Verified Document

Britain: The Cultural Identity Of Term Paper

A much more current view of nationalism than in Anderson might read as follows: The national world order is a distinct from, and in opposition to, other world orders. It claims, and effectively controls, all land surface on Earth. The national world order is an autonomy-minimizing world order. It sets rigid limits on which states are legitimate, and in effect suppresses all non-nation states, and refuses to grant them superiority or soveriengty.

States are historically linked to one single tangible territory. Despite its association with war, a world order of nation states minimizes territorial conflict - at least compared to a world of expansionist universalist states (empires of conquest).

State formation is limited to one type of group: nations or peoples. These groups have distinct characteristics: permanence, transgenerationality, and long-term convergence around a core culture that survives temporary change.

In consequence, states in the national world order have the following characteristics:

1) they are permanent: no temporary states exist, although...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

Symbolic culture is therefore important: no nation state has existed without national symbols, and none will.
3) the states codify activities and norms uniformly over the territory - laws, administrative semi-law, national standards, cultural policy, spatial planning. Nation states are definitely more than 'imagined communities'. This prong of the theory despites such states'-rights regimes such as the United States because of federalism.

In general, Anderson's world-view in Imagined Communities does not give enough credence to the fact that nationalism is far more than reactionary; it is natural and essential, and a pervasive development over time that has steered the course of history from England to Latin America.

A more modern view of nationalism is much more successful, as demonstrated in Wilson's work. Indeed we need to move "beyond" imagined communities to understand our world and its communities.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now