Verified Document

Circle Of Life Framework In Breast Health Essay

Circle of Life Framework in Breast Health Education Article Critique Analysis: Use of the Talking Circle for Comanche Women's Breast Health Education, by E. Haozous, V. Eschiti, and J. Lauderdale

The journal article, "Use of the Talking Circle for Comanche Women's Breast Health Education" by E. Haozous et. al. (2010), promotion of education on breast health was explored using a specific and unique tradition as the framework of the study. This tradition, called the Circle of Life (COL), is an "intertribal cancer prevention program focused on breast health education" and is specifically implemented among American Indian (AI) women (378). Using the COL as framework, the authors aimed to achieve "cultural congruency" in exploring, discovering, and identifying the different dimensions concerning breast health education and promotion effectiveness in the context of AI women's culture -- specifically, Comanche women (378). Harmonized understanding of the Comanche community, female and health cultures led to an understanding of factors that could significantly determine the effectiveness of initiatives related to breast health education (e.g., information dissemination through printed and audio-visual materials).

As rationale and support to the authors' decision to use the COL framework in the study, the situational analysis and review of literature centered on the criticality of understanding breast health as understood and perceived by Comanche women. Focus on this specific group was supported by an empirical study demonstrating that AI women -- specifically Comanche women -- is a high risk group in the U.S. when it comes to the health problem of breast cancer (378). Apart from being a high risk group in the health issue and problem of breast cancer, Comanche women also have a unique set of values and beliefs when it comes to health and health-seeking behavior. Given these unique characteristics of Comanche female culture, it was then necessary to undergo the study using a framework that is also known as uniquely derived from AI culture.

Thus, the central focus of the review of related literature was the development and utilization of the COL framework. The review revealed that COL was a framework that brings about "community-researcher partnership," a characteristic that is necessary for community-based participatory...

As COL literature is limited, the authors managed to cover its history and development comprehensively, at least within the scope by which the framework was used in the study. The fact that COL literature is limited was pointed out as a limitation to the review; however, rather than a limitation, this made the literature review an intensive and extensive study of COL studies throughout its 20 years of existence. In the article, the authors strengthened the literature review through empirical data supporting the claim that Comanche women is a high risk group for breast cancer, in addition to a historical review of the creation and development of COL. Combining this information from the article, the authors developed an effective synthesis that set the ground for the study's methodology (the Talking Circle) and analysis framework (emergent themes from the Talking Circle).
The framework of the study itself, the COL, is hinged on AI cultural tradition, making the study qualitative in nature utilizing the focus group discussion technique in data collection. This FGD technique is aptly called the Talking Circle, where participants/discussants are given a specific "talisman" to signal that it is the participant's turn to talk freely about an issue being discussed. Although the talisman was not used during data collection, the principle behind the Talking Circle was nevertheless implemented by the authors. The authors detailed that exploration of dimensions and themes related to the issue of breast health education and promotion were thoroughly exhausted. In addition to discussion transcripts, the authors also took note of their observations of the participants and the participants' facial expressions during the group discussion. To establish rigor in bringing out all the emergent themes from the group discussion, the authors used content analysis to "reach a consensus" in terms of identifying the 'codes, categories, and themes' that will be used during data analysis (380).

The decision to use the Talking Circle as a group discussion technique demonstrated that the authors wanted to reflect the 'community-based' and 'participatory' nature of their study. As a tradition, COL was fully integrated as the anchor that steered the direction of the study, as what qualitative studies must exhibit at the…

Sources used in this document:
Work cited:

Haozous, E., V. Eschiti, and J. Lauderdale. (2010). "Use of Talking Circle for Comanche Women's Breast Health Education." Journal of Transcultural Nursing, Vol. 21, No. 377.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Health Behavior the "Theories at a Glance"
Words: 7053 Length: 24 Document Type: Term Paper

Health Behavior The "Theories At A Glance" manual discussed a variety of healthy behaviors. Select two theories that can be used to explain why people behave the way they do. Discuss the basic premise and constructs of the theories you choose. Cite two examples of how each theory could be used to explain a health behavior. Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) The relationship that exists between behavior and attitudes, beliefs and intention

Palliative Care
Words: 21397 Length: 70 Document Type: Ghost Writing

Hisory of Palliatve Care Palliative Care Palliative Care Methods Palliative care entails assisting patients get through pain caused by different diseases. The patient may be ailing from any diseases, be it curable or untreatable. Even patient who are sick and almost passing away will need this care. Palliative care has characteristics that differentiate it to hospice care. The key role for palliative care is to help in improving the existence of someone and

Medication Reconciliation Evidence-Based Practice and the Procedural...
Words: 6404 Length: 20 Document Type: Essay

Medication Reconciliation Evidence-Based Practice and the Procedural Education of Nurses Medication reconciliation is a critical issue in healthcare reform. Today, improvement in this area of treatment could have a transformative effect on the current practices of nursing and medicine administration. The discussion, literature review and research tests that are conducted hereafter will outline the implications of medication reconciliation; justify the call for improvement in this treatment area; and offer support for the

AVON Calls on Foreign Markets Avon Believed
Words: 870 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

AVON Calls on Foreign Markets Avon believed that having regionalized new product development centers, supply chain operations, marketing and sales divisions would make them more competitive in foreign markets. Ironically the exact opposite happened, as the case illustrates. Avon's performance was drastically reduced and the duplication of effort crippled the organization. Unfortunately the highly decentralized, market-driven organizational structure that Avon had such high expectations for failure to deliver the results needed

Parenting Education for Teen Mothers if a
Words: 6240 Length: 20 Document Type: Capstone Project

Parenting Education for Teen Mothers If a community values its children, it must cherish their parents. (John Bowlby) Rationale of intervention population Group based intervention programs Multi-purpose programs Teen Mother Empowerment Program Series (TMEPS) Framework of TMEPS Program-Fig Fig 2-Phased TMEPS Phase 1 sessions Table 1- Session Administration Lesson Plans Evaluation of program outcomes Follow-up plan Continuation of TEMPS Appendix II-Program Evaluation Questionnaire This paper is aimed at presenting a parenting education and support program for teenage mothers. To identify the most basic needs of

Controversial Business Practice
Words: 5379 Length: 17 Document Type: Term Paper

Plastic Surgery Teen Plastic Surgery: A Controversial Medical Practice According to the American Society of Plastic Surgeons, in 2007, more than 87,000 teenagers had cosmetic surgery; and that number has grown exponentially since. Although aesthetic cosmetic surgery is popular amongst United States teens, physicians and plastic surgeons worry that such invasive surgery on teens' still growing bodies can be dangerous. Other developed countries, including Germany and Australia, are considering banning all but

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now