Verified Document

Bad Motives For Good Actions Essay

Business Ethics Something that I have found particularly interesting in Baird's textbook is the notion of "deontological" ethics. (Baird 151). This is the idea that "right" behavior or "good" behavior is about playing by the rules. However what I find really interesting about the idea is that, in some sense, it is the only way we have of getting a glimpse into the motivations of others. In some sense, a full account of the ethics of any given situation must in some way take into account someone's motives -- especially motives for compliance. Ethical behavior shouldn't be something that we adopt out of a sense of compulsion. Instead, with deontology, we are talking more about the concept of duty.

I suppose what is most interesting to me about this is the notion that there can be different reasons, good and bad, for adopting the same set of ethical principles. I'm also fascinated by the fact that sometimes a seemingly good principle can be made bad -- either because it is adopted shallowly, or because it is taken to an extreme. However, I think this is useful because deontology is, in some way, a good way to guard against only judging actions by their results, which I think is a serious error, especially in the business world. In any case, these are current ways in which Baird's approach has expanded by own ethical imagination.

Perhaps I can give a personal example. A number of years ago, I recall sitting with my grandmother and watching an interview program on the Catholic cable television network (EWTN) which was broadcasting an interview with the Catholic ethical thinker and retired philosophy professor Alice von Hildebrand. There was one example that Von Hildebrand gave which really stood out in my mind. She was discussing the importance of integrating emotion into one's moral choices, but noted that an excess of emotion could be as dangerous as the opposite. The example she gave was from an Austrian play, where a rich man discovers...

The rich man says to his servants "Throw this beggar down the steps -- his misery breaks my heart."
Now obviously from the standpoint of basic ethics there is not much complexity here -- the idea of a wealthy person having a poor one treated with violence is pretty instinctively repellent to most people. Although it is a sign of the coarsened ethical times in which we are currently living that there has been a glut of examples of the equivalent of the rich man here in what is currently America's liveliest business sector, Silicon Valley. It has seemed like 2013 and 2014 have been years in which the technological elite keep saying insensitive things about homeless people in the Silicon Valley area, and a quick Google search will reveal that the worldview Von Hildebrand was trying to capture with her example of the rich man is actually not far off from something that really gets expressed among today's business elite.

However, what made Von Hildebrand's illustration so memorable -- besides the fact that she made it clear that it was a joke that also proved a deep ethical point -- is of course the way it uses irony to demonstrate a certain kind of ethical failing. Von Hildebrand notes that the simple fact is that the rich man in this scenario is actually not immune to the sight of suffering. He is being forced to confront something about which he has a natural ethically-motivated reaction -- the sight of a poor and miserable person has an instinctive effect on the rich man, who is not hardened, and in this case has no option to look away or ignore what he sees, because it is on his own front doorstep. The joke of the example is that we are witnessing someone who is genuinely contradictory within the space of one sentence -- his capacity for being moved to pity is very real, and so is his capacity for demanding violence. For Von Hildebrand, the story here is one about too much emotional…

Sources used in this document:
References

Baird, C.A. (2012). Everyday Ethics: Making Wise Choices in a Complex World. Ethics Game Press Publishers.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Good and Evil and Contradictions
Words: 870 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Paper

The "contradictory actions" will be strictly limited to the literal statements on the pages authored by Hawthorne in order to avoid evaluation by modern standards perhaps not shared by the Puritans this story discusses c. Young Goodman Brown seems to come to the conclusion that everyone around him carries the taint of real or potential "sin" or "evil" (Hawthorne 7) which he tries to distance himself from. 3. Considering 2c the

Good and Evil: The Dual
Words: 1556 Length: 5 Document Type: Thesis

But when it comes down to the reality of the question as to whether man is good, evil or both by nature, we must heed the message contained in the New Testament which equates traits like "ungodliness," "lawlessness" and especially "evil" as being based upon "moral and spiritual depravity which links sin with Satan" (Peterson, 2004, p. 287). In this respect, man is both good and evil but has the

Bad Employee Behavior Versus Anti Union Efforts
Words: 1486 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Hostile Work Environment The term "hostile work environment" has a wide range of meanings and definitions. Obviously, how precisely it is defined would vary based on the role or position of the person involved, their opinion about things employer rights, employee rights and unions and one's general feeling about what is and is not acceptable when it comes to general or work-based interactions with others. Others still may cast too wide

Born Bad William Golding's Lord
Words: 1510 Length: 4 Document Type: Thesis

There are no shortcuts" 50). On Golding's island, the nature of animal is based on a primal urge for survival; on Christie's the crimes reveal some of the true base or seamy sides of humanity. "The world, that understandable and lawful world, was slipping away" (82).Yet -- it is that very descent into fear that Christie postulates may have allowed those disposed of to, at the very last moment, repent

Is the EU a Good Thing
Words: 3457 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

EU Profile In 2012, the European Union (EU) was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for its work in "the advancement of peace and reconciliation, democracy and human rights in Europe" for more than half a century (The Nobel Peace Prize for 2012). Lauded by the Norwegian Nobel Committee for its commitment to reconciling Germany and France in the post-war period, the EU joined such notable persons as Barack Obama, who was

Banking Fees and Morality Integrating Values: The
Words: 5580 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

Banking Fees and Morality Integrating Values: The Legal, Moral, and Social Responsibility of the Government, the Banks, and the Consumers Legal Section Statement of Relevant Legal Principles and Rules of Law Application of Law to Topic and Legal Analysis Ethics Section Utilitarian Ethical Analysis Kantian Ethical Analysis Additional Ethical Analysis Social Responsibility Section Introduction to B. Definition of term "Social Responsibility" Application of Social Responsibility Banking fees in one form or another have existed in the United States hundreds of years, however the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now