Verified Document

Authors Comparing Views On The Bill Of Rights Term Paper

Bill of Rights Two of the most renowned authors in American history, Amar and Levy attempt to rejuvenate Bill of Rights, by interpreting its usage for this century. While one takes a liberal view of the Bill, the other takes a very detailed interpretation of the connotation of the law prevalent at the time. Leonard W. Levy in his Origins of the Bill of Rights argues that the Bill of Rights is not only a militarized document but also it is also a document for the purpose of the ruling class. On the other hand Akhil Reed Amar in his The Bill of Rights argues that the rights of the individuals is incorporated in the Bill but it needs further interpretation for proper application.

The United States' Bill of Rights is not only an ambiguous document but its interpretation has not generated the kind of application it needs in today's world. Levy and Amar's argument and interpretation through historical evidence show this fact.

Analysis:

According to Amar's long narrative, Bill of Rights is an individualistic documentation. Veiled though the context of the Bill maybe it was designed to attract the individuals during the Civil War. As a result of the social turmoil, the founding parties like democratic and the republics designed this Bill to protect democracy. Hence, in this context the Bill of Rights was designed to protect the government itself rather then the individual liberty. On the other hand Levy's thesis has been based on the view that Bills of Rights is basically an attempt to coerce the individuals...

He mentions the causes for the emergence of Bills of Rights but he does not fully address how it relates with the individuals.
Further study of the books indicates that Amer is much influenced by the notion that Bill of Rights is about self-rule. Even the government has created the Bill to protect itself; it was based on self-rule. "We the People of the United States." According to him refers to the people as a collective whole; who want to have a structural change for their own betterment. For instance the mentions the changes in the Bill of Rights before the ratified bill was presented. This he claims is because the people wanted to ensure that the Constitution was developed for the Rights of everyone. Levy on the other hand is of the opinion that, the Bill of Rights was a concoction of the anti-Federalist, who designed the Bill for States' rights and not civil rights. He thinks that the notion of people as part of the state is a myth. Although his argument is comparatively tame, Levy nevertheless touches upon the controversial issue that American Bills of Rights needs revision if it is going to be applied to the people of today.

Amar considers the various Amendments - First, Second, Eighth and declares that the amendments were militarized then it was meant for the civilians. The most important in this context in his opinion is the Second Amendment which state that: "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people…

Sources used in this document:
References

Leonard W. Levy, Origins of the Bill of Rights, New Haven: Yale University Press, 1999.

Akhil Reed Amar, The Bill of Rights, Yale University Press, 1998
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Authors Comparing Views on the Bill of Rights
Words: 1225 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

authors discussing the Bill of Rights. The authors are Irving Brant and Michael J. Kryzanek, both experts in the field of political science. The Bill of Rights did not exist when the Constitution was first written; it was a series of amendments proposed by James Madison in 1789. It now stands as the first ten amendments to the Constitution. "The Bill of Rights was ratified by the states on December

Rights Vs. Responsibilities the Conflict
Words: 1010 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Paper

Unfortunately, those not exercising this "right," that is the traditional two-parent families bear the brunt of these phenomena. Their incomes are heavily taxed to bear the burden of the "rights" of those who are passing the bill on without paying their fair share. This brings up what Mr. Lloyd calls the other "R"-responsibility. The emphasis upon rights has impoverished the social discourse. For rights to be meaningful and workable, they

Right to Privacy Being a Citizen of
Words: 2461 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Right to Privacy Being a citizen of the United States comes with many benefits in comparison to citizenship in other countries. Through the U.S. Constitution and the Bill of Rights we are granted certain rights -- the right to free speech, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, and freedom of assembly -- just to name a few. However, despite the 27 amendments the Bill of Rights that guarantee American protections

American Civil Rights Movement, Which Garnered Large
Words: 2673 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

American Civil Rights Movement, which garnered large support and public attention in 1960 and continued for the next decade is largely considered one of the most powerful and driving force behind significant changes that took place on both a social and legislative level within the United States. The movement itself took place in order to stop racial discrimination and racism against African-Americans that for years had run rampant throughout the

Bill Mckibben's Deep Economy Chapter
Words: 567 Length: 2 Document Type: Thesis

The current healthcare issue is reflective of the same basic problem that McKibben identifies in this chapter. People look at the cost and other factors of a "public option" for healthcare and get scared for themselves, positive that this would mean bureaucrats making medical decisions and scared about the costs when the fact is this is exactly what happens now -- we just don't call private executives in insurance companies

Comparison Between Count Dracula and Hannibal Lector
Words: 12217 Length: 30 Document Type: Dissertation or Thesis complete

Count Dracula and Hanibal Lector Program Authorized to Offer Degree The Analysis of Count Dracula and Hanibal Lector Identities of Count Dracula and Hannibal Supernatural Powers Gender and Sexuality Blood-Drinking The relation between Dracula and his victims Hannibal Lecter Power Gender and Sexuality Criminal Mind of Hannibal: Justification of Diagnosis Hannibal's Relations with his Victims The Power of Horror Dracula Silence of the Lambs Count Dracula Van Helsing Lucy Mina Jonathan Hannibal Lecter Clarice Grumb Mischa Starling Vocabulary Deployment- the arms and equipment with which a military unit or military apparatus is supplied. Sentence: "I suggest that we

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now