Verified Document

Black History And Black Identity: Book Review

He thus rejects Afrocentrism as a fundamental political act of self-definition by American Blacks along with the term as an African Diaspora to describe slavery, given that the slave trade dispersed members of Black tribes in Africa and in other areas of the Western world. Black Americans, once again, have produced a unique cultural legacy and suffered unique historical injustices, as distinct from the injustices of colonialism. Also, even before slavery, Africans lived all over the world but for reasons distinct than those originating with the Middle Passage. While well-intentioned as Afrocentric ideology "reflects the renewed pride of black people in shaping a future based on the concept of one African people living in the African Diaspora, "the notion of Diaspora fails to convey a sense of the "vast global presence" of black Africans and their descendants and "the African Diaspora concept, as it is usually used, puts black Africans into Western hemispheric history and reality much too late in human history. Additionally, Black Americans, although they may feel a sense of kinship with Africans, do not have the same geopolitical interests, necessarily, as Africans living in Africa, and Africa is not a homogeneous identity block. While "events on the African continent and in the African Diaspora [Western Hemisphere] have profoundly affected Afro-American thought and action... An interest in the political objective of unity between black Africans and black people of the "African Diaspora" should not be permitted to supersede" Black interests and concerns in America. In contrast to the concept of the Diaspora, Wright instead suggests the term "African Extensia" or the extension of African contributors into other spheres of the world, without denying the fusing and blending of cultures as an alternative framework for Black studies. This Extensia was partially compelled by slavery, of course but "could be said had its origins millions of years ago when prehistoric creatures initially left Africa and migrated to the continents of the world."

Many modern Black historians will no doubt resist the contentions of Wright that in fact contemporary Black historiography has actually disrupted and confused Black history from its original focus, given its blending of...

Colonialism in African and White racism in America is linked, they might respond. But Wright would respond: "Black historians for the most part, and this is also true of other kinds of Black intellectuals for the most part, are utterly careless when it comes to projecting the identity of Black people, invariably eschewing the historical evidence." Black identity is used conveniently to assert a theory, in other words, rather than with consistency and the uniqueness of the experience must not be undervalued, although parallels and commonalities may be drawn with colonialism.
Wright's assertion about the need for division between Blackness and Africanness may be too extreme -- it is hard not to argue that a lack of sensitivity towards suffering in Africa, versus suffering in Europe, for example, has no ties to the history of racism in the United States. Furthermore, what of African immigrants who maintain strong ties to their homeland, yet still have the experience of being Black in America? If Black identity is based upon a divorce between the Black experience in Africa and an inability to tie one's roots back to Africa, this might define many Black Americans out of Wright's definition of Black history.

In the future, it will be interesting to see if the new Black president differs in his relation to Africa, to see if there is a marked difference that might call into question some of Wright's definitions of "Third-Wave Black historiography." At times, Wright's obsession with excluding certain individuals from Blackness becomes troubling, and more of a verbal exercise than something that seems really helpful from the point-of-view of a policy-maker, historian, or even a human being. Still, his challenge of an easy assertion of Afro-Centric pride by those who have not really explored what ties to Africa mean makes his work a valuable contribution and argument in favor of the continued usefulness of the term 'Blackness.'

W.D. Wright, Black History and Black Identity: A Call for a New Historiography. (New York: (Praeger, 2002), p.1.

Wright, p.20.

Wright, p.1.

Wright, pp.17-18.

Wright, pp.53-54.

Wright, p.37.

Wright, p.65.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Black Culture Films Black Culture Documentaries Quite
Words: 619 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Black Culture Films Black Culture Documentaries Quite often and particularly in the United States, it is commonplace to understand the black cultural experience largely through the lenses of slavery and the Civil Rights movement. And to be certain, these are aspects of the experience that have left indelible imprints on black identity. However, as the collection of documentaries assessed here denotes, the black cultural experience is diverse and nuanced in a way

Black Church the Redemptive Role
Words: 16899 Length: 50 Document Type: Dissertation

It will use historical evidence to examine the role of the church is a spiritual entity. It will examine the role of the church as a political entity throughout changing political landscapes. It will explore the role of the church as a social service provider with regards to the importance of this role in helping black people to redeem themselves in light of historical cultural atrocities that they have

Black Rednecks and White Liberals
Words: 901 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Furthermore, he gave a comparison of the northern blacks and southern blacks, demonstrating as to how the northern blacks were more educated, gained higher on tests, and had a higher graduation rate. The reason was because 'north' had 4x more schools than the south (Dutch, 2005). He commented that racism in the north began when ghetto blacks moved to north, being that both whites and blacks were not much comfortable

Black Identity As Seen in The Tempest by William Shakespeare & Oroonoko...
Words: 2280 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Imagining the Colonial Subject:The Tempest by William Shakespeare & Oroonoko by Aphra BehnIn the sixteenth century, individuals of Black ancestry or individuals from non-European contexts were often portrayed in British literature, as seen in works such as The Tempest (1610-1611) by William Shakespeare & Oroonoko, or The Royal Slave (1688) by Aphra Behn. Nonwhite individuals were symbolically significant, even in the works of white European authors. However, the portrayal of

Black Vernacular English
Words: 1808 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

African-American Vernacular English can be described as an assortment of American English that is mostly used by urban-working class and mostly bi-dialectical middle-class black Americans. The language is also commonly known as Black Vernacular English or Black English. In some cases, particularly outside the academic community, it is referred to as Ebonics given its distinctive features and similarities with other non-standard English varieties. The similarities with other varieties are evident

Identity Politics Indigeneity
Words: 1827 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Unpacking Identity Politics and Indigeneity Introduction In recent years, discussions surrounding identity politics and indigeneity have gained significant traction within academic and activist circles. These concepts are deeply intertwined, as they highlight the complexities of individual and collective identities in the context of marginalized and oppressed groups. Identity politics, as a concept, refers to the ways in which individuals construct and assert their identities based on shared experiences of discrimination, systemic inequalities,

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now