Verified Document

Analyzing Prison Condition In USA Vs Russia Research Proposal

Prison Condition in USA vs. Russia In assessing the human rights conditions of maximum security facilities, human rights groups look into 3 main areas: the duration of confinement; the conditions of confinement, and the criteria of eligibility. Each of these areas must be looked into individually and then considered in the context of the entire situation (Human Rights Watch). Quite a number of concerns have been raised about the human rights conditions of the individuals held in prisons including: mistreatment of inmates / detainees by prison officials; unsafe conditions; and lack of sufficient legal protection (United States Department of State, n.d.). This paper also compares the situation of prison facilities in the United States and Russia.

Introduction

The Standard Minimum Rules, or the SMRs for the Treatment of Prisoners are one of the most important international agreements on how prisoners should be handled. The SMRs were adopted in 1955 by a special United Nations congress (United States Department of State, 2012). However, studies have shown that most of the prison systems all around the globe do not treat prisoners at the standards recommended by the SMR agreement. In many nations, there is blatant disregard of international treaties on the treatment of prisoners and this paper deals with this issue with a special focus on the American and Russian prison systems.

According to the SMR, prison authorities have to treat prisoners with respect and human dignity. They should also not subject inmates to any form of treatment that could be classified as degrading, inhuman or cruel. It is however unfortunate that the public authorities in-charge of maximum security prisons are operating them in ways that basically violate human rights. The confinement conditions are unnecessarily severe and are not proportionate to the actual security concerns. The conditions also impose undue humiliation and suffering on the inmates. In short, inmates in maximum security facilities are treated with the lowest level of respect and without regards to human dignity (Human Rights Watch).

Literature review

Conditions

Currently there are more than 20,000 prisoners in the United States who are held in maximum security facilities or blocks. The...

They are allowed only a few hours to exercise or take shower, often in enclosed spaces.
Maximum security inmates have almost zero access to recreational or educational programs or any other kind of activity that can offer them mental stimulation. They are often handcuffed and escorted by a minimum of two prison officers every time they walk out of their cells (Human Rights Watch). Even for inmates that are truly dangerous such conditions are unnecessarily harsh especially when used for a prolonged period of time (Human Rights Watch).

Some prison officials and policymakers have admitted that some of the conditions in maximum security facilities are not for security purposes (Hounshell, 2010). They stress that such negative conditions are necessary as a deterrent to misconduct. There are, however many better ways to deter youths from committing crime than maintaining harsh conditions in maximum security facilities (Human Rights Watch).

In some states, maximum security inmates have access to "privileges" such as the television, radio or more telephone calls and can walk themselves to the shower without shackles or handcuffs. However, these privileges can often be taken away even for very small infractions (Human Rights Watch).

In the Russian Prison system, inmates in maximum security facilities such as Butyrka and Vladimir, are served in their cells. This is in contrast to America's Stateville where inmates have access to a common dining area. All prisoners at Butyrka and Vladimir are locked all day in their cells except for a 60-minute walk time and shower every 10 days. In contrast, inmates at Stateville can only be held all-day when they are in segregation or on lockdown. During…

Sources used in this document:
References

Hounshell, B. (2010). What are Russian prisons like? Retrieved March 15, 2016 from http://foreignpolicy.com/2010/12/28/what-are-russian-prisons-like/

Human Rights Watch (n.d.). Supermax Prisons: an overview. Retrieved March 15, 2016 from https://www.hrw.org/reports/2000/supermax/Sprmx002.htm#TopOfPage

Markovic, V. (2000). Maximum Security Prisons: A Comparative Analysis. CRIME AND JUSTICE INTERNATIONAL, 16(39), 9-10.

Rosen, A. (2012). Inside Russia's Prison System. Retrieved March 15, 2016 from http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2012/10/inside-russias-prison-system/263806/
United States Department of State (2012). A Practical Guide to Understanding and Evaluating Prison Systems. Retrieved March 15, 2016 from http://www.state.gov/documents/organization/210347.pdf
United States Department of State (n.d). Report on International Prison Conditions. Retrieved March 15, 2016 from http://www.state.gov/documents/organization/210160.pdf
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

United States Has the Highest Rate of
Words: 13726 Length: 50 Document Type: Essay

United States has the highest rate of confinement of prisoners per 100,000 population than any other Western country. Analyze this phenomena and discuss actions that you feel are necessary to combat this problem. The United States currently has the highest incarceration rate of any nation worldwide. For example, greater than 60% of nations have incarceration rates below 150 per 100,000 people (Walmsley, 2003). The United States makes up just about

Annotated Bibliography for Prisons Conditions
Words: 1321 Length: 3 Document Type: Annotated Bibliography

Aleinikoff, T. (2014). Between National and Postnational: Membership in the United States. Palgrave Macmillan UK, 110-129. http://dx.doi.org/10.1057/9780230554795 This paper focuses on the 'postnational viewpoint' to the American notion of sovereignty and membership. The author defines what postnational viewpoint is and explains it means the view that a universal model of membership is replacing national citizenship and is doing so because it is anchored within deterritorialized concepts of persons' rights. Essentially this

Analyzing Clinical Research Funding
Words: 1387 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Prison Condition in USA vs. Russia In assessing the human rights conditions of maximum security facilities, human rights groups look into 3 main areas: the duration of confinement; the conditions of confinement, and the criteria of eligibility. Each of these areas must be looked into individually and then considered in the context of the entire situation (Human Rights Watch). Quite a number of concerns have been raised about the human rights

Differences in Following Smrs by U S And Russia Prison Systems
Words: 4325 Length: 13 Document Type: Research Proposal

TREATMENT OF PRISONERS IN THE U.S. AND RUSSIA How Does the United States Compare to Russia in Following the UN Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners? There are nearly 9 million people under certain forms of incarceration or supervision across the globe. The United States has the highest number of prisoners or individuals under some of supervision since approximately 25% of the world's prisoners are held in the country (U.S.

Analyzing the Gun Control Issue
Words: 4052 Length: 11 Document Type: Research Proposal

Gun Control Definition of the Problem (Gun Control) In America as well as other parts of the world, the role played by guns in committing violent acts, and what must be done in this regard, is a hotly debated topic. However, some facts are incontestable. Over 31,000 individuals sustained gunshot injuries in the year 2010, in America. As these victims are mostly youths, gun violence can be considered as one among the

Analyzing Foreign Corrupt Practices Act Fcpa
Words: 5505 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

FCPA The following till take a look at Foreign Corrupt Practice Act or in other words the FCPA. Discovering the corporate payments difficulty in the middle of the 70s from a blend of work by the Watergate Special Prosecutor office, this includes related additional work and inquiry by SEC-Security and Exchange Commission and the Multinational Corporations Subcommittee by Senator Frank Church. In 1975, within four months, separate hearings were held by the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now