Verified Document

Client Representation: Ethics Essay

Ethics: Client Representation Ethics

Ethics is the study of the rightness or wrongness of human actions, based on what society has identified as its moral values. Individuals are expected to observe ethical standards in their daily interactions as a way of preventing conflict and maintaining peace. For this reason, philosophers have focused on developing ethical theories to guide individuals towards making moral decisions. This text assesses these theories to determine how they inform the decision-making process.

The Situation

One of your clients is accused of murdering her husband and she, as a result, faces the death penalty. An eyewitness has wrongly identified her as the killer, but she maintains that she was in an out-of-town hotel at the supposed time. However, there is no evidence of the same as she paid the hotel fee in cash, received no official receipt, did not sign the hotel register, and the clerk does not remember seeing her. You are sure that she is innocent, and the only way to get her acquitted is to forge her signature on the customer register at the hotel. Acting on instinct, you do it, and then present the register with the forged signature as evidence in court.

This text assesses how theory influenced this decision, and how it would change if different theories are considered.

Teleological Theories

These are theories that judge the rightness or wrongness of an action based on its consequences (Peterson, 2013). They two most common teleological theories are egoism and utilitarianism

i) Egoism: egoism advocates for...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

It evaluates the morality of an action based on the degree to which it maximizes the decision maker's physical, emotional, or psychological well-being (Peterson, 2013). In this case, egoism would push the decision-maker to forge the client's signature not because he believes that she is innocent, but because winning the case would give them personal satisfaction, build their reputation, and perhaps bring in more clients. A person guided by egoism would, therefore, forge the signature regardless of who the client is, and whether or not they are innocent.
ii) Utilitarianism: utilitarianism judges an action as right or wrong based on the number of people who are likely to benefit from the resultant outcome(s). It advocates for the greater good, and urges individuals to always settle for the option that benefits a greater number of people (Peterson, 2013). From a utilitarian perspective, therefore, the decision to forge the client's signature would be considered ethical because it gives the authorities reason to go after the real murderer, thereby saving hundreds of innocent people in that neighborhood from meeting the same fate. If the signature were not forged, an innocent person would have been jailed, and the perpetrator would still be at large, posing danger to more citizens. From a utilitarian standpoint, therefore, the community is the greatest beneficiary of the decision-makers 'unethical' action.

Deontological Ethics

Deontology judges an action as right or wrong based on its adherence to rules or moral norms. It requires people to always choose actions because they are right and not because they are good or reasonable. It is based on i) Kant's categorical imperative, which requires people to only act in such a way that that they would will the same to be accepted as universal law (Carroll & Buchholtz, 2008; and ii) the 'Golden Rule', which is more or less the same in every religion, requiring individuals to always do unto others what they would want to be done to them in return (Currie, 2004). Towards this end, deontology would forbid the forging of the client's signature not only because society's norms forbid the same, but also because no rational person would wish that everyone be allowed to forge others' signatures whenever it suits them. If the decision-maker…

Sources used in this document:
References

Carroll, A. & Buchholtz, A. (2008). Business and Society: Ethics and Stakeholder Management (7th ed.). Mason, OH: Cengage Learning

Currie, R. (2004). The Golden Rule -- the Same in All Religions? Compass Distributors. Retrieved 27 March 2015 from http://www.compassdistributors.ca/topics/golden.htm

Peterson, M. (2013). The Dimensions of Consequentialism: Ethics, Equality and Risk. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Virtue Ethics
Words: 1316 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Virtue Ethics: The Good and the Bad About Virtue Ethics The philosophy of virtue ethics holds that being a 'good person' or what one might call 'character' is the most important determinant of moral action. Virtue ethics is considered to be one of the major philosophical orientations in the field of normative ethics, along with consequentialism and deontology (Hursthouse 2010). Many consider it to be the oldest form of ethics, harkening

Virtue Ethics
Words: 1385 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Virtue Ethics Virtue-based vs. duty-based ethics: arguments and examples from Victor Hugo, Aristotle, Bernard Mayo, Nathaniel Hawthorne, and William Frankena In the study of ethics and morality, there have been theoretical foundations in which it was argued that morality comes with being rather than doing, or that a true moral life is one that is a product of doing instead of being. Or, oftentimes, theoreticians and philosophers contend that morality must bear

Virtue Ethics
Words: 712 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Virtue Ethics and reasoning for the scenario Virtue ethics is the ethical strategy preferred. Efficient leaders and true professionals strive at achieving moral excellence which encompasses integrity, justice, valor and good sense. In the present day, virtue ethics constitutes one among the three key normative ethics strategies. Primarily, it can be considered a strategy which stresses moral fiber or virtues, contrary to consequentialism (which focuses on the consequences one’s actions have)

Virtue Ethics Over the Centuries
Words: 1833 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

This will allow someone to move beyond the different emotions, so that they can be able to see how the different actions will affect the world around them. Despite some of the obvious weaknesses, you can be able to determine the most appropriate course of action, by asking questions and gaining more information. Once this achieved, you will have a greater sense of enlightenment, because you were able to

Virtue Ethics' Refers to the
Words: 926 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

The question here arises, why did we have to return to ancient philosophy of virtue ethics? But interestingly while a great deal of credit is given to Aristotle and Plato, the modern moral philosophers such as Anscombe, Foot, Murdoch, Slote had mentioned in very precise terms the problems they found in Aristotelian ethics. They must have absorbed the writings of ancient philosophers since a lot is said about the moral

Virtue Ethics Virtue Theory, Utilitarianism,
Words: 716 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Deontological ethics are based on other theories that focus on duty and obligation. Immanuel Kant (1785) argued that an individual should "always act in such a way that you can also will that the maxim of your action become universal law" (p. v). It can be argued that Kant's arguments are echoed in a quote often attributed to Ghandi, "Be the change you want to see in the world"

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now