Verified Document

Capital Punishment The Pros And Term Paper

life imprisonment, we must follow common sense and assume that if one punishment is more fearful than another, it will deter some potential criminals not deterred by the less fearful punishment" (p. 282). In an effort to deconstruct the tenability of van den Haag's assertions, Reiman takes the deterrent analogy to an extreme and suggests that the death penalty is insufficient and that death by torture would serve as an even more effective deterrent. While some observers might suggest that this is precisely what is happening to internees at Guantanamo Bay detention camp, Reiman's extreme position concerning capital punishment does serve to highlight the moral and legal ambiguities involved in assessing the value of the death penalty for a modern society. Notwithstanding these moral and legal ambiguities, though, in the case of capital crimes, there is far too much at stake to allow such heinous acts to go unpunished, and van den Haag's "best bet argument" maintains that it is better for society to err on the side of safety by using the death penalty rather than taking a chance on alternative punishments. This pragmatic perspective is reinforced by the fact that having been convicted of a capital offense, death row inmates forfeit all of their cards (e.g., right to life) in favor of the house (e.g., the state) in the gambling analogy presented by van den Haag's "best bet argument." According to White, "van den Haag's 'best bet argument' [maintains] that given uncertainties about whether execution deters, the best bet is to execute, for this involves gambling with guilty lives rather than innocent ones. The bet, of course, is that executions will deter and thus save innocent lives" (p. 249). Indeed, it is difficult to argue with the reality that an executed criminal will not commit any further capital crimes, just as it is difficult to challenge the rationale that at least some people will be dissuaded from committing capital crimes because of a fear of the death penalty.

Conclusion

One of the fundamental challenges involved in living in a free...

The question of whether the state has the right and moral authority to execute those convicted of capital crimes has been debated since time immemorial, but the issues involved remain as salient and compelling today as they did thousands of years ago. The research showed that the United States remains one of the few nations in the world to use the death penalty, and the arguments in favor and against capital punishment showed that the analysis is a complicated one. Nevertheless, the research also showed that despite the arguments against the death penalty, the single best reason in favor of its continued use was the fact that executed criminals commit no further crimes and their execution may in fact serve as a deterrent for others in the future.
References

Black's law dictionary. (1991). St. Paul, MN: West Publishing Co.

Cahn, S.M. & Markie, P. (1998). Ethics: History, theory, and contemporary issues. New York: Oxford University Press.

Reiman, J.H. (2000). Justice, civilization and the death penalty. In White at 273-283.

A van den Haag, E. (1978). In defense of the death penalty: A practical and moral analysis.

Criminal Law Bulletin, 14(1), 51-68 in Cahn & Markie at 837.

White, J.E. (2000). Contemporary moral problems (6th ed.). Belmost, CA: Wadsworth Publishing Company.

Sources used in this document:
References

Black's law dictionary. (1991). St. Paul, MN: West Publishing Co.

Cahn, S.M. & Markie, P. (1998). Ethics: History, theory, and contemporary issues. New York: Oxford University Press.

Reiman, J.H. (2000). Justice, civilization and the death penalty. In White at 273-283.

A van den Haag, E. (1978). In defense of the death penalty: A practical and moral analysis.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Death Penalty
Words: 2882 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

As such, it is unlikely to change in light of knowledge or information about the death penalty and its administration" (Vollum & Buffington-Vollum, p. 30). Furthermore, "those who scored higher on value-expressive attitudes were less accepting of information critical of the death penalty and, in turn, less likely to change their views in light of the information presented." Thus, the widespread support of the death penalty in the face

Death Penalty
Words: 2338 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Death Penalty is the most severe forms of punishment that can be accorded to a criminal who has committed a crime and deserves to be punished. The brief history of death penalty shows that this is nothing new, because it was something that was practiced right from the eighteenth century BC, in Babylon, and thereafter in Athens, and in Rome, and in Great Britain. The death penalty methods of punishments

Capital Punishment in the United States
Words: 1910 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

Capital Punishment in the United States Capital punishment is one of the comprehensive, but debatable punishments given to criminal offenders in the U.S. And many other nations across the globe. Capital punishment involves the issuance of the death penalty because of committing serious crimes like crime in the society. Capital punishment has received tumultuous public support touching both ends of the society with its authorization in thirty-seven American states. It is

Capital Punishment in USA
Words: 1430 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

From 1977 to 2007, the number of death sentences per capita was as follows: Alabama .89, Oklahoma .818, Mississippi .558, Nevada .546, Delaware .497, North Carolina .481, Florida .463, South Carolina .422, Arizona .412, Arkansas .399, Texas .379, Louisiana .342, Missouri .313, Pennsylvania .277, Ohio .270, Tennessee .270, Idaho .267, Georgia .236, Illinois .233, California .219, Kentucky .193, Virginia .192, Oregon .184, Indiana .148, Nebraska .147, Wyoming .134, Montana

Death Penalty Is A Fair Punishment For Murder
Words: 1917 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Death Penalty All indications are that capital offenses are on the rise and the response to this phenomenon has been a cry to impose capital punishment as retribution. Certainly the issue is one of the most hotly debated in the world today; both for consideration of its humaneness as well as efficacy as a deterrent. For the purposes of this assignment we will examine the issue from both sides with the

Death Penalty Is Fair Punishment
Words: 1594 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Death Penalty Is Fair The Death Penalty Is a Fair Punishment for Murder Arguements have been raised concerning death penalty for a long time now. A lot of people consider death penalty as an immoral, or an unreasonable punishment. (Messerli, 2007) Despite the fact that the death sentences were a constant element of society in the past, which actually initiated from lynching and ended in the modern capital punishment and is still

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now