Documentary Response: “A Death in St. Augustine”
The nationwide and then global calls for racial justice erupted following the murder of George Floyd on May 25, 2020 by Minneapolis police officers underscore the public’s overwhelmingly negative reaction when law enforcement authorities, long held in high esteem and respect, are suspected of committing violent crimes themselves. Although
The purpose of this paper is to provide a systematic review of the PBS documentary video,” A Death in St. Augustine” to identify and describe the major issue addressed by this documentary and the primary individuals and groups that were involved. In addition, a description of the several biases identified in the documentary, what was liked and disliked about it and what was learned from watching it are followed by a discussion concerning issues in the film that were unconvincing and anomalous. Finally, a discussion concerning whether the documentary changed this writer’s mind about any aspect of the subject addressed and if this documentary would be recommended to others is followed by a summary of the research and key findings concerning the documentary, “A Death in St. Augustine” in the conclusion.
Review and Discussion
Identify and describe in detail the major issue addressed by the documentary
The major issue that is addressed by the documentary concerns the special treatment afforded to members of the law enforcement community by their peers when they become involved in the criminal justice system following the death of Michelle O’Connell on September 2, 2010. Although O’Connell was a single mother, her family emphasized that she loved her daughter, Alexis, and even worked up to three jobs to support her. The point is made repeatedly by family members and friends that O’Connell was “planning for her future not her end” despite her death being ruled a suicide by the medical examiner. For instance, her employer, Teresa Woodward, stated outright that, “Michelle’s life was not spiraling down. She was happy with the changes she was making.”
One of the most important changes O’Connell was trying to make in her life was seeking an end to her stormy relationship with Deputy Banks, but there are numerous signs that she was contemplating suicide as evinced by a stream of cryptic messages that indicated she was planning on taking her own life (i.e., the several texts to her sister stating, in part, “Promise me one thing. Lexi will be happy and always have a good life [and] that no matter what, Lexi will always be safe and loved.” Conversely, there were also significant indications that O’Connell was murdered by her physically abusive and controlling boyfriend, Deputy Banks.
Identify the primary individuals/groups involved in the documentary
The two primary individuals involved in the documentary were Michelle O’Connell, the deceased, a full-time daycare worker who had recently been promoted and Sheriff Deputy Jeremy Banks, the main suspect in her death. The key group that was involved in the documentary was Deputy Banks’ employer, the St. Johns County Sheriff’s Office in St. Augustine, Florida.
Identify the biases on the part of the filmmaker that you were able to identify in the documentary
Like other Frontline presentations, this documentary is prefaced with selected excerpts from the video. In...…aspect of the subject that it presents? What information, argument or persuasive technique caused you to change your mind?
While the producers did provide some evidence that indicated O’Connell took her own life, the multiple claims that Deputy Banks was responsible for her death were piled on to the point where members of the audience likely concluded he was the murderer without looking any further and I was nearly, but not completely, drawn into this perspective myself.
If the filmmakers were to ask how the film could be improved, what would you tell them?
The producers should recruited Deputy Banks to comment on the case, just as they did with the other stakeholders in this case, rather than just use his prerecorded telephone calls and testimony.
If someone asked you whether you would recommend this film, how would you respond?
If people were interested in learning more about law enforcement’s unwritten but powerful code of silence, I would recommend this documentary; however, if they were just looking for some solid entertainment, I would recommend an alternative.
Conclusion
The untimely death of Michelle O’Connell on September 2, 2010 that resulted in an investigation by the St. Johns County Sheriff’s Office in St. Augustine, Florida officially determined that she died of a self-inflicted gunshot wound. The research showed that there was abundant circumstantial evidence that implicated O’Connell’s boyfriend, Deputy Sheriff Jeremy Banks, but this evidence was disregarded throughout the investigation. The several instances of wrongdoing and errors made by investigators did nothing to change the outcome of the investigation, though, and the official cause of O’Connell’s death remains a suicide…
Ken Burns' Documentary: The National Parks -- America's Best Idea The reputation Ken Burns has acquired over the years is a glowing, highly lauded reputation, and for good reason. His use of history, video and well-written narrative has won awards and has entertained and informed all those who have come into contact with his documentaries. The documentary to be critiqued and reviewed in this paper is The National Parks -- America's
Photographers: Exploring the World Through Their Lenses Documentary Photography: a depiction of the real world by a photographer whose intent is to communicate something of importance -- to make a comment -- that will be understood by the viewer. (Documentary Photography 12) When the camera was invented, photographers learned that they no longer needed oil paint and brushes to capture a scene or a person. On film, they could now record the
Babies Documentary It is always interesting to see how another culture lives. As a person who lives in a modern country, it is hard to fathom living in any other way. You take for granted the modern conveniences all around you. Now, it is more difficult imagining how to raise a baby in an environment unfamiliar to your own. "Babies" does a great job showing this distinction. The best thing the
The PBS Frontline documentary Ghosts of Rwanda shows how music enhances the medium of documentary film. Judicious scoring enables the story of the Rwandan genocide to unfold, even though the film is heavily editorialized. The film opens with the dramatic statement of truth, that 800,000 people were “slaughtered by their own government” in Rwanda. The Hutus and the Tutsis were supposed to sign a peace agreement. That agreement was to
Child Abuse and Neglect Intervention Child Abuse Neglect & Intervention The documentary Family Affair was written, narrated, and filmed by Chico Colvard ("IMDB," 2010). The film is focused on a retrospective look at events that took place in his family over a period of several decades. The four siblings featured in the film are the children of a black veteran named Elijah Colvard, Jr., and his wife, a white German Jewish woman
Documentary Part 1 1. This film follows the daily workings of retailers in the dying bricks and mortar retail centers of an urban area. It pays particular attention to the piling inventory and the slowing sales. It shows the emptiness of stores and alludes to the ominous presence of e-commerce and Amazon hanging over the heads of these bricks and mortar retailers. 2. This will be an informative documentary that will include aspects
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now