Verified Document

Barriers To Health Care In Rural Areas Research Paper

Hughes, A., Watanabe-Galloway, S., Schnell, P., & Soliman, A. (2015) studied the differences in colorectal screening between rural-urban in Nebraska. Their investigation into the reasons behind this gap indicated a few differences, some of which were not of the expected variety. The authors found that rural residents were more likely to believe that colorectal cancer cannot be prevented, and thus they did not feel screening was worthwhile. A higher percentage of rural residents also indicated that cost was a barrier, as well as things like perceived embarrassment, perceived unpleasantness were indicators found more frequently among rural residents. The study indicates that there are definitely some cultural factors that speak to the rural-urban divide. However, they also found that people with a personal doctor had a higher rate of receiving screenings. This indicates that physician density can also play a role – people without a doctor are more likely to not receive advice to get screenings, or referrals, and these factors can definitely result in a lower rate of screening and higher rate of morbidity. An Icelandic study (Haraldsdottir, S., Gudmundsson, S., Thorgeirsson, G., Lund, S. H., & Valdimarsdottir, U. A., 2017) regarding cardiovascular disease arrived at similar conclusions. The authors found that rural areas had a higher prevalence of preventable risk factors. However, they also found that hospital discharges were more frequent in rural areas, and that this might have contributed to higher mortality rates. The underlying causal factors of higher discharge rates were not studied here, but the implication is that shorter hospital stays might be more associated with rural residents, especially if the hospital is not in their community, but may deprive them of the full range of testing that they would have received had their stay been longer.

Amponsah, W. A., Tabi, M. M., & Gibbison, G. A. (2015) looked at cardiovascular disease in rural Georgia. As was the case with the Icelandic study, they found that lifestyle factors contributed to the gap in health outcomes. Rural residents in their study generally had lower socioeconomic status, and lower socioeconomic status is associated with higher rates of cardiovascular disease. This adds to the body of evidence that health disparities between rural and urban residents are at least in part attributed to lifestyle differences.

One of the roles that physicians play is to provide medical advice and guidance for their patients. Bo Nielsen, J., Leppin, A., e Gyrd-Hansen, D., Ejg Jarbøl, D., Søndergaard, J., Veldt Larsen, P., & ... Larsen, P. V. (2017) conducted a study in Denmark to query potential gaps in preventative care as a reason for the rural-urban outcome divide. As in many of the other studies, socioeconomic factors were linked to lifestyle choices that in turn saw increased likelihood of cardiovascular disease. In their study, rural residents were more likely to smoke, have poor diets and abstain from exercise.

Campbell, D. T., Manns, B. J., Weaver, R. G., Hemmelgarn, B. R., King-Shier, K. M., & Sanmartin, C. (2017) conducted a study in Canada that was not specifically linked to the rural-urban question. They found, however, the correlation between lower socioeconomic status and higher rates of cardiovascular disease held in their study. They specifically cited that financial barriers to accessing medications and healthy food as reasons why poorer people faced higher rates of cardiovascular disease. This removes the rural-urban dynamic from the argument, but lends further support to the link between socioeconomic status and higher rates of cardiovascular disease.

In South Carolina, rural residents face further barriers, including several that are not directly linked to socioeconomic status. Some of the barriers identified for them include lack of health insurance, lack of knowledge, misperceptions and fear, and limited accessibility as reasons why rural South Carolinians do not participate in clinical trials (Kim, S., Tanner, A., Friedman, D., Foster, C., & Bergeron, C. (2014). A fairly reasonable argument can be made that these factors could easily apply to other forms of health care as well.

Where other studies looked at lifestyle factors, Allenby, A., Kinsman, L., Tham, R., Symons, J., Jones, M., & Campbell, S. (2016) took a different approach and looked at the quality of care in rural communities, to compare it to the quality of care in urban communities. There is a clear association between targeted preventative activities and practice factors....

In other words, people tend to respond if their doctor tells them that they are at risk, and that they need to make lifestyle changes in order to solve the problem. What the authors found was that "there is substantial room for enhanced cardiovascular prevention throughout rural primary care in Australia, particularly for high-risk patients." Often, only when someone is diagnosed with cardiovascular disease were they receiving lifestyle advice – so preventative care was lacking. The authors did not delve into why this preventative care might be lacking (overworked physicians, patients traveling long distances), leaving those as critical gaps in the literature.
One study that counters many of these findings is Choo, W. K., McGeary, K., Farman, C., Greyling, A., Cross, S. J., & Leslie, S. J. (2014), where the authors found that in rural Scotland the referral rates between rural and urban patients were not significantly different. However, this is one study, and findings applicable in Scotland might not be applicable in another country as health care practices can differ. That said, it is valuable to know that rural location need not inherently pose barriers to care.

Syed, S., Gerber, B., & Sharp, L. (2013) looked at transportation barriers faced by rural residents. They found that transportation barriers were often cited as issues for rural residents by looking at 61 different studies. This form of analysis does not seek to validate the view that transportation is an issue, only that it is cited by patients as an issue. The authors found that the strongest case was for people with lower incomes and the un/underinsured. The former group might find traveling for care to be a legitimate financial burden, the latter group might not be able to pay for care, but claim other reasons why they didn't seek care. It would be interesting to see the particulars of each study – rural residents cannot travel the same distance on average as urban residents for cardiovascular care, but they don't for anything else either. Why would health care be an issue and other things not? There are unanswered questions that require looking at the constituent studies in greater detail.

One of the biggest challenges in cardiovascular care is that the care usually has to be very individual-centric and personal. In particular, preventative care needs to meet these requirements because each person needs their own individual health plan to provide cardiovascular care (Harrington RA and Heidenreich PA, 2015). The rural residents who have the worst outcomes with respect to cardiovascular disease are the ones who face the biggest obstacles – they do not receive the preventative care they need, and they do not receive the individualized care that they need in order to manage their heart health.

The body of research suggests that the biggest issues for rural residents are actually lifestyle, and they are typically related to the overall lower level of incomes in rural areas. Lower socioeconomic status is associated with less healthy lifestyles, and these in turn are associated with greater incidence of cardiovascular disease. The literature also highlights that rural people may not receive the same standard of care, certainly not in terms of preventative medicine, but none of the studies in this literature review delve too deeply as to why this is. Certainly, rural residents must travel further to receive care, but they also seem to seek it out less.

This is one of the peculiarities of eh American studies. Many rural residents have greater shame about health, seek out health care at lower rates, and generally seem less comfortable discussing or dealing with their health issues. Overall, these issues speak perhaps to a greater conservativism, but this is not helpful to health outcomes, especially when coupled with already lower physician density and greater travel times.

Drawing on the literature, finding ways to encourage rural residents to adopt healthier lifestyles seems a starting point. To do this, higher income levels would help, but so would stronger relationships between rural doctors and their patients. The lack of strength is not known, but likely relates to higher transportation barriers, and in the US the lower ability to pay. Many will simply not receive any health care at all.

The literature actually does not examine the issue of specialists. It looks mainly at primary care, and that is related to preventative medicine. But the reality is that there are fewer specialists. This might not impact on morbidity…

Sources used in this document:

Abbott, L., Williams, C., Slate, E., & Gropper, S. (2018). Promoting Heart Health Among Rural African Americans. Journal Of Cardiovascular Nursing, 33(1), E8-E14. doi:10.1097/JCN.0000000000000410

Allenby, A., Kinsman, L., Tham, R., Symons, J., Jones, M., & Campbell, S. (2016). The quality of cardiovascular disease prevention in rural primary care. Australian Journal Of Rural Health, 24(2), 92-98. doi:10.1111/ajr.12224

Amponsah, W. A., Tabi, M. M., & Gibbison, G. A. (2015). Health Disparities in Cardiovascular Disease and High Blood Pressure among Adults in Rural Underserved Communities. Online Journal Of Rural Nursing & Health Care, 15(1), 185-208. doi:10.14574/ojrnhc.v15i1.351

Bo Nielsen, J., Leppin, A., e Gyrd-Hansen, D., Ejg Jarbøl, D., Søndergaard, J., Veldt Larsen, P., & ... Larsen, P. V. ( 2017). Barriers to lifestyle changes for prevention of cardiovascular disease - a survey among 40-60-year old Danes. BMC Cardiovascular Disorders, 171-8. doi:10.1186/s12872-017-0677

Campbell, D. T., Manns, B. J., Weaver, R. G., Hemmelgarn, B. R., King-Shier, K. M., & Sanmartin, C. (2017). Financial barriers and adverse clinical outcomes among patients with cardiovascular-related chronic diseases: a cohort study. BMC Medicine, 151-13. doi:10.1186/s12916-017-0788-6

Choo, W. K., McGeary, K., Farman, C., Greyling, A., Cross, S. J., & Leslie, S. J. (2014). Utilisation of a direct access echocardiography service by general practitioners in a remote and rural area - distance and rurality are not barriers to referral. Rural & Remote Health, 14(4), 1-6.

Haraldsdottir, S., Gudmundsson, S., Thorgeirsson, G., Lund, S. H., & Valdimarsdottir, U. A.(2017). Regional differences in mortality, hospital discharges and primary care contacts for cardiovascular disease Scandinavian Journal Of Public Health, 45(3), 260-268. doi:10.1177/1403494816685341

Harrington RA and Heidenreich PA. Team-Based Care and Quality: A Move Toward Evidence-Based Policy. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2015;66:1813-5.

Hughes, A., Watanabe-Galloway, S., Schnell, P., & Soliman, A. (2015). Rural-Urban Differences in Colorectal Cancer Screening Barriers in Nebraska. Journal Of Community Health, 40(6), 1065-1074. doi:10.1007/s10900-015-0032-2

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Health Care Disparity in Maryland
Words: 18449 Length: 67 Document Type: Dissertation

Figure 1 portrays the state of Maryland, the location for the focus of this DRP. Figure 1: Map of Maryland, the State (Google Maps, 2009) 1.3 Study Structure Organization of the Study The following five chapters constitute the body of Chapter I: Introduction Chapter II: Review of the Literature Chapter III: Methods and Results Chapter IV: Chapter V: Conclusions, Recommendations, and Implications Chapter I: Introduction During Chapter I, the researcher presents this study's focus, as it relates to the

Healthcare Proposal
Words: 1207 Length: 4 Document Type: Annotated Bibliography

HEALTHCARE PROPOSAL Healthcare Proposal Annotated BibliographyAbelsen, B., Strasser, R., Heaney, D., Berggren, P., Sigurosson, S., Brandstorp, H., Wakegijig, J., Forsling, N., Moody-Corbett, P., Akearok, G.H., Mason, A., Savage, C. & Nicoll, P. (2020). Plan, recruit, retain: A framework for local healthcare organizations to achieve a stable remote rural workforce. Human Resources for Health, 18. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12960-020-00502-xThe article discusses the effectiveness of The Framework for Remote Rural Workforce Stability designed to fortify

Healthcare Management Information Systems Telemedicine
Words: 3032 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

Therefore in the economic sense many institutions have been viewed to lay back. Knowledge and Expertise in Telemedicine Another challenge has to do with the limited knowledge and expertise in telemedicine as well as the need for enhanced and modified telemedicine systems. In this sense, little knowledge currently exists among medical practitioners on how to effectively and practically use various forms of telemedicine. This knowledge gap on insight into telemedicine, in

Health Care Services for the
Words: 2754 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

1903). The management goal for HCH is to improve the effectiveness of health care delivery to the homeless and indigent of Milwaukee in close partnership with the community. In this regard, the management of the HCH community health center requires careful and timely coordination between the community health care specialists, including family practice physicians and advanced practice nurses, who provide accessible primary care preventive health services. There are also management

Healthcare and Medicine in the
Words: 2981 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

The issue of grey and black markets often arose as a result of the shortages of experienced health care personnel. The system could not adapt to a flexible environment as it was led by rigid official procedures and the mentality of the people who controlled it was commanding, their vision short-sighted and hardly beneficial in such a situation (Barr and Mark, 1996). The breaking up of Soviet Union which brought

Policy Analysis Issues in Healthcare
Words: 3285 Length: 12 Document Type: Literature Review

what drives/motivates providers. In a nutshell, these authors assert that any healthcare system built on market principles is doomed to eventual crisis as payers (meaning patients by and large, whether directly or through government taxation) attempt to receive adequate care while reducing the flow of dollars to providers while providers attempt to increase the flow of dollars for the same or lower levels of care (Harrington & Estes, 2008).

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now