Verified Document

Arnolfini Marriage And American Gothic:the Art Of Relationships Essay

Artistic Expression in Van Eyk and Grant: A Comparison There are few things that convey such intimate detail about any given period in history as its work of art. By incorporating certain principles of design and composition, the artist can visually represent or rebel against the artistic and social conventions of his or her time. As such, visual arts such as painting and sculpture become not only a representation of their creators, but also of the wider context within which they existed. This becomes all the more poignant and clear when works from different time periods are compared and contrasted, especially where these concern similar types of relationships among the elements being presented for scrutiny. IN Van Eyk's "The Arnolfini Marriage" and Wood's "American Gothic," the center stage is taken by a romantic couple in each case; in both cases the protagonists are most likely married or at least involved in a long-term relationship. By examining the composition and design principles of each, it becomes clear that, while the paintings are similar in the kind of human relationship they depict, they are wildly different in almost every other aspect, including the dominance, balance, and unity of each work.

The dominance in "American Gothic" by Grant Wood is almost exclusively taken up by the male and female figures in the foreground. The house is secondary, taking up most of the remaining space on the canvass. All other elements, including the sky and trees that represent nature have a position that is far inferior to the rest of the painting. If one takes this dominance in terms of balance to indicate a position of power or importance, the balance element in this painting indicates the importance of the human couple in terms of dominance over their environment. The pitchfork in the man's hand serves as a strong focal point, being even further in the foreground than the couple. Representing hard work, the pitchfork indicates the dominance of the man over the woman. The man is slightly towards the foreground, with the woman looking up to him and standing with her should behind his domineering figure. In order of importance, then, the main figures in this painting represent the male as strongest and most important force, the female as secondary, and all else as subordinate to them.

This is in...

The dominance element is far less pronounced in terms of the human figures and their environment. The two figures, in contrast to Wood's painting, are positioned in the middle of their surroundings and in the interior. An animal is in the foreground, with the rest of the room arranged around them to create only a slight emphasis on the human figures. Instead of dominance, the effect achieved by this is more complementary. Rich in religious and ceremonial symbolism, the room is arranged in such a way that the visual component of the non-human environment serves to enhance and complement the meaningful event taking place between the human participants. It is a mutual relationship between the human and the non-human, rather than one of contrasting dominance and subordination. A much greater harmony is indicated in this design component than for the painting by Wood.
When examining the visual balance each artist achieves, the contrast between the paintings is reiterated. In Wood's painting, the balance is almost as stark as the expressions on the couple's faces. The house in the background, for example, creates straight lines that connect the couple visually, with the pinnacle of the roof and the highest window positioned perfectly in the middle between them. Behind the left shoulder of the husband, the outbuilding and natural elements such as trees are lower than the top of his head, indicating his superior position as male. The wife, on the other hand is positioned lower than the background elements of the house and trees, indicating that, although as a human being she enjoys superiority, she is in a subordinate position to her husband. In contrast to the symmetrical balance of the house between them, then, there is a clear lack of equal balance between the partners. The wife's duties are inside the home, while the husband works in the outbuildings and the lands to support them. Rather than a partnership, there seems to be a clear delineation of duties that separates them rather than creating a sense of belonging and togetherness.

There is a contrast with this in Van Eyk's painting. Balance is achieved in a much more…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Arrange Marriage Among Adolescent
Words: 1550 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Arranged Marriages The social custom and institution of arranged marriages makes up a large part of the history of marriage and society. However the custom has been criticized and often condemned in the contemporary Western world. Many people see arranged marriages as unethical and as a deprivation of human rights and of the right to free choice of life partner. However, this view is sometimes contradicted by many modern youths from

Arranged Marriages V. Traditional Dating: Which Method
Words: 765 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Arranged Marriages v. Traditional Dating: Which Method Results in the most Successful Union? According to Yumiko Asano, success in marriage is characterized by longevity, financial stability, compatibility and a strong commitment on the part of both the man and the woman to keep the union together. Yumiko Asano also asserts that successful marriages arise more frequently from using a matchmaker than the traditional dating method as preferred by the majority of Americans.

Arranged Marriage in India Vs. Traditional American Marriage
Words: 1512 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

ARRANGED MARRIAGES IN INDIA VS. AMERICAN TRADITIONAL MARRIAGE Arranged marriages are common in South Asian communities and India is thus no exception. People with traditional bend of mind hesitate to even mention any other form of marriage and for them, love-based marriages are a threat to family honor and values since it involves dating and pre-marital mingling. In India, youth whether educated or illiterate, modern or traditional, religious or not are

Marriage Is a Social Institution With Strong
Words: 1587 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Marriage is a social institution with strong political overtones. The institution has created and enforced gender norms throughout every human society in all historical eras. Therefore, one of the reasons marriage works is because it is often strictly enforced with social codes. Marriage is only now starting to fall out of favor, and is being viewed more and more as an option rather than as an expectation. Yet there are

Marriage Law Society Marriage, Law
Words: 785 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

2. Should marriage be a path to citizenship for an American citizen's alien spouse, children, siblings, or parents? Discuss the pros and cons of prioritizing family reunification in our immigration policies. Marriage should certainly be a path towards American citizenship. People should be free to determine their spouse and this choice should not be restricted to any geographic area. It is often the case that love knows no boundaries. Individuals should

Marriage and Dating in the Middle Ages
Words: 1174 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Marriage and Dating in the Middle Ages Throughout the ages the ideals a marriage is based on have greatly fluctuated. Whereas the practice of arranged marriages isn't common in the Western world, during the Middle Ages, marriages were often arranged on the basis of land ownership, or the acquiring of power and wealth. Dating in the Middle Ages was practically an obsolete step in the higher classes. Classes were not allowed to

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now