Verified Document

Bruce J. Malina's Timothy, Paul's Book Review

Paradoxically, while the entirety of Molina's book argues that a sociological, network-centric analysis of the New Testament is necessary to understand the spread of Jesus groups in the first century AD, Molina does not pay much attention to the sociological and cultural details which organized interpersonal relationships in the first century AD. Aside from broad conceptions of in-group/out-group relations as they apply to Jews centered around Jerusalem and those "Greek" Jews of which Paul and Timothy are likely part, Molina does not examine the contextual realities that would have informed and constrained Paul and Timothy's relationship. In other words, Paul and Timothy's travels throughout the Mediterranean were likely organized by a far more complex set of interpersonal standards than those organizing the interactions between coworkers on an extended business trip. Thessalonica is not Toledo, and the institution of churches practicing an offshoot, apocalyptic Judaism seems a far cry from regional sales calls. It seems that Molina discusses Paul and Timothy's working relationship in relatively "modern" terms as way of making the oftentimes obscure functioning of early Christianity more accessible, but in doing so, he glosses over details that seem intrinsic to an understanding of the spread of Pauline Christianity.

he book assumes Paul and Timothy's success, and so rather than examine what specific, individual facets of their social network made them so successful...

Of course, this may be beyond the intended scope of the book, as Molina's analysis hints at itself being only an introductory examination as to the sociological underpinnings of Paul's missionary work, but nonetheless, it runs the risk of selling itself short by failing to engage its object of study in more detail.
Bruce J. Molina's Timothy: Paul's Closest Associate examines Timothy as part of a larger generational struggle regarding the legacy of Jesus following his death. Molina locates Timothy, and Paul, in a second generation of Jesus groups which made it goal the spread of Christianity to pockets of Jews living in predominantly Gentile regions. Timothy was especially suited for this goal, as his cultural background made his particularly adept at conferring with churches in various regions. However, Molina's analysis only goes so far, and in his efforts to discuss Timothy in large-scale, sociological terms, he manages to obscure relevant details concerning the particular standards of interpersonal relationships during the establishment of the early Christian church.

Malina, Bruce J. Timothy: Paul's Closest Associate. Collegeville, MN: Order of Saint Benedict,

2008. Print.

Sources used in this document:
Bruce J. Molina's Timothy: Paul's Closest Associate examines Timothy as part of a larger generational struggle regarding the legacy of Jesus following his death. Molina locates Timothy, and Paul, in a second generation of Jesus groups which made it goal the spread of Christianity to pockets of Jews living in predominantly Gentile regions. Timothy was especially suited for this goal, as his cultural background made his particularly adept at conferring with churches in various regions. However, Molina's analysis only goes so far, and in his efforts to discuss Timothy in large-scale, sociological terms, he manages to obscure relevant details concerning the particular standards of interpersonal relationships during the establishment of the early Christian church.

Malina, Bruce J. Timothy: Paul's Closest Associate. Collegeville, MN: Order of Saint Benedict,

2008. Print.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Exegesis to Understand 2 Corinthians As a
Words: 2363 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Exegesis To understand 2 Corinthians as a letter, one must first understand the context in which it was written. This was Paul's second letter to the Christian church at Corinth. His first letter had been less than kind, admonishing the Corinthian church for what Paul saw as many deficiencies in their manner of living and worship. As might be expected, the original letter was not exactly welcome by the Corinthians, and

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now