One of the simplest and most common methods to assess leadership attributes are questionnaires. Questionnaires, such as the Leadership Behavior Description Questionnaire (LBDQ) use quantitative survey techniques to assess the degree to which organizational actors display leadership behaviors (Bryman, 2011). It should be noted that the LBDQ asks not the leaders themselves whether they display specific leadership attributes, but members of the organization. The LBDQ “provides a technique whereby group members may describe the leader behavior of designated leaders in formal organizations. The LBDQ contains items, each of which describes a specific way in which a leader may behave” (Tepper, 2011). However, questionnaires submitted to followers or leaders have a number of constraints which limit their accuracy. Firstly, the data collection method design can bias results regarding behaviors which may be ambiguous, such as forcing respondents to answer whether they agree or disagree, or rate something on a Likert-type scale.
Attribute studies, in contrast, attempt to link specific personality attributes to leadership abilities, versus behaviors. They too often survey leaders and followers about qualities they associate with leadership. For example, in a study conducted by the staffing company Robert Half, leaders and followers were asked to rank the following attributes: “Accessibility, Collaborative Mindset, Competitiveness, Decisiveness, Fairness, Integrity, Strategic Mindset, and Transparency” (Lipman, 2016, par.5). Although the ranking varied depending on the individual’s position in the corporate hierarchy, all persons answering the questionnaire ranked integrity first. Although this was taken by the constructor of the survey to suggest that integrity, is the most important leadership attribute, attribute studies have similar problems to behavioral studies,...…lack of trust in the leadership, and contested leadership positions (Smollan & Griffiths, 2020). While qualitative studies can be valuable in terms of bringing light to unexpected aspects of leadership on one hand, the narrowness of focus often make organizations reluctant to set policy or make generalizations based upon their results.
Thus, leadership, despite the general agreement of its importance, remains a very difficult attribute to study. First of all, there is widespread disagreement about how to define various behaviors and qualities associated with leadership. Secondly, the use of quantitative studies can force respondents into very narrow, culturally imprecise definitions of such attributes, while qualitative studies may not be broad enough to generalize beyond the leader and the organization. The best research methods with which to study leadership may be just as elusive as the…
References
Bryman, A. (2011). The SAGE handbook of leadership. London: Sage.
Lipman, V. (2016). The most important leadership attribute. Forbes. Retrieved from: https://www.forbes.com/sites/victorlipman/2016/10/25/the-most-important-leadership- attribute-new-study-has-clear-answer/#143889a84df2
Smollan, R., & Griffiths, C. (2020). Taking over or taking in? A qualitative case study of successful acquisitions. Journal of Management & Organization, ;1-21. doi:10.1017/jmo.2020.12
Tepper, B. (2020). LBDQ. The Ohio State University. Retrieved from: https://fisher.osu.edu/centers-partnerships/leadership/leader-behavior-description- questionnaire-lbdq
Leadership Theory in a Changing and Globalizing Marketplace Modern business practice is permeated by the complexities of a changing world. The impact of globalization on the cultural makeup of companies, the effects of the global recession on the conventions of daily business and the evolutionary shifts brought on by emergent technology all call for an orientation toward simultaneous stability and adaptability. Only under the stewardship of a qualified, communicative, flexible and
Leadership Portfolio Political tactics are essential for quality leadership. It is important to be tactful in all situations, and to understand the confounding variables that can impact communication clarity. Politics refers to skillful communications and strategic decision-making. Compromises are critical to good politics. For example, we were working with a large team of over 25 people. Each person had a clearly defined role, but there came a time when egos started
Leadership and Organizations: Bill Gates and Steve Jobs The theories of leadership date way back to when dynasties existed and people were led by kings. The leader took control and made decisions whenever disputes arose. The question of leadership qualities may not have been all that important then, but people still considered some to be better leaders than others. It would be prudent to begin by giving the fundamentals of the
Leadership Theories The role of leadership in business organizations Many leadership theories have been applied, in different organizations, to help in attainment of the objectives of the organization. Leadership theories are many, but the most common include the trait theory, which assumes that different people inherit the qualities and also traits of leadership and later suit for the position of leadership. The characteristics related to the trait theory are behavioral and personality
Leadership Evaluation Introduction to Award Program Any discussion of employee incentive programs will make use of many different terms, most of which will mean different things to different people. In order to ensure the discussion has apples-to-apples clarity, this paper begins with a basic lexicon. Employee incentives are a form of payment that is tied to the performance of employees. The incentive payment can be either intangible or tangible, and with or without
Leadership is defined as the procedures that individuals use as authority over others to achieve an objective. The action also provides direction in a manner that makes an organization more coherent and cohesive. Three-Skill Approach This approach refers to three skills including human, technical, and conceptual, which form the fundamental personal skills required in leadership. Technical skills involve proficiency in and knowledge about some defined activities or work. It includes analytical ability,
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now