Verified Document

2001 The New York Times Magazine Published Essay

¶ … 2001 the New York Times Magazine published an editorial by Andrew Sullivan entitled "Who's Being Shut Out of All the World War II Glory?" In it, Sullivan asked why historians (both in Washington and Hollywood) have ignored the contributions of gay soldiers, and links this to the current "don't ask, don't tell" policy that was resulting in an upsurge in sexuality-related discharges from the military. Shortly after this article was released, David Horowitz wrote a response article entitled "Why Gays Shouldn't Serve." Though Horowitz claimed that his article was designed to refute the "p.c. thinking" of Sullivan's article by arguing for "pragmatic" counterarguments, in reality he does not argue particularly about any of Sullivan's ideas of recognizing the past roles of gay individuals or relating those past experiences to the decisions of today. Rather he creates a practical argument which suggests that allowing homosexuals officially in the military would be counterproductive for the military's long-term goals. Though Sullivan and Horowitz have very different conclusions, and significantly different methods, they do have some elements in common which could theoretically allow the two authors (were the right arguments made) come to some agreement. Sullivan's argument suggests that there are monuments (both of the film and structure varieties) to the most diverse sorts of warriors, such as African-Americans, women, and even Japanese-Americans....

It seems that America today is recognizing the sacrifices of all those who fought for the country, except for gay individuals. He points out that there were many gays in combat in the Second World War, so much so that the military experienced a sort of "gay revolution" during this period. He suggests that it is time the public recognize the contributions made by homosexuals. This need for recognition he links to the number of gays removed from the military under the recent policy changes. He does not precisely argue for an inclusive military, but allows that argument to suggest itself from the egalitarian messages of asking for more recognition of past service and pointing out inequalities in today's treatment. Overall the message of his editorial is more about egalitarian recognition and treatment of gays than a cohesive call for policy change.
This is very different from Horowitz' position. Horowitz actually acknowledges that there should be more recognition for former homosexual soldiers. He also says that allowing openly gay people in the army would be bad not because homosexuals deserve to be discriminated against, but for the very simple reason that if there were homosexuals in the army that would introduce a factor of sex and individuality. This would, he then suggests, culminate in unreliable soldiers who might make poor decisions to protect their lovers. He, oddly, backs this up by evidence regarding how few…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

America's International Relations Americanization and Anti-Americanism...
Words: 3764 Length: 11 Document Type: Term Paper

Pictures on the news of American flags being burned seem to appear more often than they used to. Perhaps my generation just isn't used to having our nation criticized to the extent that it has been since our response to September 11; we all know there have been anti-American protests in the past, that flags have been burned and protests against certain American military endeavors waged. Anti-Americanism has many definitions

Media Ethics
Words: 4981 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

Media in America as the Fourth Estate: From Watergate to the Present During the 1970's, the role of the media changed from simply reporting the news to revealing serious political scandals (Waisbord, 2001). The media's role during Watergate was viewed as the mirror that reflected the most that journalism could offer to democracy: holding powers accountable for their actions. This became a trend in the American media and journalism had

Research Assistance Companies Including the
Words: 1444 Length: 5 Document Type: White Paper

Students benefit from the commodity element of research assistance companies because they are the benefactors of the product. They are given opportunities to choose the best company and the companies work hard to attract their business by providing the best possible materials for them to draw from in their research. In short the industry has exploded into a healthy commodity market and through that market the students using the services are

Ethics and Friedman and Accounting
Words: 1788 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Accounting and Ethics The stakeholder model should be implemented in combination with Friedman's shareholder model In his article, "The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase its Profits" published in 1970's reputed "The New York Times" Magazine, Friedman debates in favor of precisely what the article's title states. He alleged that corporate social responsibility (CSR) was a diversion from the economic rudiments of business that helps in capitalization of profits and yields

Corporate Philanthropy on the Developjment
Words: 8566 Length: 31 Document Type: Term Paper

" (McKinsey & Company and CECP, 2008, p.3) Fine, Kirkpatrick, Parker, and Watson (2008) in the work entitled: "Social Media: Philanthropy in a Connected World" states that today's companies can no longer "ignore the influence of social media and the opportunity to "deepen engagement with employees and customers alike through philanthropy efforts capitalizing on new media channels." (p.5) Fine, Kirkpatrick, Parker, and Watson (2008) additionally state that some companies have "already

Marketing of Atkins Diet Products in Europe Vs. The US
Words: 7184 Length: 18 Document Type: Term Paper

Marketing of Atkins Diet Products in Europe vs. The U.S. Background on Atkins Diet (A) Who was Robert Atkins? Atkins was born in Columbus, in the state of Ohio in the year 1930. After having joined the University of Michigan, he graduated with a Major in Pre-meds, after which Atkins received his Medical Degree in the year 1955 from the Cornell University Medical School. By the year 1959, he had finished his residencies

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now