Verified Document

Biomedical Ethics Case Study

Biomedical Ethics The case of Dr. Nancy Morrison and Mr. Mills is an important one, as it forces the legal system to tackle the question of Euthanasia and end of life care. The important questions raised by this case are what is the extent of a doctor's responsibilities towards a patient that is in pain and dying, can a doctor make a judgment call and end a patient's life prematurely; can a patient make that decision on their own? Is it ethical to let a patient die in agonizing pain for hours? Also, is it ethical to make that decision as a healthcare provider? The paper will examine the specifics of the case, the extent of the suffering Mr. Mills underwent, and the ethical and moral issues associated with Dr. Morrison's actions.

The specifics of the case are as follows, Mr. Mills was admitted to the Moncton General Hospital in April 1996 for cancer of the esophagus (Sneiderman & Deutscher, p.3). The cancer was removed via surgery but due to necrosis there was leakage of gastrointestinal fluid which infected other tissues. Mr. Mills underwent three further surgeries in Moncton before he was transferred to the QEII in Halifax and underwent another six surgeries, for a total of ten. Mr. Mills lost 42 pounds between October 15 and November 6 and his infections were so severe that healing from his surgeries became unattainable. Mr. Mills was "heavily sedated, on narcotics, on antibiotics, multiple IVs running. Probably in the realm of 10 tubes in him, fully catheter arterial line, central lines for administration of antibiotics, and tubes in his stomach and tubes in...

His condition continued to quickly deteriorate; on October 15th he was admitted to the ICU and placed on a ventilator. On the 17th his doctors and family signed a DNR. When it was time to take Mr. Mills off life support, it was believed that he would pass away quickly, a means of shortening his anguish. Mr. Mills experienced an extreme shortness of breath for hours. He was administered morphine, Dilaudid, and Versed, yet his shortness of breath continued (Sneiderman & Deutscher, p.4). The nurse in charge of Mr. Mills conveyed his distress and her concerns to Dr. Morrison. Dr. Morrison administered nitroglycerine to decrease blood pressure and when his blood pressure increased after an initial drop, she administered potassium chloride. Dr. Morrison was suspended by the hospital for her actions, and the police later pressed murder charges against her.
There are several legal and ethical reasons that can be issued against Dr. Morrison's actions. First, while the patient previously mentioned wanting to die a month before expiring, he was not conscious to make a decision concerning his healthcare. Secondly, whether Dr. Morrison, willfully, committed murder and should a hospital or any healthcare setting employ healthcare providers that are willing to resort to killing a patient, despite the extreme circumstances. It is a doctor's or nurse's responsibility to look after the welfare of their patients; however what is the limit of this authority. Should a doctor determine whether a patient should live or die? (Collier &…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Collier, Carol, and Rachel Frances Christine Haliburton. Bioethics in Canada: a concise philosophical introduction. Toronto: Canadian Scholars' Press Inc., 2011. Print.

Reynolds, Sharon, Andrew B. Cooper, and Martin McKneally. "Withdrawing Life-Sustaining Treatment: Ethical Considerations." Surgical Clinics of North America 87.4 (2007): 469-480. Print.

Sneiderman, Barney, and Raymond Deutscher. "Dr. Nancy Morrison and her dying patient: a case of medical necessity." Health Law Journal 10 (2002): 1-30. Print.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Biomedical Ethics
Words: 685 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

Biomedical Ethics -- Reflection of "I Am Sam" The treatment of vulnerable population in situations of legal rights is an ever-growing dilemma. In the movie "I Am Sam," Sam is a mentally disabled father seen as unfit to care for his daughter. Because of social workers observations, the courts removed the daughter from his care. Individuals with mental disabilities, like Sam, suffer daily with basic right infringements. People are quick to

Biomedical Ethics
Words: 1254 Length: 4 Document Type: Case Study

Biomedical Ethics The Case of Scott Starson In 1999, Scott Starson was involuntarily committed to a psychiatric hospital in Ontario after he had been found not criminally responsible for two counts of uttering death threats. Starson had a history of psychiatric disorders, and had recently been diagnosed with bipolar disorder. Starson recognized his disorder and voluntarily underwent psychotherapy, but he refused any medication for the condition. Starson, a gifted theoretical physicist, believed

Biomedical Ethics
Words: 1250 Length: 4 Document Type: Case Study

Biomedical Ethics: Euthanasia Mercy killing continues to elicit debates on the moral and ethical aspects involved in conducting the act. Mercy killing, which is also called euthanasia, is a practice that medical professionals consider to assist the terminally ill patients (Huxtable 21). Terminal illnesses do not have a cure, or such conditions that have terminal consequence are irreversible. For instance, the case of Paul Mills, who was terminally ill due to

Ethics Biomedical Ethics in the Medical Profession
Words: 950 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Ethics Biomedical Ethics Ethics in the medical profession is a topic that has gained in complexity in the past three decades. As patients are able to get more information about medical procedures, as billing becomes more complex, as new healthcare reform takes place, nurses are forced to gain an understanding of more issues with regard to biomedical ethics. The book "Intervention and Reflection: Basic Issues in Medical Ethics" by Munson and Munson

Biomedical Ethics in Research
Words: 1692 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

To make sure that the prisoner's viewpoint is observed, review boards must consist of at least one inmate or inmate representative when examining such research (Kluge, 2010). Children In researches dealing with kids, government laws require that guardians or parents to give authorization. In most cases, the child may assent whenever possible. Parent's authorization is one factor of the "special protections" provided to this vulnerable segment. The need to obtain assent

Biomedical Ethics
Words: 1599 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Child Limit Laws Biomedical Ethics The debate regarding the right of having children against the importance of national family planning has raged for years. In the late 1960s, many strongly believed that a decline in fertility rates would slow population growth, especially in developing countries and thus reduce poverty. This was the popular view at the time but in the 1980s, there emerged a fresh thinking about the right to bear children.

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now