Verified Document

Abuse And Harassment In Sports Essay

Abuses of Power Relative to Elite Athletes It is often the case that elite athletes are subjected to rigors and standards that are far beyond what is expected of the majority of the general public. There are many issues that are common among elite athletes that are known to affect either their bodies or their minds. For instance, some athletes are subjected to such high levels of discipline from either coaches or parents that the experience can be considered emotional harassment or even abuse. Coaches and parents can also use and abuse an elite athletes' bodies in many different ways. There is often a fine line between an eating disorder and attempts to maintain a body in a state of being able to achieve peak performance. Females athletes often attempt to suppress weight gain while it is more common for males to attempt to gain weight by increasing muscle weight and density. Similarly, narrow thresholds exist between training and overtraining elite athletes. However, even more extreme examples of abuse can be found in this population such as the case with sexual harassment or abuse. This study will conduct a literature review that focuses on the various forms of abuses of power that can be common among elite athletes.

Literature Review

Weight-control behavior is commonly observed in a wide range of elite sports, especially leanness sports, where control over body weight is crucial for high peak performance; nonetheless, there is only a fine line between purely functional behavior and clinically relevant eating disorders (Werner, 2013). It has been estimated that female elite athletes represent an at-risk population relative to developing eating disorders during elite sports training periods, during times of competition, and later in life. One meta-analysis on weight-control behaviors found inconsistent results that vary along the lines of factors such as age, gender, and the type of sport that is played.

There are many sports that are considered "leanness sports" in which the athletes are expected to keep their bodies trim to be able to perform the best it can. For example, it is expected that long distance runners or sprinters have extremely low levels of body fat while the same requirements do not apply to sports that are not depended upon leanness such as shot-putting, golf, or baseball. It can be difficult to detect eating disorders (EDs) in elite athletes because many people may perceive their eating behaviors as being consistent with the requirements that the sport demands or overlook weight gains or losses for similar reasons. Furthermore, elite athletes may also fail to report any ED behaviors for fear of reprisal such as not being allowed to compete or make the team (Torstveit, Rosenvinge, & Sundgot-Borgen, 2007).

Much of the research that has been conducted has focused on elite female athletes at the college level. One such study has indicated the difference between lean-sport related EDs and every other category of athletes and non-athletes. Lean-sport athletes had a higher score on body dissatisfaction, and lower actual and desired body weight than non -- lean-sport athletes and within the athlete sample, the high-risk group included 2.9% of the non -- lean-sport athletes and 25% of the lean-sport athletes (Reinking & Alexander, 2005). Given the risk factors that are evident within such groups, it is also argued that athletic trainers have the capacity and responsibility to play active roles as integral members of the health care team and facilitate early detection and treatment of eating disorders (Bonci, et al., 2008).

While coaches and trainers can undoubtedly be part of the solution, it is reasonable to suspect that they are more commonly part of the problem. In regards to some sports, coaches, trainers, and parents may unconsciously project expectations about body image to elite athletes, while in other sports, this practice is simply overt. For example, coaches may facilitate a highly competitive culture in which athletes believe that they have to use every tactic available to them to improve their bodies and/or performances. Athletes in these environments are more likely to develop unhealthy body images that lead to ED or the use of performance enhancing substances. However, in some sports that actually have classifications for different weights of athletes, such as in boxing and wrestling for example, coaches may even mandate extreme forms of weight management to ensure compliance with the intended classification. Furthermore, in all competitive sports, coaches may pressure their athletes to use unhealthy behaviors to gain any performance edge that is possible.

Although there is a common perception that sports are generally a positive influence on the development of individuals at all ages, there have been increasing concerns about elite athletics and the physical...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

Anytime there is a large distance in the gap in power held between individuals, there exists the temptation for individuals to abuse their power. Examples of this can be found throughout society and common examples include the employer/employee relationship, coach/athlete relationship, and child/parent relationship. Out of these associations there is also the potential for emotional damage to be inflicted. Emotional damage can be caused by verbal hostility, denigration, unrealistic expectations, induced fear and anxiety by threats among others (Stirling, 2011). Given the competitive nature of sports, especially with elite sports, it has been argued that it is more likely to find such abusive behaviors.
One study attempted to investigate abusive behaviors in a sample of twelve former elite athletes and these behaviors were categorized under eight headings: belittling, humiliating, shouting, scapegoating, rejecting, isolating, threatening and ignoring; the results showed that all of the participants reported experiencing belittling and shouting by their coach, nine athletes reported frequent threatening behavior, nine reported frequent humiliation, seven reported scapegoating, six reported rejection or being ignored and four reported being isolated when they were elite child athletes (Gervis & Dunn, 2004). Another interesting aspect to this study is that all participants reported that the behavior of their coaches changed and became more negative after they were identi-ed as elite performers. It is reasonable to suspect that the identification of an athlete as "elite" increases the expectations of their discipline and performance. Other findings included the participants reports of feeling stupid, worthless, upset, less con-dent, humiliated, depressed, fearful and angry as a result of the behavior of their coaches.

So far this study has illustrated methods in which authority figures may exercise their influence to facilitate unhealthy behaviors in athletes regarding their body image or performance abilities, however there are far more egregious abuses of power that are also common among elite athletes. Sexual harassment, based similarly on the concept of power dynamics, has been well-established with society in general as well as in the sporting world (Krauchek & Ranson, 585). However, the extent into which sexual harassment occurs in elite sporting seems to depend upon the location, culture, and broader context in which the harassment occurs. For example, one study carried out with over six hundred Norwegian female athletes showed no higher rates of sexual harassment in these athletes that were found in a sample of non-athlete females (Fasting, Brackenridge, & Sundgot, 2003). Therefore, such evidence suggests that sexual harassment in sports is consistent with what is found in the general population and that the power dynamics within elite sports does not amplify of prevent the rates of occurrences. However, there was also an exception noted that stated that the elite status female athletes were in fact at more risk to experience sexual harassment than the control group.

Similar results were found in studies in other locations such as the Czech Republic. The female elite athletes in this study were statically more likely to experience sexual harassment at the elite level when compared to competitive female athletes that were not considered to be competing at an elite level (Fasting, Brackenridge, & Knorre, 2010). The theory was provided that once women reach an elite level in competitive sporting environments, that these environments are traditionally male dominated which allows for the power dynamics to influence abuses of power at greater rates than found elsewhere. However, another interesting aspect to the study of the athletes in the Czech Republic also reveal that competitive, but not elite, female athletes were actually at less risk than being sexually harassed than their non-athlete counterparts. This may suggest that athletes may benefit from factors that ward off some instances of sexual harassment such as physical fitness and confidence.

Other studies seem to indicate that culture plays a role in the identification of sexual harassment, both within the sports culture that can be found within the sporting environment, but also in the culture in general. One study used a population of female athletes in Puerto Rico to determine the cultural norms that sexist behaviors are common and tolerated by athletes because they are perceived as "part of the game" as well as Hispanic-Caribbean culture in general (Rodriguez & Gill, 2011). The researchers found that verbal harassment (e.g., jokes, sexual remarks) was more expected and socially tolerable than physical harassment as well as for…

Sources used in this document:
References

Bonci, C., Bonci, L., Granger, L., Johnson, C., Malina, R., Milne, L., . . . Vanerbunt, E. (2008). National Athletic Trainers' Association Position Statement: Preventing, Detecting, and Managing Disordered Eating in Athletes. Journal of Athletic Training, 80-108.

Fasting, K., Brackenridge, C., & Knorre, N. (2010). Performance Level and Sexual Harassment Prevalence Among Female Athletes in the Czech Republic. Women in Sport & Physical Activity Journal, 26-32.

Fasting, K., Brackenridge, C., & Sundgot, B. (2003). Experiences of sexual harassment and abuse among Norwegian elite female athletes and nonathletes. Research Quarterly for Excercise and Sport, 84-97.

Gervis, M., & Dunn, N. (2004). The emotional abuse of elite child athletes by their coaches. Child Abuse Review, 215-223.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Abused and Neglected Children an
Words: 1604 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Lastly, children that are abused and neglect tend to turn to spousal abuse and battering or intimate partner violence in adult life. The studies associate intimate partner violence with exposure to neglect, abuse, and witnessing parental violence in childhood (Widom & White, 2003). Moreover, children exposed to violence at home develop the same behaviors, by becoming more aggressive, and violence. This violence and aggression is alter turned to their peers

Abused and Exploited Children Child Abuse Is
Words: 1167 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Abused and Exploited Children Child abuse is one of the most unfortunate realities of our society. In a world marked by progress, it is sad that there are still many households where young children are being subjected to violence both physical and otherwise. Child abuse is defined as any non-accidental harm or injury to a child caused by an adult. Despite the presence of numerous child protection services and agencies, children

Abuse: Effects of Abuse in Children Abuse:
Words: 1702 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Abuse: Effects of abuse in children Abuse: Effects and Impacts on Children The purpose of this paper is to research the subject of childhood abuse in view of what is suffered both immediately and on the long-term basis in relation to the child's psychological, biological and social development. Child abuse is all too common in today's world and is a subject that is almost daily splashed across the news. Physical abuse is by Merck

Abuse There Are Many Factors That Must
Words: 707 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Abuse There are many factors that must be considered when evaluating a possible abuse situation. The first thing that must be done is that all parties involved must be committed to taking the situation seriously, but also committed to acting without prejudice. Instances of abuse should neither be ignored nor falsely identified. "Because childhood molestation has been hidden for decades, our quick suspicions are well founded. But there can be backlash:

Abuse of Older Adults Abuse
Words: 2330 Length: 7 Document Type: Literature Review

Even with under reporting, approximately 5% of elder women are likely abused to the point where they seek medical attention at least annually. These women are often well-known in their communities, so when they come into the emergency room with some story of malady, they know everyone will want to about what happened. In some cases, the trend is becoming more supportive, though. As educational programs transend economic barriers;

Abuse at Home and Domestic
Words: 1600 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

This can also be done to enable one attain a restraining order against their spouse while in the course of getting a divorce. In conclusion, victims of domestic violence should be treated fairly and not discriminated against because of their gender. The system needs to make adjustment so as to be able to accommodate cases of domestic violence and abuse against men. The reason why these cases are rising is

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now