Verified Document

Case Study And Bank Case Study

Managerial Hubris: Case Study of Farrow Bank Instances of leaders and managers portraying overconfidence as far as their managerial behavior is concerned are not rare. This excessive overconfidence is referred to as managerial hubris (Brown, 2006). The individual overwhelmingly believes they cannot wrong. In most part, this behavior emanates from a sustained period of success, which makes the individual unrealistically perceive themselves as somewhat prone to error. Hubristic behavior can be costly to an organization, sometimes even leading to downfall (Hollow, 2014). This was particularly true for Farrow Bank, a booming bank in the early 20th century. The bank collapsed in 1920, with managerial hubris on the part of its founder and CEO, Thomas Farrow, being the major contributing factor. Focusing on the failure, this case study explores the implications of managerial hubris on organizational success. The case study particularly pays attention to four issues: how corporate culture, leadership, power, and motivation drove Thomas' hubristic behavior; the relationship between managerial hubris and ethical decision-making; the pressures associated with ethical decision-making at the bank; as well as the extent to which managerial hubris may have been avoided.

As depicted in the case study, four factors contributed to Thomas' hubristic behavior: power, leadership, corporate culture, and motivation. As early as the age of 19, Thomas was already close to power (Hollow, 2014). He served as a confidential and political secretary to powerful politicians in the British government, notably Rt. Hon W.H. Smith (head of the lower legislature)...

Thomas' position gave him the authority to criticize the UK banking sector despite not even having any background in economics or finance.
With widespread dissatisfaction with the prevailing banks, Thomas established Farrow Bank in 1904 with a view to providing a cheaper alternative for low income consumers (Hollow, 2014). The bank drastically became a success, and had established 72 branches across England, Wales, Scotland and Ireland. The bank became the top bank in the UK in terms of not only geographical presence, but also banking innovation, deposits, and assets. The phenomenal success of the bank added to Thomas' overconfidence. He became more ambitious and envisioned himself as not only a leader in banking, but also an influential voice in issues of national policy. In his speeches and publications, Thomas exhibited arrogance, often painting the bank as a divine as opposed to a commercial entity (Hollow, 2014).

By losing touch with reality, Thomas permitted a dangerous culture to flourish in the bank. In 1920, following an acquisition deal, it emerged that the bank's financial figures were misleading (Hollow, 2014). The bank had over the years disregarded standard accounting practices. More unfortunately, with his excessive confidence and concern for self-image, Thomas had long abandoned auditing the bank's financial statements, leaving the job exclusively to the chief accountant,…

Sources used in this document:
References

Brown, R. (2006). CEO overconfidence, CEO dominance and corporate acquisitions. Retrieved 20 October 2016 from: https://research.mbs.ac.uk/accounting- finance/Portals/0/docs/2007/Raynabrownmanchester.pdf

Hollow, M. (2014). The 1920 Farrow's bank failure: a case of managerial hubris? Journal of Management History, 20(2), 164-178.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Bank America Case Study From Goldsmith &
Words: 1404 Length: 5 Document Type: Case Study

Bank America Case Study From Goldsmith & Carter textbook, select Bank America (Chapter 2) case study assignment - uploaded Write a (5-7) page paper: 1.Outline talent management program led success company. Bank of America case study The modern day working environment is a highly complex and intricate field, in which employees and employers have to continually meet new demands, standards and challenges. Employees, for instance, have to perform new tasks at superior

Case Study on Management Hubris
Words: 709 Length: 2 Document Type: Case Study

Farrow's Bank -- Case Study On Management Hubris Case Study on Management Hubris, a report about 1920's Farrow's Bank. VICTIMS RIGHTS MOVEMENT Characterizing Farrow's Hubris The steady rise and increase in Farrow's Bank's prominence boosted Farrow's confidence and determination. Farrow stopped seeing himself as just a banker, and became increasingly vocal regarding matters of industrial legislation and national policies. He took liberties by airing his views through the Bank's in-house publications and giving strong

Case Study: Wal-Mart
Words: 3414 Length: 9 Document Type: Capstone Project

Wal-Mart Inc. Wal-Mart is an American-based multinational discount store, currently operating more than 11,000 retail outlets in 27 different countries, and serving approximately 140 million customers weekly. Headquartered in Bentonville, Arkansas, Wal-Mart grew from a small family-managed retailer in 1945 to the world's largest retailer, and was named the world's largest company by revenues in the 2014 Fortune 500 list. The company operates its retail stores in two forms: i) Sam's

Dennis Kozlowski and the Tyco Case Study
Words: 872 Length: 3 Document Type: Case Study

Business Ethics," Peter Stanwick Sarah Stanwick, 2009 Read Case Study 20 (p. 389), "Tyco: I'm That It's a Really Nice Shower Curtain." Summarize viewpoint author paragraph form, discuss major issues presented case. Dennis Kozlowski and the Tyco case study The author in this case concentrates on providing readers with more information on the central character involved in the story and the way he singlehandedly cheated the authorities and society as a

Drug Abuse Case Study the
Words: 1659 Length: 6 Document Type: Case Study

As indicated by Miller & Rollnick (1991), confronting a client might leave them with a feeling of being under attack. This may then reduce their urge of being treated. Zweben, Miller, Rychtarik, DiClemente (1992) indicated that most people would resist the advice of a counselor by constantly reacting as well as acting in the opposite manner to what the counselor wants them to act. The other principle of motivational thinking

Nuclear Decommissioning Authority: Case Study Analysis Hoover
Words: 2440 Length: 9 Document Type: Case Study

Nuclear Decommissioning Authority: Case Study Analysis Hoover Dam The objective of this study is to conduct research and provide a case study of a human-made system and to report on that system. This work will cover technical and operational details and relate these case study specifics to the course content. It was reported in April 2006 that the United Kingdom had established the Nuclear Decommissioning Authority (NDA) and that this agency had set

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now