Verified Document

Alamo In Sleuthing The Alamo, James Crisp Essay

Alamo In Sleuthing the Alamo, James Crisp does not think that Sam Houston gave the racist "half Indian Mexicans" speech. This is contrary to the fact that the speech has been widely attributed to Sam Houston. "The words of the speech were harsh," as Crisp states it (p. 10). Houston speaks about the "phlegm of the indolent Mexicans," and calls them "half-Indians," thus denigrating both Tejanos and Native Americans," (cited by Crisp). Houston knew that most of the Anglo Texans were already racist and he capitalized on these beliefs to foment fervor for secession and American statehood. Crisp comes across as an apologist, as his "sleuthing" seems like it is done only to vindicate his childhood hero. Yet what he is really trying to say is that historians' own biases were attributing their racist beliefs to Houston. It wasn't Houston that was the real racist; it was the interpreters of history.

The views of society impact the way the Alamo and its historical context are portrayed and remembered in history books. Comics, movies, and paintings present a romantic version of events, told primarily from the Anglo side of the conflict. Whites are good, Mexicans and everyone else are beneath whites. This portrayal is largely because the bulk of authorship for these artifacts is biased. The truth is far more complex than that, as Crisp shows us. Moreover, the experiences of blacks and Native Americans have been silenced in these representations. The...

The Mexican side of the events will be far different, because the views of Mexicans towards the Alamo would be different. Similarly, the African-American and Native American portrayals would also be different from the Western movies, paintings, and novels whites are familiar with.
3. The representations of the Alamo in comics, movies, and painting can shape beliefs and attitudes about the Alamo too. Just as advertisements both reflect and shape social norms, movies and other cultural expressions both reflect and shape attitudes and beliefs about history. This impacts the way historians perform their research, and can bias them to asking certain questions over others, or focusing on some events more intensely than others. From reading and viewing these somewhat biased interpretations, the individual forms a romantic vision of the events that took place, and fails to comprehend the complex character of what actually happened.

Long Essay

Few figures in American folklore are as romanticized as Davy Crockett. Thus, any story that emasculates him by portraying Crockett as having surrendered at the Alamo will be controversial. Any historian predisposed to believe in the undying heroism of Davy Crockett will not appreciate Crisp's sleuthing, but it is the duty of the historian to uncover truths in spite of prevailing attitudes and beliefs. This is especially true when…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Operation D. Torch the Focus
Words: 1550 Length: 5 Document Type: Case Study

This will embolden the Axis powers by believing that their strategy for a long protracted war will be successful. At the same time, the large numbers of casualties or the inability to make significant territorial gains will force commanders to rethink their approach. This is when they will begin taking a defensive position in the region (which will allow the Axis powers time to regroup and build up their

The Center of Gravity for Operation Torch
Words: 2763 Length: 6 Document Type:

staff officer with the Combined Chiefs of Staff, European Theater of Operations. As a recent CGSOC graduate, your supervisor has tasked you to review the Norfolk Group's plan and related documents (Parts 2 and 3). The Combined Chiefs will meet soon to be briefed on the planning thus far to advise President Roosevelt and Prime Minister Churchill on the status of Operation TORCH. Your supervisor's instructions to you are: "I

Testing Materials -- Sensitive in Nature Do
Words: 2526 Length: 7 Document Type: Case Study

Testing Materials) -- Sensitive in Nature Do Not Copy, Print, Transmit, or Save Unless Specifically Authorized TORCH exam The desired End State of the Allies here is complete control of North Africa from the Atlantic (in the west) to the Red Sea (in the east). The primary obstacle at present to achieving this End State is fairly easily described: the Axis has control of the Mediterranean Sea with small exceptions on the far

Heart of Darkness
Words: 2500 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

Conrad explores the vileness of imperialism in a cloak of goodwill with various approaches to the way in which Europeans and Africans are viewed in this novel. Heart of Darkness is a novella written by Joseph Conrad which has a strong autobiographical tone and discusses the dark side of imperialism with an underlying irony. Heart of Darkness was based on Conrad's journey to the Belgian Congo in 1890 where the Africans

OSHA High Priority Standards Ventilation.
Words: 579 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

The hand-held grinders used in finishing could lead to massive injuries. Four Written Programs 1910.95: Occupational noise exposure. The written program outlining the guidelines to be posted and distributed is necessary to apprise the employees not only of the laws and regulations, but also of the potential risks to their hearing. 1910.104: Oxygen. The written program for oxygen use, such as the oxy-acetylene torch, requires proper placarding and operating instructions be posted

Sustainability It Appears There Is Much Riding
Words: 1036 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Sustainability It appears there is much riding on the earth's future. Leadership of the next decades must be ready to deal with new challenges that have not been recorded in history. A major issue of this future will be the ability for society to sustain itself amid an illusion of resource scarcity. The purpose of this essay is to investigate the next generations' ability to carry the torch of sustainability as

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now