Verified Document

AUS Corp Law HP Case Case Study

The June 2010 change to the manner in which dividends were deemed payable shifted the requirement from a measure of profit to a balance sheet-based formula in which dividends were only payable if assets outstripped liabilities, essentially. This is, according to the facts of the case as presented, the only reason the dividend payment might be considered insolvent trading or otherwise contrary to the legal and financial constraints of the company under current Australian law. As the error was again solely the fault of chief financial officer George, the directors incur no liability in this instance.

Part B

As described above, the board of directors at Hampton Park Pty, Ltd. incurred no liability in this case as they relied on information provided by a competent and informed employee in the person of the company's chief financial officer, George, which legally absolves them of liability in this case.

Whether or not the company ultimately engaged in insolvent trading would require a more careful analysis of financial documents and a deeper knowledge of the facts of the case than are given, but that the directors would not be liable for any insolvent trading is certain and that such trading did not exist at all -- i.e. this does not appear to be a case when dividends were declared at a time when the company could not meet its obligations, but rather it was unable to meet its obligations shortly after paying a dividend (though not as a direct result). As Section 588g of the Australian Corporations Act of 2001, which defines insolvent trading, establishes that dividend payments are to be recorded as debts when they are paid or when they are declared, and with Section...

This defence is based on Section 189 of the Australian Corporation Act of 2001, which defines the degree to which directors are allowed to act on the reliance of others rather than obtaining first-hand information. While arguments can be made that the directors had a greater duty of care in determining that George's information was accurate and the actions he recommended were legally allowable, the only director for whom this could possibly have any sticking power is William, who as managing director was himself in a position of supposed competence and accurate information. Section 189 applies equally to William as to the other directors, however, and thus would seem to provide the same protection to him as it does to others. Consequences for any personal breach will be nil, though payments from the company in the form of dividends might be returned if it was deemed they were paid out illegally.
Corporations Act 2001, Section 189; See also Phillip Lipton, Abe Herzberg and Michelle Welsh, Understanding Company Law (Thomson-Reuters 2012) 469.

Lipton, et al., 469.

Deloitte, "Changes to Corporations Law rules for payment of dividends." (2010).

Corporations Act 2001, Section 189.

Sources used in this document:
Lipton, et al., 469.

Deloitte, "Changes to Corporations Law rules for payment of dividends." (2010).

Corporations Act 2001, Section 189.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Market Driven Management
Words: 25695 Length: 75 Document Type: Term Paper

Pharmaceutical industries have to operate in an environment that is highly competitive and subject to a wide variety of internal and external constraints. In recent times, there has been an increasing trend to reduce the cost of operation while competing with other companies that manufacture products that treat similar afflictions and ailments. The complexities in drug research and development and regulations have created an industry that is subject to intense

Nazi Germany's Financial Preparations for War
Words: 2586 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

1930's, Germany was plagued by unemployment and stagnant growth despite efforts by the administration to alleviate the country's economic difficulties. The economic liberalization of the banking system was one of few cautionary steps taken by administrations prior to Hitler to boost Germany's failing industries. This all changed following the Nazi rise to power; two notable banking acts passed in 1934 and 1936 effectively converted the banking system into Hitler's

Two Top Issues and Memo to the President
Words: 3279 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Public International Law Memorandum for preparation for next year's negotiations for the Conference of the Parties (COP) President XI Jinping of China Preparation for next year's negotiations for the Conference of the Parties (COP) Climate Change - Carbon Emissions Climate change poses one of the most difficult questions to the world today. Cities continue to be the main contributors of this challenge. Most of the greenhouse gases are produced by industries, motorized conveyance, domestic fuel,

Computer IBM, Entered the Computer
Words: 8433 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

To some users of personal computers, who state, never trust a computer that you cannot lift; the IBM has been viewed, more often than not, as an enemy, and according to Byte, the computer magazine, this was because of the fact that the IBM company rose to fame mainly on the basis of its mainframe computers, that were large and forbidding, and overwhelmingly bulky. This was probably why, when

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now