Verified Document

The Cherokee Negotiation And Removal Reaction Paper

John Ross and Jackson

The two lettersone from Chief John Ross to the US governmentthe other from President Andrew Jackson to the Cherokeeshow two sides of a terrible battle in the 19th century. On the one hand is the plight of the Cherokee, who see themselves being forced off their land in the South to go to the West. On the other hand is the argument of Jackson that the Cherokee have not bought the land and have no means of securing it for themselves, that the US has set aside funds for them and promised schools for them in the Westand so they must go. Chief John Rosss letter shows how the Cherokee just wanted to have the same kind of liberty that the Americans promoted in their Declaration.[footnoteRef:2] Jacksons letter shows how there is no thought of liberty for the Cherokee but rather an intense desire to move them out of the way and to justify their removal by glossing it with a veneer of altruism by promising a fund, schools, and shelter in the West.[footnoteRef:3] [2: Chief John Ross Letter Our Hearts are Sickened 2.] [3: Andrew Jackson Letter to the Cherokee, 1.]

Chief John Ross essentially tries to explain in his letter that when members of the Cherokee nation signed the Treaty of New Echota in 1835, they did so under a kind of duressnot as speakers of the entire Cherokee Nation. Moreover, he argues that the provisions of the treaty were altered in such a way as to make it all the more unfavorable for the Cherokee people.[footnoteRef:4] Facing overwhelming pressure, Ross argues that these individuals had but little understanding of the consequences, and that they represented only but a small group of Cherokee leaders who agreed to cede their lands in the East to the US government and relocate to present-day Oklahoma....

…significant figure whose story has basically been consigned to the dust heap of history by the American establishment. Second, these letters offer a rare glimpse into the negotiations between the Cherokee and the US government. They show what a farce it actually was and how the government was willing to use pressure and unfair tactics to get what it wantedwhich was the Southin its own hands. Finally, they shed light on the differing perspectives of Native Americans and white Americans on the issue of Removal. Taken together, these letters offer a unique window into one of the most significant events in American history. The more one realizes what was at stake at that point in history, the more one sees the negotiation as treacherousfor if the Cherokee had not been forcibly removed, there might not have been a Civil War and the total takeover of the states by the federal system of government that…

Sources used in this document:

Bibliography

Andrew Jackson Letter to the Cherokee.

“Our Hearts are Sickened”: Letter from Chief John Ross of the Cherokee, Georgia, 1836.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Cherokee Removal the "Trail of
Words: 1230 Length: 4 Document Type: Book Report

The Congress eventually followed suit by enacting the Indian Removal Act which was greeted by the newly elected President Andrew Jackson. Americans should feel no regret for the disappearance of Indians from the face of the earth, Jackson argued. "Philanthropy could not wish to see this continent restored to the condition in which it was found by our forefathers," he said to Congress in his State of the Union

Cherokees Sir Alexander Cuming 1730
Words: 2771 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

It was on May 4, 1730 that Cumming and the seven Cherokee began their trip to England, where they arrived on June 5. They were all headquartered in the house of James Crowe. Cuming's correspondence during this period is quite rich and we will mention some of it further below. The meeting with King George II occurred on July 18, 1730 and it is an excellent and somewhat amusing sample of

Cherokee the Impact of Intolerance
Words: 1417 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

For examples, "In Oklahoma the Cherokee live both on and off the reservation scattered in urban centers and in isolated rural regions." (Cherokee) This also refers to the influence of contemporary industrial society, which has often been referred to as a central cause for the cultural breakdown of religious traditions in the culture. One also has to bear in mind political events and factors in the 1800s, such as the

Effect of Trail of Tears on Cherokees
Words: 713 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Cherokee Nation can be described as the government of the Cherokee people that is recognized by the federal government in the United States. Throughout its history, the Cherokee Nation has remained committed to safeguarding its people's intrinsic sovereignty while promoting and preserving the language, culture, and values of the Cherokee people. Moreover, the Cherokee Nation is increasingly committed to enhancing the quality of life for subsequent generations of Cherokee people

The Culture of the Eastern Band Cherokee
Words: 3152 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

Introduction The Cherokee Tribe in North Carolina is part of the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians, a federally-recognized independent Native American Cherokee tribe whose home base is in Cherokee, North Carolina, south of the Smoky Mountains. The Eastern Band is comprised of the descendants of the approximately 800 Cherokee who did not join the Trail of Tears—the forced migration of the Native American nations from the Southern U.S. region to the

Dieri Bevenda Cherokee
Words: 1129 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Dieri, Bevenda, Cherokee structures of religious belief and touch upon tribal beliefs about god and gods, key myths and rituals The Dieri, an aboriginal tribe of Australia, the Oklahoma tribe of the Cherokee, and the Bevenda may all be subsumed under the common category of 'native people,' when comparing such indigenous faiths with the common faith of those who colonized these individuals, namely white Christians. However, upon closer examination of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now