Verified Document

Business Ethics Drucker's Approach To Business Ethics Essay

Business Ethics Drucker's approach to business ethics revolves around the belief that business people are rational actors who, as agents for the shareholders, will evaluate all decisions on a cost-benefit basis. His view of business builds upon and only somewhat contrasts with that of Milton Friedman, who in 1971 famously espoused that the "social responsibility of business is to increase its profits." This paper will analyze these two views, showing how they are similar and how they are different from one another.

Although Friedman's editorial has been distilled into its pithy headline, his view on the subject of business ethics was complex. Friedman viewed business managers -- executives -- under the agency theory whereby they would be accountable only to the shareholders. Under this view, managers would and should only focus on enhancing shareholder wealth as the underlying philosophy of their actions. Friedman allowed, however, that the actions under this dictum should still be within the bounds of common ethics. This is essentially a Kantian perspective, where Friedman understands business to be bound by the general ethics that prevail in society -- the categorical imperative -- as defined by the legal system. Thus, the pursuit of profit for Friedman was constrained by the need to adhere to laws and common ethical standards.

Drucker's view was similar to that of Friedman, but with significant and noteworthy alterations. Drucker's view remained rooted in agency theory, in that the executives had a role that was to act as agents for the shareholder. In this role, Drucker posited, business leaders would make decisions "as a cost-benefit calculation." Drucker therefore viewed executive decision-making differently from Friedman in that he viewed such decisions as strictly rational, in the economic sense. Drucker did not subscribe to the idea...

As a result, business leaders could make a decision that would benefit shareholders in the short run but perhaps not in the long run, a function of the decision to focus rather myopically on short run returns.
One of the key differences between Friedman and Drucker is the notion of common ethics. Friedman believed that a common set of ethics should prevail, even over and above the pursuit of profit. His essentially Kantian view evidences a much different view of the relationship between the business entity and the world than that which Drucker envisioned. Friedman not only viewed the shareholders as a stakeholder, but also understood the role of externalities in managerial decision-making. Friedman was an economic, whereas Drucker was a management scholar, so the notion of externalities came more naturally to Friedman.

Friedman's understanding of externalities gave way to his general understanding of stakeholders. He understood that the rational manager must balance the needs of many different stakeholders. When Friedman wrote his paper, the question had arisen of business' obligations to society. Friedman's response was that while there was some degree of obligation to various internal and external stakeholders, the most important stakeholder remained the shareholders, as they had their money in the game, so to speak. Yet the implication, policy wise, is that Friedman argued that if certain specific externalities are not addressed, the shareholders will suffer. Friedman was arguing against charitable contributions from business, which was a hot button issue at the time. However, Friedman's point was in a general sense that once the most important stakeholders -- the shareholders -- were taken care of,…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Friedman, M. (1970). The social responsibility of business is to increase its profits. New York Times Magazine. Retrieved October 31, 2010 from http://www.colorado.edu/studentgroups/libertarians/issues/friedman-soc-resp-business.html

Drucker, P. (1981). Can there be business ethics? The Public Interest (Spring, 1981).
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Ethics and Management and Ethics
Words: 17336 Length: 55 Document Type: Research Proposal

Therefore, corporations have had to change their viewpoints and start looking at the long-term consequences of their behavior, as well as looking at the bottom line. Businesses also have to be concerned because consumers have also become aware of environmental concerns, and many consumers are demanding earth-friendly products and have shown a willingness to pay more money to competitors who observe environmentally-friendly practices. Interestingly enough, this demand has given rise

Business and Society
Words: 2361 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

Business and Society: The Microsoft Case "Microsoft" is one of the most well-known and highly diversified computer software manufacturing organizations of the world, founded in 1975 by Bill Gates. Only after five years of its foundation, this company earned $8 million and this success has continued to date. It is still run by its founder and its success story continues, which has made it one of the most famous organization of

Regulating Business Vs. Self-Regulation
Words: 1314 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

contract between society and business are, in fact, changing in substantial and important ways. Business is being asked to assume broader responsibilities to society than ever before, and to serve a wider range of human values...In as much as business exists to serve society, its future will depend on the quality of management's response to the changing expectations of the public."-from an editorial in Business Week Magazine Discuss the social

Ethical Perspectives Alahmad Friedman Vs. Drucker Murphy
Words: 2579 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

CSR Contrasting Different Vantage Points Regarding the Role of CSR and Business Ethics Introduction to Corporate Social Responsibility Review of the Variety of Ethical Systems Contemporary Vantage Points Corporate social responsibilities as well as business ethics have served as hotly contested issues over the last few decades. There has yet to be a consensus reached, to say the least, as to what there composition should look like or even if they are necessary academic pursuits

Futurist Kings: Welch and Drucker
Words: 2667 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

We have come full circle to the days of local businesses, but geography has been eliminated as a barrier to communication. Companies are now expected to contribute to their local economy and culture. Whatever a company does at home will be broadcast to the world, positive or negative. Wal-Mart is highly criticized for its low wages, even though the company admits it does not expect to retain entry level

Leadership Behavioral Approach "Leadership Is the Lifting
Words: 1821 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Leadership Behavioral Approach "Leadership is the lifting of people's vision to a higher sight, the raising of their performance to a higher standard, and the building of their personality beyond its normal limitations" (Drucker, 1985). Ability to inspire others in a shared vision is one of the quality features of a leader. Leaders have cleared visions and communicate these visions to their subordinates to enhance corporate values. The objective of this essay

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now