Verified Document

Clinical Staging Of Psychiatric Disorders Essay

¶ … DSM diagnostic criteria have long been a source of criticism. McGorry, Hickie, Yung, Pantelis, and Jackson (2006) point out some basic deficiencies of the DSM diagnostic system. First the authors state that the function of a diagnosis is to state what treatment should be applied or predict the prognosis of the condition. These are certainly functions of a diagnosis, but a diagnosis has broader implications. First and foremost the idea of having a diagnosis is to take a series of related signs and symptoms that hang together consistently and label them so as to facilitate communication between health care professionals. A diagnosis alone is useless unless it allows professionals to communicate about the same entity. Then descriptions of course, treatment, and prognosis can follow. McGorry et al. charge that in the DSM system the clinical features that occur early in the course of the disorder are not distinguished from those that occur later and that treatment is more effective early in the disorder. The goal of the DSM diagnostic criteria has always been on reliability, which sets the upper limit for validity but does not ensure validity. McGorry are concerned with a valid diagnostic method which can assist in more effective treatment. They support a clinical staging approach that is allegedly a more refined form of diagnosis than the DSM classification system. Clinical staging differs from the traditional DSM diagnostic practice in that instead of looking at a bunch of co-occurring symptoms and fitting them into a diagnosis it attempts to define the extent of progression of a disease at the time of the assessment. Clinical staging stresses that greater emphasis be placed on a description of where the patient lies on the continuum of the course of the particular illness, from early to late in its course. Clinical staging has been successfully applied to several different physical diseases; most successful applications have been to different types of cancers. McGorry et al. state that this method...

In other medical conditions clinical the clinical stages are defined by biological markers and their impact on the patient. McGorry et al. present a proposed table for the clinical staging of psychotic disorders and severe mood disorders. In the McGorry scheme social markers are also present, but these "objective" staging criteria which include GAF scores and other staging criteria that are more subjective than objective.
There are numerous issues with this approach. First, and the main problem here, is that there are no universal recognized clinicopathological signs for the vast majority of disorders described in the DSM system. McGorry et al. describe the results of studies that indicate that lower hippocampal volumes are found in the brains of severely depressed people and schizophrenics, lower frontal cortex volumes in schizophrenics, etc. But what the researchers fail to mention is that not a single one of these markers is pathonomonic of any disorder. In fact, even such taken-for-granted psychological markers like lower Serotonin levels have never been empirically demonstrated in sufferers of clinical depression, even though psychiatry still purports this as a cause of depression (Kirsch, 2010). Psychiatric disorders are not like physical diseases such as cancer that have a well-defined clinicopathological progression. Moreover, McGorry et al. fail to mention either by intent or ignorance that many of these neuro-findings in psychiatric populations occur only in patients who have taken psychiatric medications for a substantial period and it may be the medication that is responsible for the "marker" (Kirsch, 2010). There are no pathonomonic physical markers for the majority of disorders in the DSM. There are no blood tests or clinical medical tests that can diagnose psychiatric disorders. Clinical staging is aimed at physical diseases like cancer and of course the psychiatrists have long tried to classify DSM disorders in this…

Sources used in this document:
References

Fava G.A. & Kellner, R. (1993). Staging: a neglected dimension in psychiatric classification. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 87, 555-558.

Fava, G.A. & Tossani, E. (2007). Prodromal stage of major depression. Early Intervention in Psychiatry, 1, 9-18.

Hetrick, S.E., Parker, A.G., Hickie, I.B., Purcell, R., Yung, A.R., & McGorry, P.D. (2008).

Early identification and intervention in depressive disorders: Towards a clinical staging model. Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 77, 263-270.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Assessment of the Mental Health of Psychiatric Patient Monique
Words: 1976 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Chronic Fatigue Syndrome -- A Case Study Case study 'Monique.' Case presentation and history Monique, a female aged 30, possesses a history of depression and chronic fatigue syndrome, starting at the age of 16 to 17, together with suicide attempts (entailing overdosing), in addition to a long record of anxiety. During baseline evaluation, she reported continuous constant fatigue as well as anhedonia. She also expressed dense retrograde amnesia following a 12-week program of

Disorders and How It Affects Older Adults
Words: 4151 Length: 14 Document Type: Term Paper

Disorders in Older People Alzheimer's and Eating Disorders and how they affect Older Adults Alzheimer's and Eating Disorders and how they affect Older Adults Disorders in Older People Alzheimer's-Type Dementia Eating Disorders Disorders in Older People In considering the general health of the population, the larger elderly population does not necessarily imply that most of them live or are ill from severe disabilities. Age related disorders would occur to different people early or late in their lives.

Etiology and Treatment of a Psychological Disorder
Words: 2917 Length: 9 Document Type: Essay

Individual Programmatic Assessment TREATMENTS OPTIONS FOR IRREGULAR SLEEP-WAKE SYNDROME Irregular Sleep-Wake Syndrome is a form of a psychological disorder also called Irregular Sleep-Wake Rhythm. People with Irregular Sleep-Wake Syndrome have non-aligned sleep times. These people have sleeping patterns that do not adhere to the "normal" times of sleeping at night. The sleeping patterns are disorganized to a magnitude that one cannot tell the presence of a clear sleep or wake pattern. Such

Diagnosis of Cancer There Is
Words: 1108 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

He may also be humiliated by his having the disease or may be avoided by others who do not know how to approach the patient or are discomfited by doing so, particularly since cancer indicates mortality and mortality is one aspect of life's facts that individuals generally like to avoid. Other feelings of inferiority and shame are caused by loss of autonomy and independence, vulnerability, and mutilation and most frightening

Cancer Care Knowing More About Cancer Approach
Words: 1586 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Cancer Care KNOWING MORE ABOUT CANCER Approach to the Care of Cancer The integrative approach to cancer treatment is the most widely used by cancer patients today as it is the most comprehensive (Nelson, 2011). It is the method used by integrative oncology, which combines complementary therapeutic approaches and conventional therapies. As a combination, the integrated approach covers natural and botanical products, nutrition, acupuncture, traditional Chinese medicine and mind-body therapies. It fits together

Social Work Approach to Bipolar
Words: 2552 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Client is an African-American male, age 19, diagnosed with Bipolar Disorder 1 (296.89), with mixed and psychotic features. Lability and mood cycles have become more rapid recently. Currently, the client is experiencing an acute but mild manic episode. Risk Influences The client has no significant biological issues. As the first in his family known to have Bipolar Disorder, no genetic component to the disorder has been determined, but further work in a

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now