Verified Document

AIDS In The Workplace, Discuss The Following: Essay

¶ … AIDS in the Workplace," discuss the following: What are the moral issues in this case?

The first moral obligation Carla has is to the law: it is illegal to discriminate against someone because they have an illness, if that illness does not substantially affect the employee's job performance. In this case, there is no concrete evidence that Tom's rumored illness has affected his abilities as a worker. The second moral obligation Carla has is to the truth. The evidence of Tom having AIDS is based upon second-hand testimony from his ex-wife, and Carla only convinced herself that Tom may have seemed thinner after hearing Frances' comments. Tom's illness does not seem as bad, objectively, as Carla's fears suggest. Carla also has a moral obligation to honor Tom's loyal service and evident qualifications for a promotion.

What ideals, obligations, and consequences must Carla Lombard consider?

Carla Lombard must consider the ideal that all individuals should be treated fairly, regardless of whether they are sick are well. So long as someone's illness is not a danger to others, they should not be discriminated against and turned into a social pariah. Carla has an obligation to Tom as her employee. She must also be aware of the consequences that her business could suffer if she was found to have engaged in illegal, discriminatory practices.

However, some might say that Carla has an obligation to ensure that the business functions...

This might be said to include only employing people who can perform to a high standard. If Tom is given a position of leadership and fails, this does not only hurt Carla. It hurts the entire business, and all of the employees whose livelihoods depend on that business.
Finally, some might state that Carla as an obligation to the truth to talk to Tom, because Tom has a right to discuss his illness with Carla. But conversely, Carla also has an obligation of confidentiality to Frances.

What rights, if any, are at stake?

Tom has a right to be treated fairly and not condemned, based upon a rumor. Even if he does have AIDS, he also has a right to be employed in a position, so long as he has shown that he can fulfill his duties.

Will it make a difference whether Carla adopts a Kantian approach or a utilitarian approach to this situation?

It will make a great deal of difference. A Kantian approach suggests that Carla must follow her duties and moral obligations, and act as if she is setting a moral precedent for all time with her actions. The precedent Carla must set is clearly one of non-discrimination against a good employee. She must anti-discrimination law. A utilitarian approach would suggest that paying Tom but not requiring him to come to work would sweep the matter under the table, and avoid any possible controversy that would arise, if Tom's illness was exposed. In this approach, although…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Workplace Demands Influences Patient Safety PICOT Question
Words: 2464 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Workplace Demands Influences Patient Safety PICOT Question PICOT Question: How can the implementation of accurate safety standards reduce errors that hamper patients' safety in healthcare facilities in the short and long run? P -- Patients in healthcare facilities Recognition of Errors Procedural and Human Errors O -- Implementation of Safety Standards and Systems to improve Caretaker Efficiency and Patient Security different interventions take different times, but results should be seen with a year from all interventions

Generational Gap in the Workplace Contemporary Working
Words: 3120 Length: 10 Document Type: Dissertation

Generational Gap in the Workplace Contemporary working age Americans are categorized into four distinct generations that, allegedly, have been made into what they are and their personalities formed due to the socio-political and economic as well as historical occurrences of their age. These four generations are variously known as: Traditionals, Baby Boomers, Generation X, and Generation Y There are at least two views regarding generational differences in the workplace. The first suggests

Injury and Illness Prevention Within the Workplace
Words: 6068 Length: 22 Document Type: Term Paper

Unlike our predecessors in the mines and mills and factories - and even offices - we today expect our workplaces to be safe. We consider this a birthright - that our employers should design and monitor the workplace in such a way that we are allowed to do our job without any undue risk for ourselves. And yet, of course, this is not a birthright but rather a legal protection

Positive and Negative Stress in the Workplace
Words: 9457 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

1. Introduction The modern 21st century has posed new challenges for the organizations to survive and grow (Smith et al. 2010). As they are operated and managed by human beings, the challenges are ultimately faced by the individuals who are responsible for making decisions and implementing them (Nieuwenhuizen, Weiss and Rossouw, 2009). As challenges are multifaceted, and human lives are divided into various aspects, it is difficult to excel in every

The Pedagogy of Emotional Intelligence Ei in the Workplace for Generations...
Words: 5531 Length: 16 Document Type: Essay

Multigenerational Workforce Motivation Leadership Style Talent management and human resource management personnel have, been aware of the commercial value of creating and leveraging an all-encompassing, diverse workforce for several years. Recruitment and employee retention programs have focused on gender, ethnicity, race, recruitment and career development of veterans, disabled persons, etc. One can observe increased demands among corporate personnel, to include multigenerational diversity in their organizations. Talent and human resource managers have

Health Disparities in Louisville KY
Words: 3177 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

Health Disparities in Louisville KY Health Disparities Health inequities have become a major problem in the United States. Hofrichter stresses in Tackling Health Inequities Through Public Health Practice: A Handbook for Action ( 2006) that, "The awareness of the existence of inequities in health, health status and health outcomes between racial and ethnic groups in America is as old as the nation itself" (Hofrichter, 2006,P. vii). As will be discussed in this paper,

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now