marriages should be allowed in the society. Marriage is a key institution in the society. There are many reasons for marriage that may not apply to homosexuals. Gay marriages should not be allowed because marriage is traditional and morally for heterosexuals. This will cause a lot of chaos in the society, which will destroy the institution of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now