Verified Document

Borderline Leadership" Discusses The Need For Policy Term Paper

¶ … Borderline Leadership" discusses the need for policy change regarding immigration. The form of reasoning used in this article is solidly utilitarian. The author urges the White House to take solid steps toward creating "realistic and enforceable" legislation to curb illegal immigration, and the federal government should "tailor the law to economic reality." The concept of economic need is the underlying reason used by the editor to support his view on immigration policy. Furthermore, the author refers to immigrants several times as being "needed" to maintain the American economy. The greatest good for the greatest number, according to the author, would be to change immigration laws to allow for more migrant workers. However, twice the author slips slightly from his or her strictly utilitarian perspective, as when he or she discusses the high school student illegal immigrants. Referring to a judge's "sensible step of blocking their deportation," the author suggests that permitting the students to stay was a moral imperative. To punish the two students for having crept over the border when they were two and seven years old would have been an immoral decision from a deontological perspective. Similarly, when the author mentions the "hundreds of migrant workers who die each year crossing the desert in search of work," he or she hints that all human beings, illegal immigrants or not, have an ingrained moral right to live and work according to their needs. However, "Borderline Leadership"...

In fact, the author's stance on permitting the students to remain in the country is also utilitarian because of the allusion to their being "honors" students on a trip for a high school science competition. By inserting this detail, the author suggests that those two individuals might grow up to contribute to the greater good of the United States economy by becoming productive wage earners.
Illegal immigrants are discussed as having both natural and posited rights: when the author discusses the unwitting illegal immigrant honors students and the hundreds of migrants who die each year crossing the border, he or she assumes the rights of all persons to some form of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, are natural and innate. Moreover, even though the high school students did not initially have a legal right to education in America, they do since a judge permitted them to stay in the country. Therefore, the author suggests that all persons have the natural right to education, and that all young people have the natural right to escape the consequences of their parents' errors, or issues that were beyond their control. On the other hand, the author also discusses the relevance of posited rights in relation to the issue of illegal immigration. Technically, illegal immigrants have no posited rights because of their alien status. In fact, the editorial elucidates the essential conflict between natural…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Australia As an International Citizen
Words: 2786 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

One of Kilby's contentions, however, was that Australia's hypothesis that increased economic growth would result to poverty reduction is a framework that is not responsive to the realities of poor, developing countries, which are almost always the recipients of AusAID's aid program. The author's claim is that AusAID's thrust -- that economic growth will result to reduced poverty -- is developed from a neoliberalist framework, which is not as responsive

Setting the Stage for the Group Psychological
Words: 4820 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

Setting the stage for the group Psychological intervention might be most efficient when females start modification by leaving the abuser and get in a shelter. Shelters are an essential resource for victims because they offer females and kids security and link them with social, legal, and financial resources (Dutton, 1992). Furthermore, battered females in shelters have a greater threat for PTSD than those who do not look for shelter (Jones

Children, Grief, and Attachment Theory
Words: 22384 Length: 75 Document Type: Term Paper

Figure 1 portrays three of the scenes 20/20 presented March 15, 2010. Figure 1: Heather, Rachel, and Unnamed Girl in 20/20 Program (adapted from Stossel, 2010). Statement of the Problem For any individual, the death of a family member, friend, parent or sibling may often be overwhelming. For adolescents, the death of person close to them may prove much more traumatic as it can disrupt adolescent development. Diana Mahoney (2008), with the

Ethics of Group Therapy Ethical Concepts Guiding
Words: 5650 Length: 15 Document Type: Essay

Ethics of Group Therapy Ethical Concepts Guiding Group Psychiatric Therapy Practice Ethically inclined group psychotherapists use moral codes produced from their professions and from associations dedicated to the furtherance of group psychiatric therapy like a modality. Good examples from the former would be the Ethical Concepts of Psychologists and Code of Conduct (American Psychological Association [APA], 2002) and also the NASW Code of Ethics (National Association of Social Workers [NASW], 1999). The

Scientology Introducing a New Religious Movement, One
Words: 3731 Length: 12 Document Type: Research Paper

Scientology Introducing a New Religious Movement, one must be as objective as possible. I, for instance, could choose to tell you that L. Ron Hubbard founded the Church of Scientology in 1954 and marketed it as an organization for social reform that essentially became the global force it is today, with (young, professional, stylish, racially-diverse) adherents providing positive sound bites on Scientology.org that promote (in naturalistic, community-oriented settings) the religion as

Application of a Pedagogic Model to the Teaching of Technology to...
Words: 60754 Length: 230 Document Type: Dissertation

Pedagogic Model for Teaching of Technology to Special Education Students Almost thirty years ago, the American federal government passed an act mandating the availability of a free and appropriate public education for all handicapped children. In 1990, this act was updated and reformed as the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, which itself was reformed in 1997. At each step, the goal was to make education more equitable and more accessible to

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now