Verified Document

Authors Comparisons Of The Costs Of Cities Term Paper

¶ … Cities There must be few citizens of the 21st century - at least few who are citizens of both the 21st century and the First World - who do not view the city as a problematic accomplishment of humanity. Certainly, cities are the highest expression of human civilization, at least in some ways: They support the flourishing of the arts and culture, of haute cuisine and high-tech medicine, of universities and research labs. But cities are also the expressions of the worst that humans have created, both in terms of how we treat each other and in terms of how we treat the planet, as the readings that we are examining for this paper argue. The city is many things, but it is and always has been essentially a site of commerce, and the basing of relationships upon commercial grounds is never unproblematic.

Gary Brechin, in his examination of the city of San Francisco, has picked what many people might consider to be an example of a "good city" (even as others consider it to be a modern Sodom - but that is beyond the argument of this paper). San Francisco has a long tradition of both liberalism and humanism; it seems in many ways a city that is not built on the demands of businesses (that are equally likely to cannibalize workers as the environment) as a city built on an acknowledgement of human relationships and fundamental needs.

But Brechin argues that San Francisco, like all other large American cities (and indeed all large cities across the globe as well as a number of smaller ones) is essentially rapacious: The city, he argues (and does so quite convincingly, with a number of historical details to back him up) is a rapacious organism. Divorced from the ecological constraints and realities of agrarian life, the city allows its inhabitants - even encourages...

Like other classical writers, Cicero associated farming with simplicity and morality, a connection that shaped Thomas Jefferson's hopes for a new agrarian republic. Jefferson failed to foresee how the western empire that he coveted would transform his nation as profoundly as Rome had been transformed by its continental dominions (p. 16).
It was this disconnection with the land as well as the imperial desires of the new nation that would allow it to do so much harm in the form of its cities - not that farming too doesn't exact an environment cost, as all four of these writers argue. But cities allow people to pretend - for generations at a time - that their account with the earth can be safely kept closed, or rather that it can be transformed into an account from which there are only withdrawals and no deposits.

Pena would agree in the main part with Brechin, although his perspective is different, examining as he does not the kind of large First World city that is at the center of Brechin's analysis but rather the borderlands that lie on both sides (although primarily the southern exposure) of the U.S.-Mexican border. Pena seems the same fundamental lack of accountability between the present and the future in the outsourced labor that occurs at the behest of U.S. firms (and American urban residents) along the Mexican border. One of the ways that cities have been able to endure as long as they have, Pena argues (and Resnick would agree with this) is that they…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Brechin, Gary. Imperial San Francisco: Urban Power, Earthly Ruin. Brechin Berkeley: U. California P, 2001.

Foster, John Bellamy. The Vulnerable Planet: A Short Economic History of the Environment. New York: Cornerstone Books, 1999.

Pena, Devon. The Terror of the Machine: Technology, Work, Gender, and Ecology on the U.S.-Mexico Border. Austin: U. Of Texas P, 1997.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

City in Modern Literature Professor
Words: 3609 Length: 11 Document Type: Term Paper

And moreover, Barth summarizes Sennett's book as a discussion of how "eighteenth and nineteenth-century Paris and London" reflected an "erosion of public life through an analysis of middle-class behavior in the theater and on the street." And Barth adds that Sennett's work "...lacks the terse logic of comparative history," and "makes many excursions into fleeting aspects of culture, yet in its discussion of the theater misses the rise of vaudeville

Cost Estimate Cost Analysis and Activity-Based Costing
Words: 1711 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Stadium Jumps" the writers discuss the cost of building a baseball stadium and renovating Robert F. Kennedy memorial stadium in Washington, D.C. The cost analysts note that the original cost estimate for the project was too low, and that the actual costs of completing the project could be as much as $91 million dollars more than originally anticipated. D.C. councilmen overseeing the project expect that the total costs for

Delphi Study Influence of Environmental Sustainability Initiatives...
Words: 17687 Length: 60 Document Type: Literature Review

Delphi Study: Influence of Environmental Sustainability Initiatives on Information Systems Table of Contents (first draft) Green IT Current Methods and Solutions Green IT and energy costs Green It and Email Systems Green IT and ICT Green IT and ESS Green IT and TPS Green IT and DSS Green IT and other support systems Green IT and GHG reduction Green IT and the Government Sector Green IT and the Corporate Sector Future Prospects of Green IT in the software industry The paper focuses on how the

Small Business - Banking Start-Up
Words: 7548 Length: 30 Document Type: Term Paper

Video Tape and Disc Rental Rentals Catalog/Mail Order Retailing Health and Personal Care Stores Retailing Table 2: Comparisons of Most Risky Small Business (BizStats.com, cited by Telberg, 2003) An Engine of Economic Growth More and more, Craig, Jackson and Thomson (2007) argue, policymakers perceive the small business sector "as a potential engine of economic growth. Policies to promote small businesses include tax relief, direct subsidies, and indirect subsidies through government lending programs." These authors stress that encouraging lending

Urban Sociology at Academies Such
Words: 2040 Length: 5 Document Type: Thesis

The only real downside environmentally is a relatively higher crime rate. While violent crime is not necessarily higher than for the U.S. As a whole, it is still higher than that found in Tokyo due to the well-studied differences in American and Japanese cultural proclivities toward crime. More importantly, crimes against property, and specifically auto theft, are much higher in San Diego than they are elsewhere in the U.S.,

PC's, Central-System Computing, and Government Functionality in
Words: 889 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

PC's, Central-System Computing, and Government Functionality In this article, the authors use correlational methods to prove their point-of-view. The way that this is accomplished is through a survey. They used percentages comparing two sets of subjects as well as a statistical analysis based on Cramer V scoring. The importance of the correlation was based upon whether or not the values in the study were greater than.20 on the Cramer V scale.

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now