Verified Document

Analyzation Of Texts Term Paper

Guilt and its limits as a positive force upon the human condition -- two texts grappling with this central issue, from Nietzsche the Genealogy of Morals and Ecce Homo and the Myth of Psychotherapy: Mental Healing As Religion, Rhetoric, and Repression by Thomas Szasz From the hectoring Jewish mother to the penitent pilgrim standing in the Christian confessional, to patient upon the psychiatrist's couch, guilt has proved to be a powerful motivating force in modern society as well as the ancient world of morality. Or thus "sprach" conventional wisdom, to coin a phrase of Frederick Nietzsche, in regards to his famous construction of Zarathustra. In other words, this commonly expressed human sense of guilt has often, across a wide variety of cultures and historical times, been viewed as a positive influence upon human life and human moral society. Nietzsche, in his The Genealogy of Morals and Ecce Homo sees guilt as essentially a Western and Christian construct, imposed upon classical civilization. However, even after the overt emphasis on guilt regarding human life has begun to ebb in terms of its Christian stress, guilt remains a strong strain in even secular, Puritanical societies, from the 9 to 5 grind of the work day, to the alleged obligations one owes to the sacrifices made by one's family for one's success.

Also, the common images of the motivating forces of guilt, it should be noted, existed even in a classical context, in the punishing view of some underworlds, including that of the Greeks and Romans where individuals suffered torments for defying the Gods, and even in non-Christian contexts such as the son of the Jewish joke, the strains of guilt live on within our culture. Guilt drives us, conventional wisdom suggests today, even shorn of Christian iconography, to get up in the morning and go to work to earn enough money to buy our children bread and to honor our obligations as citizens in paying taxes to the government that protects us with its military and system of laws -- protects us against ourselves as well...

Conventional wisdom also speaks to us as moral actors, that guilt creates a sense of motivation to do good towards others, according to the golden rule of doing unto others as one would have done to one's self. Guilt even when suppressed is thus a moral force of beneficial influence upon the human condition, says the dogma of American morality.
Nonsense, says the German philosopher Nietzsche in his book The Genealogy of Morals. Guilt has nothing to do with one's true emotional relationship with one's loved ones or one's physical and mental obsequies to a Christian or even a pagan God. Rather, guilt is merely hatred of the self, turned inward. Guilt is all about how one feels about one's self as a son, mother, child of God, or child of the confessional, and has nothing to do with anything larger, more significant, and more beautiful. Such suggestions are merely the lies of a constructed societal -- which, for Nietzsche, meant a Christian -- philosophy with no true psychological truth in its basis. The construction of such a lie of guilt was merely designed to serve the leaders of the church and the leaders of the state.

In other words, guild is only a negative psychological motivating factor, and its motivation is merely to stymie all that is good about the human spirit rather than serving to expand the potential of the individual condition. Thus, Nietzsche suggests that the death of Christian and other sweeping dogmas regarding morality and the cultural death of God thus has the potential to serve the full scope of humanity and the individual human being, rather than to create an immoral universe. Long before patients sat upon the therapist's couch, musing over the minutia of their daily lives that drove them into guilty frenzies, obsessing over the difference between spending quality rather than quantity time with their children, Nietzsche suggested that one must let go of one's inner hatred to become fully realized as an individual self.

In The Genealogy of Morals, Nietzsche…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Nietzsche, Frederick. On the Genealogy of Morals/Ecce Homo. New York: Vintage Books, 1989.

Szasz, Thomas. The Myth of Psychotherapy: Mental Healing As Religion, Rhetoric, and Repression. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press, 1988.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Papyri Awakening Osiris: The Egyptian Book of
Words: 3588 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Papyri Awakening Osiris: The Egyptian Book of the Dead The Egyptian Book of the Dead is a western title for an ancient collection of Egyptian manuscripts, the majority of which were funerary in nature. These collected writings have also been referred to as the Egyptian Bible or identified by the names of the scribes who penned them. The Papyrus of Ani comprises the most significant contribution to these texts, though there are

Thomas Kuhn's Paradigm Theory
Words: 2840 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Thomas Kuhn (1922-1996) was an American scientist, historian and philosopher who wrote a controversial book in 1962 called The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Kuhn was born in Cincinnati, Ohio and from an early age expressed interest in science, particularly physics; obtaining his BS degree in physics from Harvard in 1943. He stayed at Harvard for his MS and PhD, and credits the period of the late 1940s in helping him

Birth of Venus by Boticelli
Words: 3077 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

In his attempt to paint the goddess, the Renaissance painter inspired from the mythological legend of Venus's birth. The Roman Goddess of love apparently emerged out of the sea as a result of a foam formed around Uranus's genitals that had just been cut by his son, Cronus. Cronus apparently did so in order to get revenge, since his father treated him very cruelly (Deimling 52). Botticelli focused on emphasizing

Erik Erikson & Post-Freudian Theory
Words: 3153 Length: 11 Document Type: Term Paper

guilt stage, that occurs in the preschool years, where the child is about 31/2 to 51/2 years old. During this stage the child learns: (1) to imagine, to broaden his skills through active play of all sorts, including fantasy (2) to cooperate with others (3) to lead as well as to follow (Wagner, 2007). Immobilized by guilt, he is: (1) fearful (2) hangs on the fringes of groups (3)

Special Education Has Changed Dramatically. Gone Are
Words: 5921 Length: 22 Document Type: Term Paper

special education has changed dramatically. Gone are the days of the special classroom down the hall where special education students were hidden away and kept from the general student population. Gone are the days when special education students were given comic books to read and passed because they were there. Civil rights mandates of the 1960's turned the world of special education inside out and today, four decades later,

Application of a Pedagogic Model to the Teaching of Technology to...
Words: 60754 Length: 230 Document Type: Dissertation

Pedagogic Model for Teaching of Technology to Special Education Students Almost thirty years ago, the American federal government passed an act mandating the availability of a free and appropriate public education for all handicapped children. In 1990, this act was updated and reformed as the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, which itself was reformed in 1997. At each step, the goal was to make education more equitable and more accessible to

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now