Verified Document

Barry Friedman Details The Ethical Essay

But if it wishes to stand by the stated principles of its founding and the message it attaches to its history, than profiling cannot be allowed to exist. 4) Deontological ethical systems "guide and assess our choices of what we ought to do," as opposed to suggesting what types of people we should be (Stanford, 2007). Another important distinction of deontological viewpoints is their emphasis on the motives and intentions behind an act in regards to that act's ethicality, as opposed to the consequences of that act. One narrow form of deontological ethics is moral absolutism, propagated by such thinkers as Immanuel Kant (Stanford, 2007). According to his view, acts are either moral or immoral in all situations, without any regard to the consequences (Stanford, 2007). Not all deontological viewpoints are this extreme, however it provides the clearest example of the deontological view. According to deontological ethics, acting in a moral way cannot have immoral effects.

Utilitarianism, in contrast, places all of the burden of morality on the effects of an action (Stanford, 2007). The overriding maxim of utilitarian ethics is "the greatest good for the greatest number" (Stanford, 2007). According to this view, the intention of an action is completely irrelevant to its morality, and each act must be viewed in the context of its occurrence. For instance, killing cannot be considered immoral simply on face value -- there are situations where killing one man might save many lives. According to utilitarian ethics, it would be immoral not to kill this man, whether he is the direct cause of the others' deaths or not; it is the outcome of the act (or the non-act, as the case may be) that determines morality in utilitarian ethics (Stanford, 2007).

5) Deontological ethics could both support and oppose my position on racial profiling. It could be argued that the intention of the profiling is to save lives. Because this can be generally agreed upon as a moral intention, it could be believed that...

It could also be argued, however, that the intention of the act is to discriminate based on race. From a moral absolutist standpoint, this act must be condemned in all situations, or it must be upheld in all situations. There is not enough space here to reconstruct moral arguments for the rejection of racism as moral, but it is generally accepted that racism and discrimination is immoral in most situations. If this is the case, than an absolutist deontological view would necessarily condemn racial profiling as immoral as well.
Utilitarian ethics seems, at first, to be much more clear cut on this issue. Certainly, the rights of the people that would be subjected to increased scrutiny at the airport of racial profiling were allowed to become common practice would not matter in the face of the lives that stood to be saved, from the viewpoint of utilitarian ethics. The greater good is served by preventing terrorism at almost any cost; racism is not the issue when it comes to utilitarian ethics. This does not entirely solve the issue, however. In order for utilitarian ethics to deem racial profiling moral, it would have to be established that racial profiling does in fact serve the greater good. That is, it would need to be proven reasonably likely that racial profiling is the most efficient way to prevent terrorism at airports and aboard airplanes. In my view, this has not been established, and in fact there is evidence that it is not the case. Therefore, utilitarian ethics would deem racial profiling immoral not for its racial aspects, but due to its inefficiency.

References

Fauchon, C. (2004). "Counterpoint: the case against profiling." International social review, Fall-Winter 2004.

Friedman, Barry. (2004). "Policy point-counterpoint: profiling at airports." International social review, Fall-Winter 2004.

Reddick, S. (2004). "Point: the case for profiling." International…

Sources used in this document:
References

Fauchon, C. (2004). "Counterpoint: the case against profiling." International social review, Fall-Winter 2004.

Friedman, Barry. (2004). "Policy point-counterpoint: profiling at airports." International social review, Fall-Winter 2004.

Reddick, S. (2004). "Point: the case for profiling." International social review, Fall-Winter 2004.

Stanford. (2007). Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Accessed 22 February 2009. http://plato.stanford.edu
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Business - Advertising Media Plan
Words: 1483 Length: 5 Document Type: Thesis

The aspect of Steve and Barry's marketing strategy that emphasizes comparable quality for lower prices than its competitors appeals very directly to all parents who pay for their children's clothing. Whereas teens and young adults respond most positively to any association between products and popular celebrities and sports figures endorsing them, their parents are practically oblivious to those connections, except perhaps to the extent they realize that products associated with

Interventionism From the Perspective of Realism Vs.
Words: 13409 Length: 44 Document Type: Case Study

interventionism from the perspective of realism vs. idealism. Realism is defined in relationship to states' national interests whereas idealism is defined in relation to the UN's Responsibility to Protect doctrine -- a doctrine heavily influenced by Western rhetoric over the past decade. By addressing the question of interventionism from this standpoint, by way of a case study of Libya and Syria, a picture of the realistic implications of "humanitarian

Ethics and Decision Making With
Words: 4532 Length: 15 Document Type: Thesis

In the former approach, tradable goods, money or services are exchanged between buyers and sellers at a rate that is agreeable to all parties. This approach assumes both the buyers and sellers have enough money, services or goods to have their needs met. The latter approach, public provision, is when all is available to those on an as-needed basis. The Pharmaceutical and Manufacturing Association warns that whenever there is government

Effect of Forgiveness on Health
Words: 28998 Length: 105 Document Type: Thesis

Forgiveness on human health. In its simplest form, the purpose of the study is to evaluate human psychological stress that might constitute a risk factor for heart disease. Further, the study will also evaluate the impact of forgiveness on heart disease. However, such a simple dissertation clearly demands further definition. What, exactly, do we signify when we speak of heart disease? What is properly considered as forgiveness? What impact does

Distributive and Integrative Bargaining
Words: 7428 Length: 22 Document Type: Research Paper

Realm of Legal Negotiation DISTRIBUTIVE VS. INTEGRATIVE Negotiation involves a dialogue of two or more parties or people with the intention to reach a favorable outcome. This favorable result can be for just one party or both parties involved. The integrative approach to negotiation tries to expand the "pie" to make sure everyone gets something. However, the distributive approach ensures one side "wins" and the other, "loses." The legal landscape of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now