Verified Document

11th Grade Froggybottom Class The Questions You Term Paper

¶ … 11th Grade Froggybottom Class The questions you asked me about have no easy answers. Philosophers, economists, revolutionaries, and social leaders have all been debating the answers for centuries, and as usual many of our politicians don't even know the first thing about the issues involved! Though the questions seem simple, they are actually rooted in the most basic questions of human existence: what is the "good life" and how can we live it? All the world's religions have tried to answer that question, and still no one knows the real answer. I can tell you my opinion, and I can tell you what famous thinkers and politicians have said, but in the end these are questions you need to figure out on you own. Think about them carefully, because your own personal answers will help you define your political and economic position wisely.

Your first question asked, "What is in the public interest? That is, what is the goal we should be trying to reach?" It was a good idea to ask this question first; the answer to this question changes the answer to all your other questions. Some people say that the public interest is to protect the rights and freedoms of each individual to the maximum. This is one of the ideas that inspired many of our founding fathers, and thinkers of their day and age like Locke and Mill (influential political philosophers). Locke said that the public interest was defined by something called "natural law" which believed people had an innate right to their property and their choices. Mill also tended to believe this, but he added that the most important thing was the greatest happiness and welfare, and that the greatest public good would be served when people had property and free choice. Both philosophers believed that intelligent self-interest would guide people to make the best choices for themselves and for society. The idea of the

It suggests that when the government doesn't interfere with personal property and business decisions (such as wages, prices and qualities and quantities of goods, and so forth) that things will still work out for the best. It is believed that consumer demand will guide what goods are produced and how much they cost, and that employees desire for employment will be balanced by their self-interest not to work for corporations that hurt them. No one will work for employers who don't pay enough, and no one will buy goods that are too expensive. Competition will keep quality high and costs down. Free market advocates say that the forces of competition and self-interest will create maximum efficiency and economic growth, by assuring that only needed things are created with the minimum necessary cost and price. This theory believes that if human rights to property and to their free choice is protected, all other good things will come naturally. The problem with relying on free choice and natural rights to provide for the good of all is that sometimes self-interest may not lead to the greater good, but instead cause harm to others. The benefit is that it allows people to be free, and minimizes the degree to which (generally corrupted) government runs the lives of citizens.
However, there are other theories about what is the most important part of the public interests. Some people say what is important to the public is safety and well-being, and that if free will and property rights…

Sources used in this document:
However, there are other theories about what is the most important part of the public interests. Some people say what is important to the public is safety and well-being, and that if free will and property rights aren't providing this then the government needs to assure them. These theories might say that the government should set minimum standards for products and for employee safety, and that if it looks like important business are going to go bankrupt the government should help them so that they can continue to produce for the economy and provide jobs. The public good is defined in terms of job security and quality, and the economic welfare of companies and employees. This theory is in many ways older than free market theory -- even back in the days of the ancient Egyptians, the government set prices for grain and exchange, and subsidized and controlled farmer choices. In other ways, this theory is more modern. Minimum wage laws and other laws protecting employees came into recent existence because business was abusing workers with low wages and unsafe environments. Laws protecting product or service quality also became more common when reformers become upset with poor quality products (such as foods with poison in them, or radioactive alarm clocks, or quack doctors selling snake oil). The problem with trying to manage society in this way is that no government is so all-knowing that it can regulate every aspect of the market without error, and moreover a government which totally protects its citizens from their own choices essentially enslaves them. The benefit with this system, of course, is that it can protect people from their own stupidity and the selfishness of others.

Today, many people talk about how important it is to have a free market where the government doesn't interfere with business; at the same time most of these people do believe that the government should take some steps to protect the public welfare. There is no country today where a truly free market exists, and no country where the market is totally controlled for the good of the people. Deciding which part of the public welfare (whether that be freedom of choice for all or positive outcomes for most) is most important is very difficult, and a personal decision. Most people try to balance these two ideals in order to reach the overall ideal: the true happiness and welfare of society. If you want more information on free market and economic theory, John Kilcullen of Macquarie University has an excellent page about the subject at http://www.humanities.mq.edu.au/Ockham/y67s26.html.

As this complicated first answer has probably shown you, the answer to the second question depends on your personal answer to the first question. I think I have already answered the first part of the question: "How can the free market, driven by greed and financial profits, ever lead to that goal?" The answer is that if all people are equally greedy and profit-oriented, then all people will essentially protect their own financial well-being and so all transactions will be beneficial in some way to both parties or else they would not proceed. If the government does not get involved, self-interest will guide actions to be mutually beneficial for all. The second part of your question, "Why is it good, and when is it appropriate, for government to stay out of the marketplace?" is simple. It is best for the government to stay out of business when the nature of the business relationships in question are such that all parties involved stand to profit in some way (either financially or by receiving products or services they need). For example, Presidential hopeful Kerry suggests allowing market forces
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Greed Economics Milton Friedman Video on "Greed:"
Words: 718 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

GREED Economics Milton Friedman video on "Greed:" Is greed really necessary? The University of Chicago economist Milton Freidman was famous for his endorsement of the capitalist system and the concept that 'greed is good.' Friedman believed that capitalism was the source of all positive human development and intellectual ferment. Capitalism had improved the lot of the individual worker, even though capitalism had occasionally been unfair in its allocation of resources and did not

Greed and Glory on Wall
Words: 1727 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

However the infighting at LBKB had made the company hard to sell (pp. 179-181). Revenues were going down, but Glucksman refused to cut costs, something potential buyers noted. The infighting was the topic of a Fortune article, and many believed that Peterson had leaked it (p. 184). Many at LBKB feared that the article would lower the company's sale price. Even several years after these events, after Shearson/American Express bought

Greed and Tragedy in Human
Words: 586 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

The plate that is brought through the door there... will be the turntable on which she will pose..." This passage from the plate shows how the woman is likened to the lowly animal, chicken, to demonstrate Hogarth's lowly perception of how Tom had wrongly conducted himself as a wealthy man. Tom's eventual downfall is shown in the last two plates of "Rake's Progress," wherein he eventually lands in prison for

Greed in Society
Words: 2231 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

greed in our society, its deteriorating impact on our society and ways to curtail the same. The Works Cited five sources in MLA format. Greed in Society Greed! Greed! Greed! This is all that we observe around us in business dealings, in institutions including those that are established to impart quality education, in movies, in television shows, in every part of the corporate world as well as in day-to-day routine work.

Greed -- Grievance Debate Is
Words: 1594 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

When this is not the case, either the state is too weak to exercise such a power, or the discontent is disproportional. In either case, it is an issue of "grievance" because it underlines the shortcomings of the state. In the first situation, it lacks legitimacy and means to exercise legitimate power; in the second case, it is unable to offer the basic principles of social security and thus

Greed Is Good or That Conspicuous Consumption
Words: 540 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

greed is good or that conspicuous consumption is a desirable trait seems to be gaining increasing acceptance in Western and certainly American popular culture. At the same time, there do appear to be sub-currents of reactionary movements towards lower levels of consumption, and more subtle means of consuming what must be consumed. Examining different designers in light of various theories regarding why people consume, what they consume, and how

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now