Verified Document

Academic Preparation And Nurses Article Review

¶ … self-psychology approach to narcissistic personality disorder: A nursing reflection. Donna M. Czuchta Romano

JOURNAL: Perspectives in Psychiatric Care, Year 2004, Volume 40, Page 20-28.

APA CITATION: Romano, D.M.C (2004). A self-psychology approach to narcissistic personality disorder: A nursing reflection. Perspectives in Psychiatric Care 40(1): 20-28.

What was the major purpose or problem described in this article?

To describe how nurses can use the self-psychology perspective to help people with narcissistic personality disorder, and to help nurses work more effectively with people with narcissistic personality disorder.

What, if any, were the hypotheses or research questions?

The research question is which psychotherapeutic interventions are most useful for nurses working with patients who have narcissistic personality disorder or similar traits. The hypothesis is that Kohut's self-psychology perspective can be effectively applied to narcissism in a nursing context.

2. What sample was used in this research?

Only one case study was used in this research, a 25-year-old university student who had been admitted to an inpatient psychiatric unit.

3. What types of methods of data collection were used?

The author does not clarify the method of data collection or even whether data was collected using systematic...

What were the results and conclusions of this research?
The author claims that applying the self-psychology framework to the case study of James, her own understanding of narcissistic personality disorder improved, allowing her to have greater empathy with the patient. Unresolved issues of self can lead to outbursts and depression, which are symptoms of underlying feelings of insecurity and vulnerability. Because narcissistic personality disorder patients can be challenging for untrained staff, it is important to help nurses understand how narcissistic personalities function and to have greater empathy in order to help the client to improve.

5. What is your opinion or reaction to this research?

The research questions the efficacy of narcissistic personality disorder as a general psychiatric condition or diagnosis. For example, the author claims that James "insisted on knowing my academic preparation" and was also "not impressed with the . . . years of academic preparation needed to work on the unit," (Romano, 2004, p. 25) as if these concerns were not legitimate or in some way indicative of narcissism. The author also fails to clarify whether the diagnosis of narcissistic personality disorder was an assumption her own, or how that diagnosis was made otherwise. Also, the research shows that there is in fact an ironic level of narcissism among nurses who dislike their…

Sources used in this document:
The author claims that applying the self-psychology framework to the case study of James, her own understanding of narcissistic personality disorder improved, allowing her to have greater empathy with the patient. Unresolved issues of self can lead to outbursts and depression, which are symptoms of underlying feelings of insecurity and vulnerability. Because narcissistic personality disorder patients can be challenging for untrained staff, it is important to help nurses understand how narcissistic personalities function and to have greater empathy in order to help the client to improve.

5. What is your opinion or reaction to this research?

The research questions the efficacy of narcissistic personality disorder as a general psychiatric condition or diagnosis. For example, the author claims that James "insisted on knowing my academic preparation" and was also "not impressed with the . . . years of academic preparation needed to work on the unit," (Romano, 2004, p. 25) as if these concerns were not legitimate or in some way indicative of narcissism. The author also fails to clarify whether the diagnosis of narcissistic personality disorder was an assumption her own, or how that diagnosis was made otherwise. Also, the research shows that there is in fact an ironic level of narcissism among nurses who dislike their credentials being challenged or questioned by clients who have a right and a responsibility to do so.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Nursing Ethics and Academic Preparation of the ADN and BSN
Words: 958 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Case Scenario: Nursing EthicsHealthcare providers are in a profound position of trust in regards to the patients in their charge. In the case scenario, an ADN nurse and a transport tech were not sufficiently watchful of an elderly patient due to complacency and the fact that they were having a personal conversation. Although a nurse with an associate�s degree (ADN) and a bachelor�s-level prepared nurse would have different levels of

Academic Nurse Educator Insights
Words: 5367 Length: 18 Document Type: Essay

Part A1. What are the qualities most needed to be a successful academic nurse educator?I have found that be a successful academic nurse educator, there are a wide range of skills that one should ideally have. One such skill is the ability to communicate with others in effective and clear formats. Without superior communication abilities, you are not likely to get your message across � which is crucial in this

Competencies Between Nurses Prepared at the Associate-Degree
Words: 888 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

competencies between nurses prepared at the associate-Degree level vs. The baccalaureate-degree level in nursing According to Moore ( 2009), Associate Degree Nurses (ADNs) are nurses with a two-year academic degree and licensed to practice nursing. Associate Nurses are prepared on the technical aspects of care giving that are necessary for their interaction with both the patients and their families in acute care settings. Their knowledge is limited to handling patients

To What Extent Can Nurses Deliver Evidence-Based Care
Words: 6819 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

nurses deliver evidence-Based care? Define main ideas within the title supported from the literature Nurse instructors confront many hurdles in the present healthcare environment. Educational methods, philosophies, and the content of curricula is required to reviewed to cater to the requirements of the professional nurses who would practice in the coming millennium. (Kessenich; Guyatt; DiCenso, 25) Evidence-based practice or EBP has currently emerged to be a remarkable attribute in nursing literature

Educating New Nurses
Words: 1284 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Competency in Entry-Level Nurses Competency In Entry Level Nurses Competency in entry-level nurses: Implications for practice Given the responsibilities shouldered by nurses, it is essential that all new nurses are competent to practice their profession when they graduate. The increased emphasis upon evidence-based practice in healthcare means that integrating this component of modern medicine into the framework of nursing education is required to produce graduates ready to face the future. Evidence-based practice is

Nursing Nurses Specialize in Various
Words: 977 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

According to the South Carolina Nurse Practice Act, the practice of nursing includes "the provision of services for compensation," and the use of "nursing judgment." Nursing judgment is clearly defined as "the logical and systematic cognitive process of identifying pertinent information and evaluating data in the clinical context in order to produce informed decisions." The South Carolina Nurse Practice Act is lengthier than either of the other two definitions provided

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now