Verified Document

Abortion And Health Care Ethics Case Study

Unfortunately for Kate, a private faith-based healthcare institution in the United States generally has a legal right to refuse access to abortion based on the principle of conscientious objection (Levin, 2016; Fiala & Arthur, 2017). Conscientious objection refers to the health care provider (or in this case, the insurance provider’s) ability to refuse to take action based on religious principles or beliefs. In this case, and in all similar cases, the legal right to refuse treatment should be separated from Kate’s rights as a patient. Ultimately, Kate’s rights to ethical treatment, medical justice, and autonomy far outweigh the hospital’s right to conscientious objection. The only compromise that can possibly be reached in this case would be for the institution to refer Kate to a nearby institution that could perform the procedure. If, however, no such institution existed then Kate must be able to access the abortion services through her primary care facility. As Fiala & Arthur (2017) point out, conscientious objection in health care “should not be considered a right, but an unethical refusal to treat,” (p. 254). A doctor has professional obligations to the patient that supersede the doctor’s personal beliefs. Put another way, “introducing religion into medicine undermines...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

254). There is no medical reason to refuse the patient’s abortion.
Refusing the right to conscientious objection in no way detracts from the tremendous benefits in forging relationships between faith-based health care plans and institutions and their communities. As Levin (2016) points out, spirituality and religion play important roles in holistic care. If an institution wishes to uphold the tenets of the faith that provides financial support for its operations, then that ideal must be tempered with the overarching medical ethic that should be—but is not yet—entrenched in law. Health care is a universal human right, not a commodity. Only a commodity-driven or market-driven view of health care could conceive of conscientious objection as a more inalienable right than a patient’s right to receive treatment. If Kate lived in an area with plentiful healthcare options and a healthcare plan that covers abortion, then there would be less of an ethical dilemma. As Rosell (n.d.) presents the facts, though, Kate’s insurance provider is actually presided over and managed by a faith-based organization. This represents a potential conflict of interest. No health care insurance should categorically deny a patient access to…

Sources used in this document:

References

Fiala, C. & Arthur, J.H. (2017). There is no defense for ‘conscientious objection” in reproductive health care. European Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology and Reproductive Biology 216(2017): 254-258.

Levin, J. (2016). Partnerships between faith-based and medical sectors. Prev Med Rep 2016(4): 344-350.

Rosell, T. (n.d.). Abortion rights and/or wrongs. Center for Practical Bioethics. http://practicalbioethics.org/case-studies-abortion-rights-and-or-wrongs


Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Ethics in Health Care Today,
Words: 891 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

(Evangelium Vitae, encyclical letter on the value and the inviolability of Human Life) What the Pope was referring to was the debate over the ethics of stem cell research, and cloning and to other related issues that deal with experimenting with human embryos and fetuses. In fact, today, embryos can be created in a Petri dish, through in vitro fertilization, and these embryos are used for stem cell extraction and

Ethics for Health Care Provider
Words: 638 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

The ethical dilemma will then be solved rationally by taking steps to serve as many people as possible, both to build awareness for the healing powers of the practice, and therefore grow my business and to serve those in greatest need. It is for this reason that the only way that I can see to further both goals is to develop a system of sliding scale payment for those in

Ethics in Health Care Euthanasia
Words: 688 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

The tragedy is that, often those who wish most for the blessing of children are deprived of this privilege for whatever reason. An even greater charity is that, when the long-awaited life finally does arrive, it is damaged so badly that medical science can do very little but alleviate its suffering to some extent. The question is whether such a child should be kept alive, and whether the quality

Healthcare Ethics - Gardasil Healthcare
Words: 344 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

Assuming all those issues are addressed, mandatory HPV vaccination may be a good idea for all children and the option should be made available to adults and funded, at least in part, by government funds and profit limitations on vaccine sales. REFERENCES Allen, Terry, J. Merck's Murky Dealings: HPV Vaccine Lobby Backfires; Corpwatch (March 7, 2008). Retrieved March 26, 2008, from Corpwatch: Holding Corporations Accountable website, at http://www.corpwatch.org/article.php?id=14401 Pharmaceutical News (March 5,

Ethics in Healthcare
Words: 969 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Heal Sometimes What personal, cultural, and spiritual values contribute to your worldview and philosophy of nursing? How do these values shape or influence your nursing practice? The personal values that contribute to my worldview and philosophy of nursing include: the ability to empathize with patients / their families, solving the needs of stakeholders and creating a positive atmosphere for everyone. Cultural values are based upon working with people and numerous demographics.

Racism and Ethics in Healthcare the United
Words: 652 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Racism and Ethics in Healthcare The United States achieved significant advances in the second half of the 20th century to reduce the prevalence and impact of racism on minorities, after failing to address it adequately in the hundred years in between the formal emancipation of the African slaves in 1865 and the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Edwards, Wattenberg, & Lineberry, 2009). During that time, systemic racism was evident throughout American

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now