¶ … Surgeon's Notes on an Imperfect Science
According to author and surgeon Atul Gawande, the practice of medicine, despite its veneer of scientific objectivity, is often based more in art and subjective impressions than science. In his book A Surgeon's Notes on an Imperfect Science (which is part memoir and part philosophical rumination on the state of modern medicine), Gawande examines various types of medical errors and misreadings in his own career and others. Intentionally or not, the effect upon the reader is often unsettling, and although Gawande makes suggestions for how to improve the practice of medicine, he implies that mistakes are unavoidable because patients and doctors are human. Even statistics elude the unpredictability of medicine. "In psychology, there's something called the broken-leg problem. A statistical formula may be highly successful in predicting whether or not a person will go to a movie in the next week. But someone who knows that this person is laid up with a broken leg will beat the formula. No formula can take into account the infinite range of such exceptional events" (Gawande 42).
Gawande admits that human beings on an individual level can be remarkably difficult to treat and diagnose: "We look for medicine to be an orderly field of knowledge and procedure. But it is not. It is an imperfect science, an enterprise of constantly changing knowledge, uncertain information, fallible individuals, and at the same time lives on the line" (Gawande 7). There is a bracing honesty to Gawande's tone that is rarely found amongst medical doctors who usually instruct their patients in no uncertain terms to do x, y, and z and to even medical journalism which often suggests that good health can be followed through a specific regime of eating, exercise, and regular preventative medicine. Gawande admits that sometimes even when physicians do all the right things much goes wrong and even when wrong things are done the outcomes are not entirely for ill. From the hapless patient's point-of-view, it is never heartening to hear that physicians inevitably make errors and despite the best efforts of the system to correct this through training, because of human frailties, some of these mistakes may be impossible to prevent.
The efforts of medicine, in short, are not unwavering and fixed in their predictable results, like balancing an equation in chemistry or the laws of gravity in physics. Gawande admits that physicians are imperfect human beings, just like their patients. "There is science in what we do, yes, but also habit, intuition, and sometimes plain old guessing. The gap between what we know and what we aim for persists. And this gap complicates everything we do" (Gawande 7). Gawande states that usually the fault lies not in the physicians themselves, who are often trying to do the right thing -- "the important question isn't how to keep bad physicians from harming patient; it's how to keep good physicians from harming patients" -- but rather in the imperfect nature of medicine, often frighteningly imperfect from both the physician's and the patient's point-of-view (Gawande 57). The reliance upon habit means that questionable or even unsafe practices may be adhered to generation after generation; intuition and guessing may mean that someone still in the beginning stages of their practice may lack the necessary experiential reference points to make good decisions (although even experienced physicians can get lazy, sloppy, and burnt out)
Gawande structures his book according to three sections, appropriately titled fallibility, mystery, and uncertainty, which he considers the three cornerstones of what is problematic in modern medicine: humans are fallible (including patients that may not present a perfect picture of their symptoms); there is often an element of mystery as to what works with one patient and not with another; and the fact that physicians are eternally operating under conditions of uncertainty, thanks to the ever-changing nature of the human body and character that eludes even the most stalwart efforts to predict the future. "The core predicament of medicine - the thing that makes being a patient so wrenching, being a doctor so difficult, and being a part of society that pays the bills they run up so vexing - is uncertainty…Medicine's ground state is uncertainty. And wisdom - for both the patients and doctors - is defined by how one copes with it" (Gawande 229). For Gawande, good doctors know how to cope with uncertainty in positive ways without cracking under pressure; bad ones do not.
Some of the problems which Gawande outlines are extremely disconcerting from a patient's perspective,...
Atul Gawande leads with the thought that healthcare that costs more isn't necessarily better care at all. And Gawande lets the reader know that the town of McAllen, Texas, is able to provide some meaningful lessons to others on healthcare. This paper provides a review / summary of the article by Gawande. To begin with, as background, McAllen is a border town that has the lowest family income in the United
Public Health Betrayals A fascinating reality of public health is that when it is working, nothing is happening. People are healthy, they participate in their community's welfare, and they themselves are likely to want to be more engaged in the culture's economic and pleasurable activities. But the problem with a negative reality like this suggests Laurie Garrett in Betrayal of Trust, is that there is a tendency for governments of all
Failure and Rescue Atul Gawande and How Failures can be Turned Around Atul Gawande makes some key points about failure that arose through contemplation about some stories about particular individuals who have faced increadible hardships, namely, surviving the Holocaust and then having to deal with some of the harshers aspects of being human and having to age. Gawande tells the story of Mrs. C. and her inherient value system that developed based
http://www.bikingbis.com/blog/_archives/2006/2/11/1754124.html Scientists examined the obese study participants to see whether this so-called obesity gene was disturbed in any way. They found that only 3% of people had an abnormal leptin gene -- indicating that leptin is probably not a factor for most obese people ("Scientists Debunk So-Called 'Fat Gene'). Exercises for Obese People needed" Accessed April 24, 2008 http://www.phenforum.com/forum/get-shape/23032-exercises-obese-people-needed.html In America, a changing environment has broadened food options and eating habits. Grocery
job aid that reduces human error and lack of attention to detail by providing a list of policies, procedures, or items that are needed to produce a consistent job or product. There are checklists used in transportation to ensure the vehicles are ready, in clinical medical practice to organize charting and patient history, in software engineering to check process compliance and code, in litigation to deal with the complexity
Hospice Care and Catholic Ethics Is Hospice care consistent with Catholic bioethics? Chapple, in her discussion of the topic "Hospice care" in Catholic health care ethics, argues that ultimately the answer is yes, but she acknowledges that there are levels of difficulty in answering the question (Chapple 2009). The ethics of Hospice care present us with a complicated question, insofar as Catholic teachings on end-of-life care have at times provoked public
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now