Verified Document

Canon Law Essay

¶ … marriage must always precede ordination and whether priests and widowhood may be allowed to remarry after widowhood or divorce was one of the topics of discussion at the revolutionary 1923 Pan-Orthodox Congress, which aimed to produce reform-oriented results that would allow the Orthodox Church to be better adapted to the new realities of the world in the period after World War I. On both issues, beyond any economic or social arguments, the discussion should always revert back to the Scriptures and to what the Scriptures say about these elements. For example, the Congress agreed that the Scriptures allow for marriage after ordination (or, in fact, that there is nothing in the Scriptures that prohibits that, meaning, by extrapolation and law principle, that whatever is not prohibited, is considered to be in line with the canonical law).

In his initial analysis, Viscuso also makes an important note on why that is: because there is no "doctrine of either sacrament's superiority" (p. xxxvii). Successive doctrines have also not prohibited the marriage after ordination: the tenth canon of the Council of Ankyra, for example, allows this to happen in the case of deacons.

With these arguments in mind, it rather seems that there is almost no discussion of whether marriage after ordination should be accepted or not. The original base of all canonical regulation, the Scriptures, has no adverse say on this topic. It seems a logical deduction that successive additions and interpretation have, in fact, created this premise that marriage after ordination should not be permitted.

There are several studies mentioned by Viscuso that make this case before the 1923 Congress. Milas, in 1907, for example, mentions that "the prohibition...

This is a clear recognition that the restriction did not come from the original base of learning, the Scriptures, but from discipline. This is an interesting aspect, because it means that successive interpretations of the Scriptures by the Church hierarchy led to a different meaning of the words of the Scripture and initial, ancient norms, on the matter of marriage after ordination. It is an acceptance of the fact that, at a certain moment in the evolution of the Orthodox history, hierarchical decisions on these matters took over the true meaning and instructions of the words of the Scripture.
For remarriage of widowed priests and deacons, other arguments, outside the range of the canonical law, should also be taken into consideration and presented here. Gavril of Montenegro mentions both economical and psychological issues of a widowed priest who also has children. Other than the issue of temptation that he brings up, a priest that is widowed and not allowed to remarry will need to care for both the needs of his children (education, upbringing etc.) and the needs of the household. This may lead to his incapacity of handling his priestly duties to the degree to which he would as a married priest.

In the same context, it is interesting to note the observations some of the representatives made on these issues, namely by reflecting on national practices in the matter. For example, one of the participants from Romania mentioned that, in his country, there was…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

1. Viscuso, Patrick. A Quest for Reform of the Orthodox Church. Berkeley, 2006.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Canon Law
Words: 1105 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Orthodox Church is indeed in a state of canonical disarray and this paper aims to put together a set of plausible arguments in favor of this statement. The best place to start is likely with Viscuso's study "A Quest for Reform of the Orthodox Church: The 1923 Pan-Orthodox Congress," which looks back at the 1923 as a quintessential moment in the process of reform that the Orthodox Church could

Canons Infallible Expressions of the
Words: 1361 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Nowadays, another common aspect of modern life is the sinful life of young women living with men without the shelter of marriage. Although this is considered by the Church to be a sin and rules of the Church are therefore broken, it is very difficult to refuse confession to such believers. The canons are in this way a means through which advice can be given by priests and ministers

Ethics in Shaping American Law: ABA Model
Words: 500 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Ethics in Shaping American Law: ABA Model Rules The objective of this study is to examine why ethics are so important in shaping American law and to explain three important ABA Model Rules along with examples that apply to law firms. This work will also explain three important ABA Model Rules with examples that apply to Attorneys and will summarize the application of the ABA model rules and responses to

Aviation Law A Reflective
Words: 946 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Law: Aviation Law Reflective EssayPart 1: ReflectionThe module is important with its relevancy to the Aviation industry since it would help understand the law of aviation in the country. When one has to adopt a professional career in a certain field, one has to get familiar with the laws and policies, which are a �code of conduct� for carrying out certain actions that are allowed and preventing those prohibited. It

Criminal Defense Attorney the Canons
Words: 1330 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Finally, a divorce attorney may be aware that it is in the client's interest to be more legally aggressive, to gain a better settlement, even if the client's temporary, overwrought emotional state runs against this tendency. The utter prohibition against active solicitation of clients would also bar much of public interest advocacy, such as lawyers who actively seek clients to challenge laws that they believe are against the public good,

Old Testament and New Testament Canon
Words: 1769 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Orthodoxy and the Canon: There are several areas in the early church on essential issues such as the deity of Christ, nature, and humanity. This period of dispute was also characterized with the emergence of groups like Gnostics, which brought a completely new set of presumed beliefs to the faith that came alongside the faith and in total compromised tenets of the faith. These new beliefs were supposedly based on

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now