Verified Document

Business Management-5. Performance Review Session: Nick Was Case Study

Business Management-5. Performance review session: Nick was relieved after his performance review from Warren because Nick did not seem to be penalized to any great degree for the servers going down while he was on duty. However, the performance review was extremely vague and undefined. It is unclear what a 'three' means in terms of a rating. Nick was told he was doing a 'fine' (i.e., acceptable) job but was not given any specific information about how to improve his performance. Warren was also extremely casual and informal (making comments about Nick's appearance and jokes) which destroyed the necessary subordinate-manager distance required for an effective review process. It made the review seem more personal and subjective. If the review had been negative, Nick may have been offended and complained about Warren's objectivity.

Q1b. When a performance review is given to a subordinate with whom you have a good personal relationship it is essential to bracket the review as a 'business' versus a 'personal' interaction so the person does not become offended by the advice and input given in the review.

Q1c. I think the statement is an excellent summary of how to approach the performance review of someone with whom you are close friends. On one hand, merely giving vague and uncritical commentary will be frustrating and if the person gets a negative rating in the next session, he will be angry he was offered no input about how to change his behavior. Constructive criticism...

However, it is also important to point out what the employee is doing right as well as what he or she is doing wrong. Friendship should not make the review more or less negative: it should be professional and objective.
Q1d. Nick got very little from the performance review: he does not really know what he is doing right or wrong. Although it can be very difficult, emotionally speaking, for some managers to bring up negative issues, from the employee's perspective it is better to receive some criticism in the present than to be fired in the future. Also, Nick did not receive any specific praise for what he was doing right. Warren gave the impression of being unprepared and therefore very uninterested in Nick's career rather than complementary.

Q2a. Status reports: Having a variety of weekly leaders turn in status reports can be frustrating, given that it is not unusual for leaders to give wildly different evaluations, depending upon their subjective impressions. If an employee receives a status report which reads he or she needs to work on, say, his or her ability to work well on a team and the other report says that he or she needs to be more independent and a self-starter, it can be difficult to reconcile these various notions. It is better if leaders can come to a consensus on a single status report.

Of course, there will always be discrepancies in the viewpoints of different leaders. However, disagreements can always be…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Market Entry the Introduction of
Words: 9989 Length: 27 Document Type: Term Paper

Com. In case of several companies, enhancing customer relationships is among the most capable features of e-commerce. However, whereas the Internet has presented the consent of a novel method to draw and communicate with the customer, hardly few enterprises have discovered a method to efficiently manage interactions with their customers on the Internet. (David, 2000) The real skill is involved in making the device suitable to accomplishment of the business strategy

Advertising and Word of Mouth
Words: 9576 Length: 22 Document Type: Research Proposal

(Snyder & DeBono quoted in Kjeldal 2003, Introduction section, ¶ 6). The results from the study Kjeldal (2003) conducted with 70 participants in two stages suggest that the word association responses high self-monitors (HSMs) produce reflect selective activation of a personally meaningful, experiential, system. The responses low self-monitors (LSMs) produce, on the other hand, indicate an intellective factual system. 2. Decision Making Process Theories Dr. Bonnie Halpern-Felsher (2009), an Associate Professor at

Mcdonald's Integrated Marketing Campaign This Paper Is
Words: 12619 Length: 48 Document Type: Dissertation

McDonald's Integrated Marketing Campaign This paper is divided into two distinct sections. The first chapter is based on literature reviews of various scholarly works that are related to the topic of integrated marketing campaign that are also relevant to the McDonald marketing campaign that was created to celebrate the inherent democracy of the McDonald's brand. The first chapter is further divided into three parts; the first section mainly focus on advertising

Latinos -- Introduction It Is
Words: 8953 Length: 28 Document Type: Dissertation

273). And Vela-Gude's article offers several of the main points of this paper's research; the services must be ready, and the counselors must be thoroughly informed and knowledgeable about the cultural implications as well as the academic realities facing those Latino students (2009). Racism Against Latinos This paper alludes to the high number of Latinos in California and Texas, but according to the Southern Poverty Law Center's research, the South is home

Consumer Perceptions Toward Personal Behavior
Words: 6548 Length: 19 Document Type: Multiple Chapters

During the survey of participants, the researcher investigates: Thai online game players' personal perceptions of online games; significant reasons that motivate the participants to play online games; factors that motivate participants to choose an online game; participants' opinions of digital society Affects of playing online games in real world. Study Objectives Objective 1 Conduct a thorough review of literature relating to online games and online game players in general, seeking specific information related to Thailand but also

Jack Welch Leadership Strategies
Words: 9411 Length: 25 Document Type: Term Paper

Jack Welch Leadership Strategies Jack Welch is rated as the greatest CEO of the current generation and one of the greatest business leaders of all times. The legendary leader, donned the top post in General Electric (GE) from April 1981 to September 2001, taking the company from mediocre levels to the very top levels, in the process turning the very basic concepts on which businesses were run till then. When he

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now