Verified Document

American Foreign Policy Term Paper

American Foreign Policy Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics -- Joseph S. Nye

What are the strengths of Nye's arguments?

By suggesting that a strategy of "soft power" (using America's substantial strength of influence, international collaborative coalitions, and non-lethal approaches to persuasion) is preferable to storming into a nation such as was the case with the U.S. invasion of Iraq in 2003 Nye certainly has attempted to stir up the waters in America's current political scene. This is one clear strong point of his argument: simply the fact that he wrote a book which presents an intelligent, well-thought-out alternative to the Bush Administration's approach to "fighting terrorism." Nye's position is that soft power (" ... getting others to want the outcomes that you want -- co-opts people rather than coerces them" page 5) is more a matter of getting people "to buy into your values" (5) than pushing them, or bullying them into believing what you believe.

Since the Bush approach is basically one of unilateralism (go it alone if we must) and hegemony ("preponderant influence or authority over others" according to Merriam-Webster Online), e.g., putting together a coalition of a handful of allies to invade and occupy Iraq, which is contrary to most American military engagements, an opposing view (Nye's viewpoint) is healthy. And since the Bush invasion of Iraq was based on what the public now knows were questionable claims (that Saddam Hussein was pursuing nuclear weapons development and had already produced weapons of mass destruction) -- without the blessing of the United Nations -- there needs to be a counterpoint to that policy. Why?

The answer lies in the fact that the American political system is based on an honest dialogue between those who are engaged in the machinery of government. This nation is strong because those on both sides of the political discussion are free to criticize and present alternative ideas. And frankly, the Nye approach to resolving the issue of Saddam's threat to the Middle East -- albeit idealistic and perhaps not entirely practical -- looks reasonable now that the war has not gone well, indeed...

There would seem to be no escape for the United States, nearly 1,500 U.S. troops have been killed, America has lost credibility and prestige around the world and the Bush policy is fast losing ground in the U.S. public opinion polls.
What are the weaknesses of Nye's arguments?

Nye's book reads more like philosophy than prospective policy. At times his narrative sounds more like Plato -- or even "Dr. Phil" -- than the grizzled political veteran he is (Nye was Chairman of the National Intelligence Council and Assistant Secretary of Defense in the Clinton Administration; currently he is Dean of Harvard's Kennedy School of Government, and has written numerous books on international politics, such as The Paradox of American Power). For example, on page 5, he equates the use of "soft power" on the world's troubled and violent political scene with "a relationship or marriage." Power, he writes, "does not necessarily reside with the larger partner [in a relationship], but in the mysterious chemistry of attraction." We are all "familiar with the power of attraction and seduction," he asserts, adding that "political leaders have long understood the power that comes from attraction."

Yes, indeed, politicians understand that folksy, family-friendly commercials can they them elected because voters are attracted to "feel-good" images. But politicians in 2005 also understand that American voters in the post-9/11 era want their leaders to take a tough stand against "terrorism" -- wherever, whomsoever, and however the president at that time tells them it is wise to attack. For a politician to vote against money Bush asks for (for "the fight on terrorism") is near political suicide. He or she will be called "unpatriotic" next election period -- and therefore, if Nye's arguments are perceived as weak, then they in…

Sources used in this document:
Reference

Nye, Joseph S. (2004). Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics. New York:

Public Affairs.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

American Foreign Policy in His
Words: 1508 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

The United States of America's foreign policy has mirrored its influence and power within the international community. As a small and weak nation, America was forced to employ a regional foreign policy, limited to the North American continent. But as the U.S. grew into a powerful industrialized nation, its foreign policy began to change to include more international issues. Finally, as a result of the need for the United States

American Foreign Policy Theories It Has Been
Words: 1102 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

American Foreign Policy Theories It has been said that all politics are local, meaning that whatever the issue, an individual always views it from the perspective of their own personal life. And since their personal life exists in a local environment, a person's view of a political issue is always clouded by local circumstances. Roarke and Boyer, in International Politics on the World Stage assert that a nation's international policy can

American Foreign Policy Towards the
Words: 2346 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Proposal

However, once they were expelled from Kuwait is when the original boundaries were restored once again. (Brown 302 -- 310) These different events are significant, because they are illustrating how any kind of attempts to change the borders in the Middle East has been a sign that U.S. is working to aggressively to maintain the status quo. Where, they do not want one particular country to be able to dominate

American Foreign Policy As It
Words: 4630 Length: 13 Document Type: Essay

Again, the press is not aware of all that goes on in the White House behind closed doors. Just because the matter was not publicly mentioned again in a direct fashion, does not mean that it was dropped. My team and I have continually discussed the best course of action for fostering trade with Tunisia and setting a much stronger precedent in the Middle East. The WSJ has actually

American Foreign Policy
Words: 1608 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

American Foreign Policy from three articles from Annual Edition's American Foreign Policy: Article 33, "Musclebound: The Limits of U.S. Power" by Stephen M. Walt; Article 12, "A Small Peace for the Middle East" by Arthur Hertzberg; and Article 11, "To Be An Enlightened Power" by Wu Xinbo. It answers the following questions: 1) What is the overall foreign policy issue/theme/problem that links the articles together. 2) What are the

American Foreign Policy
Words: 355 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

United States Presidents in the 1890s [...] which president conducted American Foreign policy more skillfully in the 1890's, McKinley or Cleveland? Why? William McKinley favored an imperialistic worldview, and brought the United States into the Spanish-American War, which ultimately added the Philippines, Guam, and Puerto Rico to the United States. He favored American intervention into foreign politics, especially when this intervention would benefit the U.S. In fact, McKinley's dominant imperialistic

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now