Verified Document

Case Study Medication Error Dealing With An Ethical Dilemma Case Study

Medication Error Medical errors cost lives, and they cost health care organizations valuable resources. Nurses are often confused about their ethical as well as legal obligations, especially with a complex, constantly changing, global healthcare marketplace. Few medical errors are completely straightforward. Most incidents involve multiple actors and numerous stakeholders. Nurses are being increasingly challenged to combine deontological with utilitarian ethical viewpoints, an endeavor that is as challenging as the work of healthcare itself.

The Case

(from Hurley & Berghahn, 2010)

A nurse with 16 years of experience was working her third shift in 24 hours, one of which was a double shift. She spent last night sleeping in the hospital. Currently, the nurse was caring for two patients. One was a pregnant teenager admitted for labor induction. The patient tested positive for streptococcus, and a medical resident wrote an order for penicillin.

To prepare for the patient's procedure, the nurse removed the medications ordered for this patient. Although the anesthesiologist had not yet ordered the epidural anesthetic, the nurse considered it to be part of the labor routine and got it ready to show the patient when it was time to give her the instructions. The nurse left the bag of epidural for the patient to read, and also the bag of penicillin ready by the patient's bed. No one on the health care team, including the nurse, had used the bar code system. As a result, a different nurse administered the epidural anesthetic intravenously instead of the antibiotic.

The patient died, but the baby was saved via an emergency caesarian section. When the nurse learned that an internal investigation had been launched, she resigned. Soon thereafter, the attorney general filed...

She was charged with felony abuse of a patient causing great bodily harm. The maximum sentence would have been ten years in prison.
Personal Values

This case raises a number of ethical issues relevant for all health care workers and administrators. As Erlen (2001) states, "Nurses are taught procedures so that they are less likely to make mistakes. Yet nurses do make errors," (p. 82). Errors are not in and of themselves ethical dilemmas. However, how to address and remedy those errors are almost always ethical concerns. There are ethics related to human resources, and how to handle nurses like the one in this case. Furthermore, there are also ethical issues at stake when it comes to hospital procedure, which is why administrators bear the brunt of responsibility for many medical errors. The nurses are often the ones who bear the blame for medical errors. However, "changing the health care system will help nurses to promote patient welfare, lessen the chance of harm, and reduce the likelihood of medication errors occurring," (Erlen, 2001). If the problem of medical error is systemic, then administrators need to recognize what they can do to eliminate or at least reduce the incidence of error.

Ethical Viewpoints

Harm to patients is the primary ethical infraction with medical errors that are preventable. However, many medical errors are related less to a nurse's negligence and more to disjointed organizational culture in a profit-driven health care system. A profit-driven health care system itself is ethically incorrect, as it is impossible to value both shareholders and patients. The current healthcare model is based on strict utilitarian ethics. For example, inducing labor in pregnancy is not generally necessary but it takes place in order to…

Sources used in this document:
References

Aiken, T.D. (2004). Legal, Ethical, and Political Issues in Nursing. F.A. Davis.

Barber, N.D., Alldred, D.P., Raynor, D.K., Dickinson, R., Garfield, S., Jesson, B., Lim, R., Savage, I., Standage, C., Buckle, P., Carpenter, J., Franklin, B., Woloshynowych, M. & Zermansky, A.G. (2009). Care homes' use of medicines study: prevalence, causes and potential harm of medication errors in care homes for older people. Qual Saf Health Care 2009;18:341-346 doi:10.1136/qshc.2009.034231

Cornett, J.A. (2013). Identifying Communication Precursors to Medical Error in an In-patient Clinical Environment: A Palliative Sedation Therapy Case Study.

Erlen, J.A. (2001). Medication errors. Orthopedic Nursing 20(4): 82-5.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Ethical Dilemmas In Nursing
Words: 1851 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Essay Topic Examples Autonomy vs. Beneficence: Respecting Patient Choices in End-of-Life Care This essay would explore the ethical dilemma nurses face when a patient's wishes regarding their end-of-life care conflict with what the healthcare team believes is in the patient's best interest. The paper could examine case studies where patient autonomy is challenged by the principle of beneficence, and how nurses navigate these complex situations to

Pharmacist.In This Case, the Pharmacist
Words: 1583 Length: 5 Document Type: Case Study

Reflection A reflection on the case shows me that ethical and moral guidelines must be instilled in pharmacy as a profession. It is therefore necessary for the pharmacies to collaborate with other key stakeholders in ensuring that proper guidelines are put in place together with polices aimed at ensuring an ethical and moral pharmaceutical practice. Case Resolution Model (CRM) (Brincat & Wike,1999) is therefore an important model since it has taken

Business Code of Ethics Evaluation of Business
Words: 1626 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Business Code of Ethics Evaluation of Business Code Ethics Over the last several years, the issue of ethics has been increasingly brought to the forefront. This is because a wide variety of organizations have been facing some kind of high profile scandal involving an ethical dilemma. To address these issues, most firms have implemented a code of ethics for everyone to follow. The problem is that most people are not aware

Are Theatre Nurses Equipped With the Skills Required to Perform Pre-Operative...
Words: 7009 Length: 25 Document Type: Term Paper

Theatre Nurses Equipped With the Skills Required to Perform Pre-Operative Visits To Perform Pre-Operative Visits? Are Theatre Nurses Equipped With the Skills Required To Perform Pre-Operative Visits? Dissemination Are Theatre Nurses Equipped With the Skills Required To Perform Pre-Operative Visits? Pre-operative assessment is part of the ER process that many medical professionals believe can be accomplished on the part of nurses in the unit.. The objective listed for pre-operative assessment is that special requirements for the

Market Orientation of Medical Diagnostic Units Dissertation
Words: 21636 Length: 76 Document Type: Term Paper

Market Orientation of Medical Diagnostic Units Dissertation for Master of Health Administration i. Introduction ii. Objectives iii. Description iv Administrative Internship v. Scope and Approach vi. Growth vii. Methodology viii. Hypothesis ix. Survey Questionnaire x. Research Design xi. Observation and Data Presentation xii. Test provided xiii. Analysis of findings Marketability of Patient Satisfaction Importance of Employee Satisfaction xiv. Conclusions and Recommendations xv. Bibliography xvi. Notes xvii. Appendices Market Orientation of Medical Diagnostic Units

Organizational Responsibility and Current Health Care Issues
Words: 2496 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

Organizational Responsibility and Current Health Care Issues Ethics is the assessment and research of the human habits in regard to moral concepts, particularly those in a certain team, occupation, or specific organization (The Free Dictionary, 2012). People deal with lots of ethical/moral problems everyday and how they react might result in significant and legal ethical/moral ramifications. In the healthcare market, having approaches for making ethical/moral choices is a necessary part of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now