Verified Document

Brady Act Research Paper

Brady Act Policy Evaluation of the Brady Act

The United States has struggled to curtail its distinct cultural vulnerability to gun violence through a combination of public information campaigns, criminal rehabilitation programs and federal legislation. To date, it remains unclear exactly what the impact of these efforts has been. This is especially true where legislative policy is concerned. The debate over gun control in the United States tends to invoke passionate response from people on both sides of the debate. Perhaps this was never better evidenced then in 1994 when President Clinton authorized the Brady Handgun Violence Prevention Act. Named for the bodyguard of former President Ronald Reagan who sustained paralyzing injuries from the 1981 presidential assassination attempt, the Brady Act was designed to create sweeping changes in how firearms may be purchased as well as who may lawfully purchase them.

Unfortunately, today, almost 20 years after the passage of the Brady Act, it remains difficult to measure the exact success of the legislation in actually reducing gun fatalities and gun violence. According to a wide array of sources consulted on the subject, the perceived success of the legislation largely depends on how one chooses to measure it.

Brady Act:

The outcome of a policy evaluation on the Brady Act is highly contingent on the metrics chosen for assessment. Indeed, as the article by Cook (2000) would point out with the legislation passing the half-decade mark, the advent of background checks would have an absolute and measurable impact on the number of people who are able to purchase handgun. Cook notes that by 2000, the federal law was in effect in 32 states (whereas 18 states already held similar laws in place at the state government level) and that in these participating states, statistically...

Cook observes that there is a "large number of adults with felony convictions, histories of mental illness, or other disqualifying characteristics who are blocked from buying handguns from licensed gun dealers in the 32 Brady states (with a total of around 44,000 such denials in 1996 alone)." (Cook, p. 1)
This finding would suggest that the Brady Act has been successfully achieving the aim of preventing firearms from falling into the wrong hands. That number would increase in the ensuing years as well. Senator Carl Levin (2005), a strong advocate for the landmark gun control legislation, noted that in the year 2004, the background check program would prevent 126,000 unsuitable candidates from purchasing handguns. By this same year, Levin reports, more that 1.2 million total applicants had been denied the right to purchase a gun from a federally licensed dealer because of past convictions for violent offenses, a history of mental illness or past or standing restraining orders. (Levin, p. 1)

These application rejections occur under the terms of the Firearm Inquiry Statistics (FIST) Program. Here, "data are collected directly from state agencies conducting background checks and from local checking agencies and include the number of firearm applications made to the agency, firearm applications rejected by the agency, and the reasons for rejection. Data." (BJS, p. 1) This data informs findings such as that by Senator Levin that 80% of all individuals rejected for handgun ownership are shown to have a serious criminal background or other truly compelling reason for rejection.

At first glance, this seems to suggest that both the Brady Act and its subordinate FIST program are successful in nature. However,…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited:

Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS). (2013). Data Collection: Firearm Inquiry Statistics (FIST) Program. Bjs.gov.

Butterfield, F. (2000). Study Disputes Success of the Brady Law. The New York Times.

Cook, P.J. (2000). Has the Brady Act Been Successful? Duke Today.

Levin, C. (2005). The Success of the 1994 Brady Act. Levin.senate.gov.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

A New Look at Implementation of the Brady Act
Words: 4939 Length: 17 Document Type: Term Paper

Corrections/Police -- Criminal Justice -- The Brady Act Seven-Stage Checklist for Program/Policy Planning and Analysis The Seven Stage Checklist for Program/Policy Planning and Analysis was employed to examine The Brady Act. In Stage 1, Analyzing the Problem: the problem was found to be at least four serious gaps in the existing Brady Act. Those gaps include: the lack of required background checks for all gun sales, including private sales at gun shows

Brady Bill the Brady Handgun
Words: 1676 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

But, even though we have the Brady Bill, homicides keep going up. Critics of the Brady Bill suggest that this means that the Brady Bill doesn't work and we ought to get rid of it. However, what it really means is that we need to do even more to strengthen gun control measures. For example, the Brady Bill ought to include sales by non-dealers as well as sales by

Campus Security Act of 1990 Clery Act
Words: 5610 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

Clery Act The Freedom Information Act of 2002 reported 2,351 occurrences of forcible sex offenses on campus and 1,670 in residence halls; 2,953 aggravated assaults on campus; 2,147 robberies on campus and 29,256 burglaries also on campus; and 1,098 arsons on campus in that year alone. This was the summary of campus crime statistics released by the U.S. Department of Education (Security on Campus 2004). This document and national studies reveal the

States Rights Vs. National Government
Words: 1485 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

RIGHTS VS. NATIONAL LAWS National laws formulated and implemented by the federal government have often been criticized for their centralizing effect and for restraining/restricting the power of state laws. In a republican form of government, state laws have enormous significance as this form of government allows "people . . . To pass their own laws in virtue of the legislative power reposed in representative bodies, whose legitimate acts may be

Impact of the Gun Control on the States
Words: 3770 Length: 13 Document Type: Research Paper

United States, in accordance with crime and violence, has been having highest rates of crime and violence in the world, and largely most of them violence are related to gun. U.S. Department of Justice has indicated that in the United States, violence related to guns consists of the largest violence rate. For example, back in year 1995. Homicides who were involved in gun violence were about 68% out of which

Gun Control
Words: 1587 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Proposition Non-Sense Crime Drugs: A Policy Guide Proposition #24: Attempts to ban the possession of handguns, or certain kinds of guns, are not a viable option for reducing crime. According to sociologist Samuel Walker: "People intent upon committing a crime are particularly motivated to obtain a gun. In short, it is not very efficient or sensible to try to control ownership of guns by the public at large when the real problem is

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now