Verified Document

Aid The United States Has Been One Essay

¶ … Aid The United States has been one of the most affluent countries of the world. Because of this fact, the country has established a history of providing aid and comfort to other groups around the world who are suffering because of economic, agricultural, or other turmoil for whatever reason, whether it be failure of government, war, or natural disaster. Some advocate that this is the rightful position of more wealthy countries and populations, to provide assistance to those who are less fortunate. This is certainly true to some extent. However, when a nation is in times of difficulty itself, like the United States is currently embroiled in, it is more important that the government provide aid to its own citizens than looking at what it can do outside the nation's borders. On an individual level, it would certainly be nice for wealthy persons to assist their fellow men and women but they are certainly not required to do so, by any means. Peter Singer states in "Famine, Affluence, and Morality" that the world's ills are everyone's problems and therefore everyone's responsibility. Jan Narveson writes in her article "We Don't Owe Them a Thing" that there are three types of aid which can potentially be given to others: reparation, helping, and dire need. Under each of these criterions there is a level of negative stigma attached to those who do not provide assistance, but again, there is absolutely no obligation to do so.

Reparation, according to Narveson, is only applicable when providing...

In cases of reparation, there may be legal or moral necessity to provide someone with funds in order to make up for the wrong that we have perpetrated against them. However this will have nothing to do with the current financial state of the person receiving the money or help. This is aid which could be legally required and for which the government could force a person to provide. On an international scale, there will be little cause for this type of aid unless there is a situation where two nations are at war and one side loses to the other, in which case the loser will be forced to pay reparation and restitution. Since the United States has not caused the harm of those in impoverished nations, it is not the responsibility of its people to heal these problems.
A secondary form of aid is what Narveson refers to as helping which are situations in which the life of the individual in need is not directly at stake. It is providing aid to another in a moderate way which although assisting another, does not permanently alter the way in which that person lives or works. Narveson advocates helping those in need despite cost, but understands that there is a difference between telling someone what they should do and what they must do.

The most necessary type of aid, dire need, is the form of aid that one most thinks of when discussing providing money or goods of some kind to others. These are cases "when putative recipients will die, say, or at least…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited:

Narveson, Jan. "We Don't Owe Them a Thing." The Monist. 86:3. 419-433. Print.

Singer, Peter. "Famine, Affluence, and Morality." Philosophy and Public Affairs. 1:1. 1972. 229-

243. Print.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

United States' Involvement in the First World
Words: 974 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

United States' Involvement in the First World War America's Involvement in the First World War The president is well aware that Americans often face the temptation to disengage from the rest of the world, especially when the issue at hand has to do with military involvement. I, personally, expected Americans to recoil from President Wilson's proposal to join the European war and fight against Germany, first, because they usually "are skeptical about

United States and the International Criminal Court
Words: 1478 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

United States and the International Criminal Court i request writer "jonsmom2" topic: "The United States International Criminal Court." paper reflect research explain U.S. association ICC. Also briefly examine goals ICC, review U.S. attitude joining outline problems U. The United States and the International Criminal Court The ICC (International Criminal Court) was founded in July of the year 2002 on the day that the Rome Statute which is the founding treaty of the ICC

United States' President Comparing and Contrasting the
Words: 2928 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

United States' President Comparing and contrasting the U.S. healthcare system with that of various other nations is not a simple job. There are a lot of details that are not just arranged in a variety of methods however likewise they are made use of to determine considerable and deviating elements. The conclusion will frequently rely on exactly what is thought and which elements are the most vital to the people carrying

USA Patriot Act
Words: 1123 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

USA PATRIOT Act: Discussion Questions The USA PATRIOT Act, as the Department of Justice (2014) points out was enacted by Congress with an aim of equipping those charged with the enhancement of law and order with new tools to not only combat but also prevent acts of terror. An acronym, the PATRIOT Act, in the words of Ronczkowski (2006, p. 64), is "formally known as the Uniting and Strengthening America by

United States Social Welfare Programs
Words: 658 Length: 2 Document Type: Book Report

The law also limits lifetime welfare assistance to five years, requires most able-bodied adults to work after two years on welfare, eliminates welfare benefits for legal immigrants who have not become U.S. citizens, and limits food stamps to a period of three months unless the recipients are working. Example: A young eighteen-year-old female who just had a child, but cannot find the father of her child, or doesn't know

United States Terrorism - Operations
Words: 2111 Length: 8 Document Type: Thesis

Domestic Terrorism Since the days of the Old West, domestic terrorism has dug its roots into the United States. From Timothy McVeigh, whose motivations for the Oklahoma City bombing ranged from his complaints over the governments' dealing with certain political situations to his anger over the violence he witnessed during his stint in the military, to eco-terrorists and animal-rights activists who use violence in order to win others to their cause,

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now