Verified Document

Budgeting Prior To The Classical Term Paper

.. discretion as a practical matter" (1988, p. 78). Wildavsky's was not critical of classical budgeting theory. He was more in favor of the concept of incrementalism that was a vital part of classical budgeting. He felt that incrementalism was superior to other budgeting approaches because it "increases agreement among the participants" (1984, p. 136) and also because it could reduce "burden of calculation" (1984, p. 136). Wildavsky went on to say that: "Clinging to last year's agreements is enormously economical of critical resources . . . which would be seriously depleted if all or most past agreements were reexamined yearly." (1984, p. 217).

The classical budgeting model proved efficient and practical for many decades but it lost its appeal in mid-20th century when a general trend towards excessive spending took over. This trend was observed all over the world and the main reason for the scope of government's responsibilities that had increased significantly after the two World Wars. Budgets began growing to alarming proportions and between 1965 and 1984 it grew 20 points in OECD countries. But revenues were not growing at the same rate. This was the case in the U.S. too where at the beginning of 1980s, federal budget was found "relatively uncontrollable" (Schick 1990). Social welfare measures had also had a serious impact on spending. These programs which began during the Johnson era were greatly expanded in 1970s thus causing serious burden on the budget. While an attempt to control these expenditures was made still by 1980s, Social Security as well as Medicare and Medicaid programs which had been started in 1965 consumed 6% of the GDP. Along with these, government was also unwilling to reduce domestic expenditure. During 1970s, Reagan refused to cut defense spending which went to a record high during his presidency.

Incrementalism failed to provide a sound theoretical framework in these conditions. The yearly model was widely accepted but the behaviors that were...

By 1970s incrementalism was completely discarded as budgets continued to grow excessively.
Another major shift was noticed in the annularity concept. Though budgets are to be developed on year to year basis, there has yet to be a year in which Congress followed this rule completely. Congress has often violated this rule by delaying appropriations. Roy Meyers notes: "Late appropriations have been routine for decades" (Meyers 1997, 26) The trend was highly noticeable in 1960s when most of the appropriation were delayed. In 1977 this tardy behavior improved only when the beginning of fiscal year was postponed. Another important development that shattered the annularity feature was the sudden and unexplained shut-downs of government departments. This led to serious delays, throwing the entire system into disarray and causing problems for employees. These types of shut-downs were unheard of before 1980s but between 1981 and 1985 alone, federal agencies were shut-down six times. Similar behavior was witnessed in 1995-1996 during the famous Gingrich-Clinton conflict. (Meyers, 1997)

These were some of the major changes that occurred in 1960s and later that accounted for the change in budgeting model. Classical budgeting couldn't possibly survive in these conditions and thus it was quickly replaced by other budgeting models as government expenditure began growing steadily.

References

1. Caiden, Naomi. 1982. "The Myth of the Annual Budget." Public Administration Review 42 (6):516 -- 523.

2. Meyers, Roy T. 1997, Late Appropriations and Government shutdowns: Frequency causes, consensus and remedies. Public Budgeting and Finance. 25:38-45

3. Schick, Allen. 1980. Congress and Your Money. Washington: Urban Institute.

4. Schick, Allen. 1990. The Capacity to Budget. Washington: Urban Institute.

5.…

Sources used in this document:
References

1. Caiden, Naomi. 1982. "The Myth of the Annual Budget." Public Administration Review 42 (6):516 -- 523.

2. Meyers, Roy T. 1997, Late Appropriations and Government shutdowns: Frequency causes, consensus and remedies. Public Budgeting and Finance. 25:38-45

3. Schick, Allen. 1980. Congress and Your Money. Washington: Urban Institute.

4. Schick, Allen. 1990. The Capacity to Budget. Washington: Urban Institute.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

California State Government Budget Deficit
Words: 1298 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

working life of a grade school teacher. The author shadowed a first grade teacher for a full work week and then recorded her observations and findings. The author also included what the experience taught her and how the experience will be used in the future. There were five sources used to complete this paper. Before I shadowed a first grade teacher for 40 hours I had a preconceived idea about

Gilgamesh to Odysseus: Near Eastern Motifs in Greek Mythology
Words: 2758 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Greek Mythology When the clay tablets that comprise the Akkadian / Old Babylonian Epic of Gilgamesh were first pieced together and translated by scholars in the nineteenth century, some aspects of the ancient text seemed remarkably familiar. There was, for example, the account of a great flood, with only a pair of survivors, Utnapishtim and his wife: "How is it that one man has saved himself? / No breath of life

Project Management History of Project
Words: 3534 Length: 12 Document Type: Essay

The study of physics, optics and biology of the eye contributed to the development of the quadrant and sextant. The Islamic world also created the concept of a library. The Crusades of the eleventh century brought the learning of the Islamic world to Europe unfortunately this information was acquired by the act of war. The Crusades also increased the flow of trade, bringing new spices, gemstones and foods to Europe.

Theories Tactics Methods and Techniques
Words: 24173 Length: 76 Document Type: Term Paper

EDSE 600: History and Philosophy of Education / / 3.0 credits The class entitled, History and Philosophy of Education, focused on the origin of education and the "philosophical influences of modern educational theory and practice. Study of: philosophical developments in the Renaissance, Reformation, and revolutionary periods; social, cultural and ideological forces which have shaped educational policies in the United States; current debates on meeting the wide range of educational and social-emotional

Mind Mapping of Public Administration
Words: 3578 Length: 12 Document Type: Research Paper

Public Administration Mind Map PA concepts decision-making, communication, public relations, supervision, coordination, unity of command, authority, leadership, Theoretical Perspectives: modern theories: behavioral approach of individual and organizational goals; social-psychological theory X and Y of McGregor; comparative PA by Riggs; developmental administration by Weidner; new PA by Minnowbrook. Historical context PA as a discipline began at the end of the th century, with basis from different administrative perspectives from philosophy, economic, behavioral, political, and social of the

Teaching Ethics and Values in Public Administration
Words: 3701 Length: 12 Document Type: Essay

Goals of a Public Administrator The implementation of the policies devised by the government is referred to as public administration. Moreover, public administration is also a discipline that is taught in many higher education institutions. This discipline is based on the studies that revolve around the aforementioned implementation and therefore it prepares the civil servants that would be working for the public service in the future (Frederickson, 1997). The fundamental goal

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now