Unfortunately for Kate, a private faith-based healthcare institution in the United States generally has a legal right to refuse access to abortion based on the principle of conscientious objection (Levin, 2016; Fiala & Arthur, 2017). Conscientious objection refers to the health care provider (or in this case, the insurance provider’s) ability to refuse to take action based on religious principles or beliefs. In this case, and in all similar cases, the legal right to refuse treatment should be separated from Kate’s rights as a patient. Ultimately, Kate’s rights to ethical treatment, medical justice, and autonomy far outweigh the hospital’s right to conscientious objection. The only compromise that can possibly be reached in this case would be for the institution to refer Kate to a nearby institution that could perform the procedure. If, however, no such institution existed then Kate must be able to access the abortion services through her primary care facility. As Fiala & Arthur (2017) point out, conscientious objection in health care “should not be considered a right, but an unethical refusal to treat,” (p. 254). A doctor has professional obligations to the patient that supersede the doctor’s personal beliefs. Put another way, “introducing religion into medicine undermines...
254). There is no medical reason to refuse the patient’s abortion.References
Fiala, C. & Arthur, J.H. (2017). There is no defense for ‘conscientious objection” in reproductive health care. European Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology and Reproductive Biology 216(2017): 254-258.
Levin, J. (2016). Partnerships between faith-based and medical sectors. Prev Med Rep 2016(4): 344-350.
Rosell, T. (n.d.). Abortion rights and/or wrongs. Center for Practical Bioethics. http://practicalbioethics.org/case-studies-abortion-rights-and-or-wrongs
Many of the chapters relate to medical research as well as medical procedures, with the informed consent issue in particular affecting both human beings involved in medical research and those facing a medical crisis and wanting to now what their treatment will entail. Throughout, the authors present ways of thinking about these ethical issues and also encourage medical personnel to consider these matters and to have a means for making
Healthcare Health Care Law Ethics Health care over the years has become one of the most important debates to take place within the United States of America. This fact holds particularly true for the major part of the Obama Administrations whose New Health Care policies has been criticized extremely (Zhi Qu, 2010). The world, however, is still waiting for the final curtain to rise and to witness the climax which would be
Conclusion Prejudice and ethical/leadership issues with healthcare are nothing new but the fight to keep those standards and ethics on an even keel and prevent racism, bigotry and predudice of any sort including based on class, money, political ideology, nationalism, and so forth should be stomped out and eviscerated whenever it can be. People are people and should treated with dignity and respect regardless of their race, gender, beliefs and so
(Evangelium Vitae, encyclical letter on the value and the inviolability of Human Life) What the Pope was referring to was the debate over the ethics of stem cell research, and cloning and to other related issues that deal with experimenting with human embryos and fetuses. In fact, today, embryos can be created in a Petri dish, through in vitro fertilization, and these embryos are used for stem cell extraction and
Futile medical care is the ongoing provision of medical treatment or care to a patient who does not show any hope of recovery. It is either that his condition is not curable and therefore the treatment that he is receiving is of no benefit. The common examples of these are that a surgeon is performing a surgery on a patient with terminal cancer. Patients who have terminal cancer have
Discussion Response: Abortion don't think abortion should be ethical dilemma for 'Americans,' but only for the American women contemplating an abortion. No woman (or at least, hardly any woman) considers having an abortion lightly. It is a personal, not a political decision. No government can make a decision that a woman must go through the pain, stress, and emotional and physical trauma of an unwanted pregnancy. But no father can,
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now