Verified Document

Against School By John Taylor Gatto The Essay

Against School by John Taylor Gatto The article is written by a former teacher who retired and hence recounts his experiences and tribulations in the teaching profession. He also airs his observations of the system and the shortcomings that he feels are in the system. He also suggests various ways through which the education system in America can be adjusted to fit the needs of the nation and of the children involved in the system.

Having taught for thirty years, Taylor indicates that there is nothing more commonly shared among children than boredom. It is an event that cuts across the children and the teachers with each side having the other side to blame. The most outstanding reason however is the education system that confines the teachers and the children to a routine for twelve years in compulsory program. The boredom comes from a predictable schedule and content by both the children and the teachers who are enshrined in the system.

The first argument in support for his castigation of the education system of the U.S.A. As it is the routine in terms of hours per day spent in school and the market value that is tied to the schooling system. He sights various figures that did not go through the entire schooling system but became significant people within the society, a proof that the schooling system is not the ultimate marking scheme for greatness in the society.

Taylor also argues that the education system is highly borrowed from the Prussian system hence makes the children to imbibe a foreign culture and as a consequence of it, the people going through the schooling system are meant to be adaptive and 'adjustive' to the governance system, to easily conform to the needs of the system, to be able to get assigned social roles and predeterminations of future and...

He calls these groups children, indeed says that "School has done a pretty good job of turning our children into addicts, but it has done a spectacular job of turning our children into children. Again, this is no accident" (Taylor J., 2003), which is summative conclusion to all the arguments made hitherto.
Response to text

Taylor puts forth his thesis and succinct defense of his thesis drawing a few examples from the current American society, all in effort to discredit the schooling system that exists. His arguments though fall short of looking at the numerous benefits that the education system has brought into the society.

It is not enough to mention one person who helped invent the WWI chemicals without necessarily having a college background, but there should be equal consideration given to the medics and research scientists who helped come up with medicine that would successfully see the eradication of malaria and other infectious diseases like chicken pox from the U.S.A. The medical field has inventions that have heavy academic backgrounds that equipped the scientists with the in-depth knowledge of the human body and the disease trends which would not be possible without education.

Indeed the argument that the schooling system is a mandatory confinement and o the other hand recognizing the home schooling system that has been embraced by millions of Americans is a self defeatist stand. The fact…

Sources used in this document:
References

Christina C. & George D. (2008). Literacy Changes Lives: The Role of Literacy in Offending Behavior -- A discussion piece. National Literacy Trust. Retrieved October 13, 2012 from http://www.literacytrust.org.uk/assets/0000/0422/Literacy_changes_lives__prisons.pdf

Fitzgerald C., (2012). Adult and Family literacy in the U.S.; limitations to our Nation's success. Retrieved October 13, 2012 from http://www.scilearn.com/blog/low-literacy-united-states.php

Literacy and Policing in Canada, (2012). The link Between Low Literacy and Crime. Retrieved October 13, 2012 from http://policeabc.ca/files/factsheets_englishPDFs/Ch02FactSheet02.pdf

Taylor J., (2003). Against School: How public education cripples our kids, and why. Retrieved October 13, 2012 fromhttp://www.wesjones.com/gatto1.htm
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Mann V. Gatto the Early Public School
Words: 709 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Mann v. Gatto The early public school reformer Horace Mann celebrated the institution of the public school as a profoundly democratizing force in American life. Mann believed that without public schooling, America could not become a true democracy. Public schooling enabled even the children of paupers to work hard and to gain a foothold in the middle class (Badolato 2011). Schools could provide students with technical expertise which would also make

Frederick Taylor Most Things in Life Are
Words: 1079 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Frederick Taylor Most things in life are black and white -- all good or all bad -- totally an advantage and not injurious in any way or a completely a disadvantage and not beneficial in any way. Would it be easy if life was so simple? Such was the case with the theory of Scientific Management developed and implemented by Frederick Taylor at the turn of the 20th century. Although his

Homeschool a Child Vs. Public School
Words: 1619 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Home School vs. Public School Home schooling was once reserved for homebound students due to a number of reasons, such as rural locations, or physical conditions. Religion has also been a major reason for home schooling. Today, however, many parents are choosing home schooling over public schools for variety of reasons and statistics show that for the majority it has proven to be the right choice. The National Center for Education Statistics,

Learning Power American Education Has
Words: 1346 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

While his loss of accent brought himself and his teachers a sense of pride, it brought sorrow to his parents, who saw the change, however gradual, in their child. The author furthermore admits that for children like him, from a non-white American background, the home and school environment are at cultural extremes. This creates conflict that the young Rodriguez handled by conforming to his school environment. In effect he

Education and How That Quote
Words: 422 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Much of the time spent in school focuses on following arbitrary rules and not theories of importance. This understanding places much pressure on the teacher. Directives often come from higher, demanding certain test scores be met and curriculum be tailored to more collective ideas. As a result, the very thing that empowers students is ignored. We are individuals with individual gifts and talents all worthwhile and important in way or

Academic Profile of Home Schoolers a Case Study
Words: 16937 Length: 62 Document Type: Case Study

Academic Profile of Home Schooling - a Case Study Home Schooling vs. Traditional Educational Methods Home Schooling Methodology Focus of the Practicum Culture Area of Inquiry Subject/Topic Areas Home Schooling as an Alternative Curricula and Materials Used for Home Schooling The Success of Home Schooling Evaluation Design Conditions for Change Timeline Chronology Legislative Information: Maryland: A Legal Analysis State Laws and Regulations - Maryland Goulart and Travers vs. Calvert County Home-schooled Kids Find Social Growth" Home Schoolers in the Trenches" Home School Academic Advantage Increases Over Time" Home Schooling." ERIC Digest,

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now