¶ … Aeneas' detachment differ from Rama's?
The French philosopher Simone Weil once wrote that, "There is no detachment where there is no pain. And there is no pain endured without hatred or lying unless detachment is present too." In the Aeneid and Ramayana a central issue is how each text's protagonist detach themselves from the consequences of their actions. The greatest juxtaposition can be seen in how the two men respond to the decision to take decisive action. In the 4th book of the Aeneid, as Aeneas is preparing his fleet to set sail from Carthage in secret, Queen Dido, his lover, suspects his ploy and confronts him. In a rage, she insults him and accuses him of stealing her honor. Aeneas responds with fatalist detachment that, "I am seeking Italy not of my own accord." This quote suggests that Aeneas views his action and the incredible suffering he is causing Dido as flowing from the pre-determined path of history. In contrast, in the Ramayana Lord Rama when asked to accompany the sage Vishwamitra refuses stating philosophically, "Who am I? What is the nature of this world? What is the purpose of human existence? I refuse to do anything till I get satisfactory answers for all these doubts. My mind is unprepared to make any decisions or undertake any actions." From this passage we can see that Rama decides to detach from the world in an effort to understand it and his place in it better before taking any further actions. In comparing the two texts it is important to understand how the two characters view the actions they are compelled by other to undertake before engaging in them. Ethical action is the one that provides the most good or does the least harm, or, to put it another way, produces the greatest balance of good over harm. In understanding Rama's detachment, his story can be seen as an allegory to demonstrate the righteous path or dharma in Hindu theology. In contrast, Aeneas is detaching himself from life's pleasures in his pursuit of Italy is not written by Virgil to provide a theological example of the moral life and therefore does not question the gods' will in telling him to leave Carthage.
2) How does Euripedes portray the relationship between the human and divine in the Bacchae?
In Euripides' play The Bacchae, human beings and divinity are presented in a unique relationship that can be merged through rapturous group activities featuring dancing, costumes, music, wine and ecstatic release out in nature. The divine is presented to us as a primarily (but not exclusively) a female experience, one which takes women of all ages away from their homes and their responsibilities and confers on them amazingly irrational powers, beyond the traditional controls exercised by men, represented by Penthus. This contact with the divine brings these human females into harmony with wild nature (most obviously symbolized by the dancing in bare feet). In the drunken merrymaking of the Bacchic celebrations, the traditional lines of division between human beings and animals and between different groups of human beings (social and gender differences) break down and are transformed. The play stresses the beauty, energy, creativity and communal joy of the Bacchic ritual. This point is reinforced when the Messenger states, "Dionysus' powers are manifold; he gave to men the vine to cure their sorrows," the reader is able to understand how the entire play is a form of worship. By illustrating how the Bacchic ritual is an avenue to the melding of the human and the divine, the play itself would have held significant religious significance for its original intended audience. In summary, Euripedes portrays the relationship between the human and the divine as an illusory barrier than can be overcome through worship of Dionysus and the Bacchic ritual.
3) If Virgil and Aeschylus had a conversation...
He and Pentheus meet and Dionysus asserts that Zeus and Semele were married and that their child was the god Dionysus, who is honored by the Bacchae. Pentheus refuses to believe it and professes his skepticism -- yet Dionysus inflames his curiosity and Pentheus admits to desiring to see the rites performed: he is like the unbeliever who asks to see a miracle, when the person with faith is
However, Pentheus is a flawed king. He seems driven by inner needs and is fascinated as well as revolted by the changes Dionysus is bringing. He is easily swayed, and sees some aspects of the new religion as alluring as well as a threat to the status quo. Part of him wants a compromise so that the new religion will not completely fade away. He seems to find it a
It was an open protest based of selfishness and arrogance and it had no rational explanation. Pentheus is punished by death and dies from the hands of his mother who thought he was a wild beats. Such death is very symbolic as it outlines that the will of god is higher than love of mother to son and god's punishment has no mercy to sinners: "What is wisdom? Or
Euripides’ Bacchae Hubris is perhaps the greatest offense that could be given in ancient Greek society. Hubris means showing arrogance and a belief that a human being can challenge the power of the gods. Pentheus, by the standards of his society, has committed the greatest offense possible in Euripides’ Bacchae by attempting to ban the revels of Dionysius. This is not a privilege extended to him as an earthly ruler. Thus,
The bacchius ritual is an expression of another related god, who has been embraced by some as the guide of the spiritual through free expression and has been judged by others as the leader of good people to wicked excess. Though the story of Bacchus is controversial it is one that needs retelling. In Andrew Dalby's work, Bacchus a Biography the life story of Bacchus is told, from am ore
Greeks The narrator is coy about whether or not he views Alexander as Great. He makes a lot of jokes about people want to be great and starts off the lecture with a bit about Kim Kardashian -- but it's not really a fair comparison in my estimation. Fame does not equate to greatness and one can be famous for being rich, pretty and making a sex tape (and having a
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now