Verified Document

Centralia 1947 Mine Explosion Throughout The Annals Case Study

Centralia 1947 Mine Explosion Throughout the annals of the American industrialized age, countless tragedies have occurred within the workplace and these incidents have forced the public at large to consider the weighty issue of applying moral precepts to the realm of public administration. While the tomes of American jurisprudence are littered with examples of corporate enterprises and bureaucratic entities failing to uphold their basic responsibilities, perhaps no case has demonstrated the capacity to generate both outrage and activism as readily as The Blast in Centralia No. 5: A Mine Disaster No One Stopped. Authored by John Bartlow Martin, this seminal case study examines the unique confluence of internal and external circumstances which eventually resulted in the 1947 explosion of Centralia Mine No. 5, a catastrophe which claimed the lives of 111 coal miners. By carefully retracing the series of events preceding the actual explosion, including a history of the Centralia mine beginning with its opening in 1907, a cursory primer on the industry of coal mining, and a blow-by-blow recounting of the evasions, denials, and betrayals committed by the various bureaucracies charged with preventing such disasters, Martin guides the reader through the machinations of both private companies and public policymakers.

The most intriguing aspect of Martin's case study are found in his recreation of the measures taken by Driscoll O. Scanlan, the Illinois state mine inspector who thoroughly inspected the Centralia mining operation while doggedly pursuing his professional appraisal of the mine's flimsy safety record, which he believed made "Centralia No. 5 the worst in the district" (Martin, 1948). While Martine assiduously recreates the vast array of actors in what proved to be a farcical demonstration of public administration, with Scanlan's tireless efforts to alert proper authorities to the dangers...

Throughout his circuitous examination of the Centralia mine calamity, Martin repeatedly returns the concept of administrative gridlock which plagued the bureaucracies created precisely to prevent such disasters, but he fails to propose alternative courses of action that Scanlan either neglected to consider or ignored outright. By opening his case study with a wrenching recreation of explosion scene, which declares emphatically that "one hundred and eleven men were & #8230; killed needlessly, for almost everybody concerned had known for months, even years, that the mine was dangerous" before concluding that the tragedy occurred solely because "nobody had done anything effective about it" (Martin, 1948), the author openly suggests that Scanlan and his contemporaries may have willfully missed their many opportunities to prevent such a tragic occurrence from taking place.
According to Martin's portrayal of the events, mine inspector Scanlan identified coal dust buildup as the source of the eventual explosion more than five years before it happened, and the numerous recommendations he made within his initial report on Centralia No. 5 appear to support this claim. The recognized historical review of major mining accidents from the era, entitled Death Underground: The Centralia and West Frankfort Mine Disasters, reported that conditions at Centralia No. 5 were known to be dangerously neglected, observing that "coal dust accumulated everywhere, reducing visibility, complicating ventilation, and making life miserable for workers," before warning ominously that when "mine air is saturated with dust particles & #8230; a spark or a flame can ignite the highly combustible dust and touch off an explosion that roars through the tunnels and rooms, claiming everything in its…

Sources used in this document:
References

Hartley, R.E., & Kenney, D. (2006). Death underground: The centralia and west frankfort mine disasters. Chicago, IL: Southern Illinois University Press.

Fanning, F. (2007). Public sector safety professionals: Focused on activity or results?. Perspectives Newsletter, 6(3), 11-15. Retrieved from http://www.usmra.com/repository/category/disasters/Best-of-the-

Best_Newsletter_Article.pdf

Martin, J.B. (1948). The blast in centralia no. 5: A mine disaster no one stopped. In R.J. Stillman
Thompson, D.F. (1980). Moral responsibility of public officials: The problem of many hands. The American Political Science Review, 74(4), 905-916. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/1954312?uid=3739552&uid=2134&uid=2&uid=7
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Coal Mining Industry Report the
Words: 1477 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

In 2006, production workers, earned $21.40 an hour in oil and gas extraction, $22.08 an hour in coal mining, $22.39 an hour in metal ore mining, and $18.74 an hour in nonmetallic minerals mining, compared to the private industry average of $16.76 an hour Figure 1 and Figure 2 below show the 'Average Earnings of Non-Supervisory Workers in 2006 and Median Hourly Mining of the Largest Occupations in Mining, May

Coal Mining Black Lung Disease
Words: 700 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

There is also a lack of healthcare facilities capable of doing the screenings in many small, rural Kentucky communities, which is another barrier for many miners. Health professionals need to become more involved in information and screening information. They need to stress the importance of early screening and regular screening, and they need to create educational resources for the miners, so they can take steps to avoid black lung. Health

Coal Mining in the United
Words: 1389 Length: 4 Document Type: Thesis

" President Truman did not deal with the UMWA because he had a love for labor, either. He feared that a prolonged strike would hurt a nation recovering from World War II, and so, he signed the fund into action with the union president. The UMWA was crucial in settling the strike and getting benefits for the miners and at the heart of the organization was its president, John L. Lewis. Lewis

Coal Mining in the United
Words: 1378 Length: 4 Document Type: Thesis

In other words, the finances of a deficit country were constrained because they did not have enough gold to go around, while a country with a surplus did not face those issues. In addition, usually the weight of modification falls on these weaker countries, which is another flaw in the gold standard. Because the weaker countries could not react quickly enough to economic problems, they had less capital to

Coal Mining in the United
Words: 643 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Proposal

Another historian notes, "Economically, baby boomers experienced unprecedented national affluence throughout their childhood. During the 1950s and 1960s, the U.S. economy expanded greatly, raising the living standards of most American families" (Clydesdale 606). Religion played less of a role in society by the 1990s, as church attendance and membership began to decline in the 60s. Historian Clydesdale continues, "When the cultural challenges of the 1960's disestablished this religious ethos,

Environmental Impact of Coal Mining
Words: 3880 Length: 13 Document Type: Thesis

" The prominence of this type of mining method is underlined by a study prepared for the Governor of West Virginia which states that, "Mountaintop removal methods are essential to maintain the state's present level of coal production. The lower production costs of MTR have contributed significantly to maintaining West Virginia as a competitive coal producer." 3. Environmental impact of coal mining in the Appalachians. 3.1. Underground mining The earliest coal mining in Appalachia consisted

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now