Verified Document

Clauswitz At The End Of Chapter One, Essay

Clauswitz At the end of Chapter One, Book One of On War, Carl von Clausewitz famously gives his "paradoxical trinity" in regard to the nature of the forces arrayed against each other in war. He tells us war is a "total phenomenon" in which there are three "dominant tendencies" that characterize the nature of warfare, and that any theory of war which neglects or ignores any of these tendencies would both "conflict with reality" and thus be "totally useless."[footnoteRef:1] These three tendencies are so intertwined that they act like "three different codes of law, deep rooted in their subject and yet variable in their relationship with one another;" that is, each of the three tendencies is variable in its operative force, and the strength of each strand dominates or is diminished in any given particular case, but nevertheless, each magnet is still intimately involved in a given war or engagement.[footnoteRef:2] Clausewitz's formulation may in fact be useful when analyzing a particular conflict, as his framework for understanding can shed light on why certain strategies and tactics seem to be consistently successful (or consistently tragic, as the case may be) and can be improved upon or understood by succeeding generations. With this in mind, this paper will use Clausewitz's rubric in considering the factors that contributed to Admiral Lord Nelson's victory at the Battle of Trafalgar. The analysis of the battle of Trafalgar will be placed in the discussion of Clausewitz's three "magnets," with the emphasis on what I believe to be the dominant strand in this battle. [1: Carl von Clausewitz, Michael Howard and Peter Paret, trans., On War, (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1976), 89.] [2: Ibid.]

At the end of the first chapter of the first book of On War, Clausewitz gives the reader what he believes are the three main theoretical tendencies found in warfare. The first tendency concerns the various peoples involved in any given conflict. He calls the emotions found on the part of the warring polities a "blind natural force," in which the dominant...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

Though the British revolution was over a century old, its polity emerged from the nonviolent "Glorious Revolution" with a government that was more republican than monarchical, and in which it was defined by more democratic practice and freedom than the nation had previously seen. The freedom of action that Nelson displayed at Trafalgar is indicative of the political freedom (i.e. decision making) found by citizens in republican polities. Furthermore, the British people were on the defensive against a possible French invasion and they were additionally supported in their "passions" by their historical enmity with France. In the case of the recent French Revolution, the French people emerged from a revolution that was violent and exhausting, and by the time of the Battle of Trafalgar, the spirit of the French polity, though excited by their two-year-old war for empire, found its fleet's sailors tired and diminished from engagements during and following the revolution. The French people, despite the Revolution, had a history of servitude under a monarchy (and now under Napoleon Bonaparte) and were more used to being "directed" by the government rather than "directing" the government as in a republic, so the motion of the French polity could be considered as "directed" by the government -- here we have the example of two peoples engaged in war where each social body was animated by two different "spirits." [3: Ibid.]
It is in Clausewitz's next principle where we find the dominant strand operative at the Battle…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Napoleon Bonaparte the Cultural Legacy
Words: 1522 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

This code sprang directly from the Napoleon's exposure to Enlightenment philosophy, whose central premise was that reason alone should dictate the rule of man. In his code, Napoleon attempted to create a rule of law dictated entirely by his principle that government should be nothing more than "the application of common sense" (Schom 290). The code spelled out rights to personal safety and property, contract procedures and obligations, even

Napoleon Bonaparte by J.M. Thompson the Book
Words: 591 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Napoleon Bonaparte" by J.M. Thompson The book entitled "Napoleon Bonaparte" by J.M. Thompson is a biographical and detailed account on the life of Napoleon Bonaparte from childhood until his last days as an exiled citizen in St. Helena and eventual death. The book is chronologically divided into important places wherein Bonaparte had influenced the society with his control and leadership and military power. Thompson's discussion of Bonaparte's life is map-like:

Analyzing Successes and Failures of Napoleon Bonaparte
Words: 2522 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

Successes and Failures of Napoleon Bonaparte Napoleon Bonaparte was the most successful leader of his era. His life consisted of many accomplishments followed by a few failures. Napoleon was born on 15 August 1979 in Ajaccio, which is the capital of the island of Corsica. He attended school at the age of 9 in France, and later got admitted to the military school in Paris at the age of 15. Napoleon

Republic, Empire and Belle Epoque Napoleon Bonaparte
Words: 1740 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

Republic, Empire and Belle Epoque Napoleon Bonaparte and the Aftermath of the Revolution Napoleon 1 (youtube) France's Regimes in the Nineteenth Century 10th anniversary bringing together 17 singers from all over the world who have sung the role of Jean Valjean: here" Excerpt from the 2012 movie of "Les Miserables": here The Role of Economics and Empire in the Building of French National Identity Video Clips - The Metro The Metro 2 - for text about the Metro go

Napoleon Defense in Defense of
Words: 357 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

(Higonnet, 1) Quite to the reality of our future, that which he has produced in the defense of the rights of man will not be retracted. Nor will be his association to these accomplishments. Therefore, both to protect ourselves from the righteous indignation of a public who will not bear to see the disgracing of its champion and to serve with justice rather than with arbitrary defensiveness the legacy

Napoleon's Influence on Lee Robert
Words: 5078 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

" (p. 164) the army of Charles was defeated in this battle however, it was not destroyed. The total loss of life in this campaign for each side of the battle was astronomical. Chancellorsville The work of Lieutenant Colonel Herman L. Gilster entitled: "Robert E. Lee and Modern Decision Theory" published in the Air University Review (1972) states in the Battle of Chancellorsville, in Virginia in May 1863 involved a battle between

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now